HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Is It 'Morally Disturbing' When Charter Schools Skim Highly Motivated Families?

Views:940
@ReasonVids

Robert Pondiscio's provocative new book, How the Other Half Learns, challenges supporters and opponents of education reform.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at Apple Podcasts: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.

----------------


At the 2000 Republican National Convention, the country got one of its first glimpses of a new type of public charter school. The claim was that with enough rigor, devotion, and "no excuses" discipline, such schools could close the achievement gap between poor minorities and their wealthy white counterparts. The shining example was the Knowledge Is Power Program, or KIPP. Skeptics pointed out that the families showing up at KIPP and other no-excuses charters were self-selected.

In 2006, a combative former New York City council member named Eva Moskowitz co-founded a new charter school network with the same approach. Success Academy was KIPP on steroids, trouncing many public schools in wealthy neighborhoods on the annual state exams. 

Enter the education writer and former public school teacher Robert Pondiscio, who spent a year embedded at a Success Academy in an effort to figure out just how these schools do it. In his widely praised new book, How The Other Half Learns, Pondiscio reports that the critics were right: Not only is the very act of applying to the lottery self-selecting, but Success Academy makes such rigorous demands on parents that it disproportionately retains only the most highly motivated families. 

The result is that an applicant's chances of winning a seat at a Success school in its annual high stakes lottery aren't as competitive as many had claimed. Pondiscio found that there are about six applicants for every spot. However, because so many families drop out, the chances of getting offered a spot are actually closer to 50 percent.

But for those that make the commitment, the impact is absolutely transformative. And he argues that these kids deserve the same access to excellent public schools that upper-middle-class parents finagle for their children, even if it means leaving the rest of their communities behind.

Reason's Nick Gillespie sat down with Pondiscio to discuss why he believes motivated families deserve the opportunity to exit their traditional district public schools—which a New York Times reviewer called "a morally disturbing conclusion" to his "unsparingly honest book"—and his challenge to both supporters and detractors of the school reform movement.

Produced, shot, and written by Jim Epstein; interview edited by Ian Keyser; additional camera by Kevin Alexander; archival research by Regan Taylor.

Photos:

Parent at Success Academy Rally
Johnny Milano/Polaris/Newscom

Eva Moskowitz
Credit: RICHARD B. LEVINE/Newscom

Eva Moskowitz
Bryan Smith/ZUMA Press/Newscom

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
charter schools
,
education
,
new york city
,
success academy
,
eva moskowitz
    Thumbnail for Remy: Horrifying Tweets Resurface1:47
    Remy: Horrifying Tweets Resurface
    ReasonVids
    788 views
    Thumbnail for Licensing Gone Wild: Oregon Bureaucrats Shut Down  82-Year-Old Barber1:31
    Licensing Gone Wild: Oregon Bureaucrats Shut Down 82-Year-Old Barber
    IJvids
    875 views
    Thumbnail for GTA 5, but if I say "cop" then the cops try to kill me | DougDoug15:00
    GTA 5, but if I say "cop" then the cops try to kill me | DougDoug
    invidious
    289 views
    Thumbnail for Chink rink2:46
    Chink rink
    AOUisgay
    1405 views
    Thumbnail for 3 Reasons to Build the Keystone XL Pipeline2:31
    3 Reasons to Build the Keystone XL Pipeline
    ReasonVids
    891 views
    Thumbnail for Nanny of the Month for July 2010: San Fran Soda Banner Mayor Newsom1:06
    Nanny of the Month for July 2010: San Fran Soda Banner Mayor Newsom
    ReasonVids
    849 views
    Thumbnail for How To Bleed & Maintain Hydraulic Floor Jack -Jonny DIY | Jonny DIY5:28
    How To Bleed & Maintain Hydraulic Floor Jack -Jonny DIY | Jonny DIY
    invidious
    359 views
    Thumbnail for The Go Fund Me Crisis - It’s Not What You Think! | AwakenWithJP7:14
    The Go Fund Me Crisis - It’s Not What You Think! | AwakenWithJP
    invidious
    373 views
    Thumbnail for Tyrone harassing a young jewish couple on the Eastern Front, 1942 (colorised)0:15
    Tyrone harassing a young jewish couple on the Eastern Front, 1942 (colorised)
    AOU
    1103 views
    Thumbnail for Earmarks: The Alien Menace5:38
    Earmarks: The Alien Menace
    ReasonVids
    864 views
    Thumbnail for The Stupid Party in Action4:57
    The Stupid Party in Action
    AmericanRenaissance
    1307 views
    Thumbnail for All Kinds of Fat | Popp Culture26:32
    All Kinds of Fat | Popp Culture
    Terrence Popp
    1650 views
    Thumbnail for Who Wants to Live Forever? Dr. Stephen Coles on the Secrets of the World's Oldest People12:20
    Who Wants to Live Forever? Dr. Stephen Coles on the Secrets of the World's Oldest People
    ReasonVids
    872 views
    Thumbnail for Ivermectin to fight RSV? - The Highwire14:56
    Ivermectin to fight RSV? - The Highwire
    bestofsaidit
    765 views
    Thumbnail for Are Drone Strikes and Kill Lists The New Normal? Q&A w Newsweek's Eli Lake6:28
    Are Drone Strikes and Kill Lists The New Normal? Q&A w Newsweek's Eli Lake
    ReasonVids
    1013 views
    Thumbnail for SIGIL II - E6M3: Twilight Desolation (Ultra-Violence 100%) | decino10:24
    SIGIL II - E6M3: Twilight Desolation (Ultra-Violence 100%) | decino
    invidious
    361 views
    Thumbnail for „Тешки Муабети“ со Мечка и Миќо, епизода 157, сезона 5, 17.04.2025 | Инфомакс2:03:20
    „Тешки Муабети“ со Мечка и Миќо, епизода 157, сезона 5, 17.04.2025 | Инфомакс
    invidious
    57 views
    Thumbnail for YouTube - Branch Education - The Engineering Puzzle of Storing Trillions of Bits in your Smartphone, SSD (2020)7:34
    YouTube - Branch Education - The Engineering Puzzle of Storing Trillions of Bits in your Smartphone, SSD (2020)
    ArcturianDeathTrap
    27 views
    Thumbnail for The Calling56:35
    The Calling
    bestofvoatxyz
    737 views
    Thumbnail for literally morons1:28
    literally morons
    bestofupgoat
    491 views
    Thumbnail for 'Your Tears Are Delicious and Your Parties Will Die,' Says Libertarian Party Chair Nicholas Sarwark10:48
    'Your Tears Are Delicious and Your Parties Will Die,' Says Libertarian Party Chair Nicholas Sarwark
    ReasonVids
    949 views
    Thumbnail for How @bushcuck married a slant (in his headcannon) 1:00
    How @bushcuck married a slant (in his headcannon)
    bestofupgoat
    275 views
    Thumbnail for You were the one thing in my way❤️ #explore #ترندالسعوديه #ترند #foryou #funny #اكسبلور | FROXY TEAM0:13
    You were the one thing in my way❤️ #explore #ترندالسعوديه #ترند #foryou #funny #اكسبلور | FROXY TEAM
    invidious
    103 views
    Thumbnail for This Simulator Was Built to Stop Cops From Shooting Dogs2:53
    This Simulator Was Built to Stop Cops From Shooting Dogs
    ReasonVids
    937 views
    Thumbnail for Pajeet trucker driving Britbong style.0:13
    Pajeet trucker driving Britbong style.
    bestofupgoat
    481 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
charter schools
,
education
,
new york city
,
success academy
,
eva moskowitz
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle