HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

5 Reasons Not to Feed the Russian Troll Hysteria

Views:1054
@ReasonVids

The conventional story is that Russian trolls infiltrated the 2016 election with fake social media ads. But according to details from a February 2018 indictment of those trolls, it's unclear how much of an effect they actually had.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a



Federal prosecutors have filed charges against 13 Russians who allegedly sought to "sow discord in the U.S. political system" through social media posts, ads, and videos falsely presented as the work of Americans. After the indictment was unveiled in February, The New York Times reported that Donald Trump's "admirers and detractors" both agree with him that "the Russians intended to sow chaos" and "have succeeded beyond their wildest dreams." But Reason Senior Editor Jacob Sullum says a close look at the indictment tells a different story.

Here are "5 Reasons Not to Feed the Russian Troll Hysteria:"

1) Russian trolling was a drop in the bucket.

According to the indictment, Russian trolls associated with the so-called Internet Research Agency (IRA) in Saint Petersburg spent "thousands of U.S. dollars every month" on social media ads, which is a minuscule fraction of online ad revenue. Facebook alone reported advertising revenue of $9.16 billion in the second quarter of 2017. The Russians are said to be responsible for producing 43 hours of YouTube videos, but that doesn't seem like very much when you consider that 400 hours of content are uploaded to the site every minute.

2) Russian trolls were not very sophisticated.

Russian trolls supposedly had the Machiavellian know-how to infiltrate the American political system, but their social media posts don't look very sophisticated. The posts often featured broken English and puzzling topic choices. A post promoting a "buff" Bernie Sanders coloring book, for instance, noted that "the coloring is something that suits for all people." Another post showed Jesus and Satan in an arm wrestling match under this caption: "SATAN: IF I WIN CLINTON WINS! JESUS: NOT IF I CAN HELP IT!" The post generated very few clicks and shares.

3) Russian troll rallies apparently did not attract many participants.

The indictment makes much of pro-Trump and anti-Clinton rallies instigated by Russian trolls, but it does not say how many people participated. The New York Times reported that a Russian-organized rally in Texas opposing Shariah law attracted a dozen people. An anti-immigrant, anti-Muslim rally in Idaho drew four people. Attendance at other rallies was similarly sparse.

4) Russian trolling probably didn't change anyone's mind.

Broken English aside, the social media posts were not qualitatively different from content created by American activists, and they seemed to be aimed mainly at reinforcing pre-existing beliefs and divisions. The Russians might have gotten a few Trump supporters to show up at anti-Clinton rallies, but that does not mean they had an impact on the election.

5) Russian troll hysteria depicts free speech as a kind of violence.

The Justice Department describes the messages posted by Russians pretending to be Americans as "information warfare." But while the posts may have been sophomoric, inaccurate, and illogical, that does not distinguish them from most of what passes for online political discussion among actual Americans. The integrity of civic discourse does not depend on verifying the citizenship of people who participate in it. It depends on the ability to weigh what they say, checking it against our own values and information from other sources. If voters cannot do that, maybe democracy is doomed. But if so, it's not the Russians' fault.

Produced and edited by Paul Detrick. Camera by Alex Manning.

Ghost Dance by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
Source: http://incompetech.com/music/royalty-free/index.html?isrc=USUAN1100573

Artist: http://incompetech.com/

Russian Folk Dance by Sam Bikov is licensed under a Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/)
Source: http://freemusicarchive.org/music/SamBikov/SamBikov/RussianFolkDance
Artist: http://freemusicarchive.org/music/SamBikov/

russian trolls
,
election
,
2016
,
president trump
,
make america great again
,
donald trump
,
hillary clinton
,
clinton
,
muller
,
russia
    Thumbnail for Stossel: China's Freedom-Crushing 'Social Credit Score'4:52
    Stossel: China's Freedom-Crushing 'Social Credit Score'
    ReasonVids
    865 views
    Thumbnail for From Ayn Rand to the iPod: Journalist Chris Lehmann on "Rich People Things"7:27
    From Ayn Rand to the iPod: Journalist Chris Lehmann on "Rich People Things"
    ReasonVids
    997 views
    Thumbnail for @master_foo can't poo in the loo0:20
    @master_foo can't poo in the loo
    bestofupgoat
    197 views
    Thumbnail for M'eeeeeeeeh! (baby goat sounds)0:11
    M'eeeeeeeeh! (baby goat sounds)
    bestofupgoat
    245 views
    Thumbnail for 30 Ways to Say DNC1:01
    30 Ways to Say DNC
    ReasonVids
    892 views
    Thumbnail for IJ Attorney Jeff Rowes Discusses Health Care Challenge on MSNBC3:54
    IJ Attorney Jeff Rowes Discusses Health Care Challenge on MSNBC
    IJvids
    980 views
    Thumbnail for The point isn’t that it’s impressive. The point is that there’s an attack helicopter buzzing your neighborhood.1:12
    The point isn’t that it’s impressive. The point is that there’s an attack helicopter buzzing your neighborhood.
    bestofanarchocapitalism
    3181 views
    Thumbnail for Google Glass: Privacy, Journalism, and the Dawn of Wearable Technology6:53
    Google Glass: Privacy, Journalism, and the Dawn of Wearable Technology
    ReasonVids
    897 views
    Thumbnail for Graphene Hydroxide in the mRNA Vaccine Vial: Assassination of Dr. Andreas Noack17:02
    Graphene Hydroxide in the mRNA Vaccine Vial: Assassination of Dr. Andreas Noack
    AOU
    1316 views
    Thumbnail for Hitler was right: Blues clues edition0:17
    Hitler was right: Blues clues edition
    bestofvoatxyz
    1247 views
    Thumbnail for UCLA Professor Abigail Saguy on What's Wrong with Fat?7:08
    UCLA Professor Abigail Saguy on What's Wrong with Fat?
    ReasonVids
    905 views
    Thumbnail for Talking Supernatural with Sandman | Grunt Speak Highlights6:22
    Talking Supernatural with Sandman | Grunt Speak Highlights
    Terrence Popp
    1616 views
    Thumbnail for Jew Free World (Tears For Fears: Everybody Wants to Rule the World)4:19
    Jew Free World (Tears For Fears: Everybody Wants to Rule the World)
    judenhass
    3195 views
    Thumbnail for my mom just got deported - WAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH0:46
    my mom just got deported - WAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH
    bestofupgoat
    96 views
    Thumbnail for Wheat, Weed, and ObamaCare: How the Commerce Clause Made Congress All-Powerful10:06
    Wheat, Weed, and ObamaCare: How the Commerce Clause Made Congress All-Powerful
    ReasonVids
    1002 views
    Thumbnail for Making a post when suddenly @conspirologist appears in it's true form 0:11
    Making a post when suddenly @conspirologist appears in it's true form
    bestofupgoat
    414 views
    Thumbnail for "How can we rebuild trust?" ~ WEF1:37
    "How can we rebuild trust?" ~ WEF
    bestofupgoat
    416 views
    Thumbnail for How to Safely Watch The Eclipse or CNN1:29
    How to Safely Watch The Eclipse or CNN
    ReasonVids
    830 views
    Thumbnail for Would Today's ACLU Defend the Speech Rights of Nazis?5:38
    Would Today's ACLU Defend the Speech Rights of Nazis?
    ReasonVids
    930 views
    Thumbnail for Duke Nukem Forever: Walkthrough - Part 1 [Chapter 22] - Blowin' The Dam (Gameplay) [Xbox 360, PS3] | theRadBrad12:54
    Duke Nukem Forever: Walkthrough - Part 1 [Chapter 22] - Blowin' The Dam (Gameplay) [Xbox 360, PS3] | theRadBrad
    invidious
    334 views
    Thumbnail for Passenger princess?? More like passenger prisoner | FunnyMemeSpot0:11
    Passenger princess?? More like passenger prisoner | FunnyMemeSpot
    invidious
    112 views
    Thumbnail for The 5 Dumbest Laws Restricting the Sale of Booze3:42
    The 5 Dumbest Laws Restricting the Sale of Booze
    ReasonVids
    939 views
    Thumbnail for Did US Force Qatar to Expel Hamas Leaders? | Vantage with Palki Sharma | Firstpost5:49
    Did US Force Qatar to Expel Hamas Leaders? | Vantage with Palki Sharma | Firstpost
    invidious
    119 views
    Thumbnail for Jimmy Song: Bitcoin, Universities, and Christian Theology49:23
    Jimmy Song: Bitcoin, Universities, and Christian Theology
    ReasonVids
    883 views

points

Permalink
Reply
russian trolls
,
election
,
2016
,
president trump
,
make america great again
,
donald trump
,
hillary clinton
,
clinton
,
muller
,
russia
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle