HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Tax Breaks for Game Makers = EPIC FAIL

Views:954
@ReasonVids

"Video games are the most heavily subsidized industry in America," says Calvin H. Johnson, professor of law at the University of Texas at Austin. "Tax ordinarily reduces your return by a third and this is an industry which instead of paying tax on a third of their profits doubles their profits. That is weird."

Last year, video game companies earned over $20 billion in revenue last year in the U.S.—and with expansion into mobile and tablet devices those profits are expected to grow. The promise of a consistent multi-billion dollar revenue stream makes gaming an alluring industry for cash-strapped states who are hungry to get a piece of the action.

Many states have gone so far as to offer generous tax incentives to companies willing to set up shop within their borders. Texas is leading the way in this approach and is aggressively targeting gaming companies with sweetheart tax deals.

Under the Texas Moving Image Industry Incentive Program, the Lone Star state has set aside $95 million in funds over the next two years toward grants for both filmmakers and developers—making it the largest incentive program in the nation. And so far it seems to be working. Texas is now only second to California when it comes to video game employment.

But are these subsidies creating enough economic growth to justify their cost? Johnson, who specializes in tax law, thinks that video game makers are enjoying a tax deal that's too good to be true.

"If you're going to double the rate of return for federal subsidies then you really ought to have a good justification that the public is getting a benefit equal to that incredibly intense incentive," Johnson states. "And I must admit, I'm not convinced that the unemployed son spending 17 hours in the basement of his mother's house working on his Doom 3 is making a grand contribution."

Tax breaks for video games are historically rooted in credits for research and development that were established in the mid-1950s to encourage investment in innovation. In 1969—three years before the first home video games were commercially released—Congress expanded the tax credit to include software development. Another research and design credit was added in 1981 to keep America's auto industry competitive with Japan.

Because of the uniqueness of the video game industry, which extends across the realms of entertainment, online retail, and software development, gaming companies can combine these tax breaks in ways other entertainment businesses cannot.

In addition to these federal breaks, supporters of state incentive programs say these subsidies are necessary to keep America competitive in the global economy. They argue that without them, gaming jobs could be outsourced to nations with friendlier corporate tax rates. (The U.S. corporate tax rate is currently the highest in the world.)

But several studies have called into question the effectiveness of these programs—a 2013 analysis done by the Tax Foundation found that film tax incentives only generate 30 cents in tax revenue for every dollar spent. And though Texas is strengthening their gaming and film incentives, more states —like Kansas, Missouri and Connecticut—are scaling back or eliminating their programs altogether.

Johnson welcomes the contraction as he feels that these subsidies benefit the gaming industry at the expense of other businesses. He argues that over-subsidizing video game companies could not only be harming overall economic growth, but innovation in game design that these credits are intended to encourage.

"There isn't any reason we should double the rate of return for those gamers because you're subsidizing games that people don't really want that much. You're wasting stuff because things are twice as cheap and they ought to be twice as profitable. The market ought to decide these things."

About 5 minutes.

Produced by Alexis Garcia. Camera by Paul Detrick.

Go to http://reason.com/reasontv/2014/05/06/tax-breaks-for-game-makers-epic-fail for downloadable versions and subscribe to ReasonTV's YouTube Channel to receive notifications when new material goes live.

video game (industry)
,
video game development (industry)
,
gaming
,
texas
,
subsidies
,
incentives
,
film
,
tax
,
corporate tax
,
calvin
,
johnson
,
calvin johnson
,
grand theft auto: vice city (video game)
,
doom 3 (video game)
,
tax break
,
games
    Thumbnail for Why League of Legends Rules3:57
    Why League of Legends Rules
    ReasonVids
    964 views
    Thumbnail for 2014 Midterms: The Very Best (and Worst!) Election Outcomes1:51
    2014 Midterms: The Very Best (and Worst!) Election Outcomes
    ReasonVids
    910 views
    Thumbnail for 24/7 Classic Christmas Music with Fireplace 🎅🏼🎄 Instrumental Christmas Piano & Relaxing Fire Sounds | Cozy Cottage1:00
    24/7 Classic Christmas Music with Fireplace 🎅🏼🎄 Instrumental Christmas Piano & Relaxing Fire Sounds | Cozy Cottage
    invidious
    316 views
    Thumbnail for Why Obamacare is "the Most Important Case" in 50 Years: Q&A with Timothy Sandefur of PLF7:12
    Why Obamacare is "the Most Important Case" in 50 Years: Q&A with Timothy Sandefur of PLF
    ReasonVids
    872 views
    Thumbnail for How can I talk politics with my earnest lefty friends without them screaming at me?2:35
    How can I talk politics with my earnest lefty friends without them screaming at me?
    ReasonVids
    971 views
    Thumbnail for It's got errything! James Bond music... classic car chase... and some creative editing thrown for the lulz0:14
    It's got errything! James Bond music... classic car chase... and some creative editing thrown for the lulz
    bestofupgoat
    502 views
    Thumbnail for Blame Biden for High Gas Prices | ReasonTV3:53
    Blame Biden for High Gas Prices | ReasonTV
    invidious
    375 views
    Thumbnail for Born to Be Alive0:22
    Born to Be Alive
    AOU
    1232 views
    Thumbnail for Party In The CIA (Parody of "Party In The U.S.A." by Miley Cyrus) (Official 4K Video) | alyankovicVEVO2:58
    Party In The CIA (Parody of "Party In The U.S.A." by Miley Cyrus) (Official 4K Video) | alyankovicVEVO
    invidious
    389 views
    Thumbnail for Enter Reason Media Awards NOW to Win $16,000!0:30
    Enter Reason Media Awards NOW to Win $16,000!
    ReasonVids
    923 views
    Thumbnail for Don't Hate the Trans-Pacific Partnership Because It's Imperfect10:22
    Don't Hate the Trans-Pacific Partnership Because It's Imperfect
    ReasonVids
    845 views
    Thumbnail for What a fine day to be giving out fines1:09
    What a fine day to be giving out fines
    publicfreakouts
    2111 views
    Thumbnail for What about Sweden, which seems like a great place to live?2:34
    What about Sweden, which seems like a great place to live?
    ReasonVids
    839 views
    Thumbnail for Seattle's $15 Minimum Wage is Hurting the Workers It's Intending to Help2:20
    Seattle's $15 Minimum Wage is Hurting the Workers It's Intending to Help
    ReasonVids
    939 views
    Thumbnail for Licensing Gone Wild: Oregon Bureaucrats Shut Down  82-Year-Old Barber1:31
    Licensing Gone Wild: Oregon Bureaucrats Shut Down 82-Year-Old Barber
    IJvids
    867 views
    Thumbnail for Vandalia School Board Had No Idea What Hit Them When This Lady Was Given The Mic, September 20, 20216:47
    Vandalia School Board Had No Idea What Hit Them When This Lady Was Given The Mic, September 20, 2021
    AOU
    1451 views
    Thumbnail for Those Who Know The Least About Bitcoin Want to Ban it the Most: Reason-Rupe Poll April 20141:13
    Those Who Know The Least About Bitcoin Want to Ban it the Most: Reason-Rupe Poll April 2014
    ReasonVids
    893 views
    Thumbnail for Kmele Foster on Why He Opposes Cancel Culture and the Anti-Capitalist Side of Black Lives Matter1:19:44
    Kmele Foster on Why He Opposes Cancel Culture and the Anti-Capitalist Side of Black Lives Matter
    ReasonVids
    790 views
    Thumbnail for Origami engineering2:36
    Origami engineering
    bestofpoal
    997 views
    Thumbnail for Chink defends multiculturalism0:11
    Chink defends multiculturalism
    bestofupgoat
    420 views
    Thumbnail for When The Relationship Between Track And Decoration Is Seamless - Kick or Clutch Ep. 182 | OwlPlague10:38
    When The Relationship Between Track And Decoration Is Seamless - Kick or Clutch Ep. 182 | OwlPlague
    invidious
    346 views
    Thumbnail for FECAL FINGER BEAR (OWEN BENJAMIN) | BARRICADE GARAGE2:15
    FECAL FINGER BEAR (OWEN BENJAMIN) | BARRICADE GARAGE
    invidious
    117 views
    Thumbnail for Detroit Threat Management: #Anarchy in Detroit, Part II3:06
    Detroit Threat Management: #Anarchy in Detroit, Part II
    ReasonVids
    1084 views
    Thumbnail for How A Spinal Tap Works 😨 | Zack D. Films0:26
    How A Spinal Tap Works 😨 | Zack D. Films
    invidious
    98 views

points

Permalink
Reply
video game (industry)
,
video game development (industry)
,
gaming
,
texas
,
subsidies
,
incentives
,
film
,
tax
,
corporate tax
,
calvin
,
johnson
,
calvin johnson
,
grand theft auto: vice city (video game)
,
doom 3 (video game)
,
tax break
,
games
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle