HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Why Obamacare is "the Most Important Case" in 50 Years: Q&A with Timothy Sandefur of PLF

Views:925
@ReasonVids

Does the fate of a federal government with limited powers rest in the hands of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia? And if so, will he rule against broad federal powers (as he did in the Gonzales case) or in favor of the feds' right to regulate just about anything (as he did in the Raich case)?

The Supreme Court case over The Affordable Care Act, a.k.a. Obamacare, "is certainly the most important case on the reach of federal power in 50 years" says attorney and legal scholar Timothy Sandefur of the Pacific Legal Foundation. "The constitutional principle of where is the line drawn on federal power - that's a matter that our children and grandchildren will have to live with."

The ruling will come sometime in early June, predicts Sandefur, who tells Reason.tv that the Affordable Care Act raises mutliple constitutional issues: Can part of the law be struck down and other upheld? Is the "individual mandate," which forces all Americans to purchase insurance as a condition of simply being alive, legal? Does the law's massive expansion of Medicaid shred the right of states to govern their own finances?

"If the Court says yes, the federal government can compel you to buy health insurance," Sandefur tells Reason's Nick Gillespie, "then it would be a matter of politics whether Congress chooses to force you to buy a Chevy Volt or buy whatever else they think is good for society or the economy or whatever else a politician thinks is a good idea." What's more, Obamacare's Medicaid provisions, which call for an ever-increasing number of citizens to be covered by the nation's health care program for the poor, deny states the right to opt out and still receive federal money. "The federal government has never done something like this before," explains Sandefur, "where it expanded eligibility requirements so dramatically."

Sandefur, who is attending the Supreme Court's oral arguments, maintains the blog Freespace and is the author of The Right to Earn a Living: Economic Freedom and the Law. He is a principal attorney at the Pacific Legal Foundation, a public-interest law firm headquartered in Sacramento, California that works for economic freedom and individual rights. PLF filed several amicus briefs against The Affordable Care Act and represented the plaintiffs in Sackett v. EPA, the just-decided Supreme Court case which ruled that compliance orders by the federal Environmental Protection Agency can be challenged in court by affected landowners. The case is being hailed as a major victory for property rights.

Watch a Reason.tv video about Sackett v. EPA here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=40iHXAOjJ3U

Approximately 7 minutes.

Shot by Jim Epstein and Meredith Bragg, and edited by Epstein.

Go to http://Reason.tv for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason.tv's YouTube Channel to receive automatic updates when new material goes live.

obamacare
,
supreme court
,
the affordable care act
,
individual mandate
,
scotus
,
nick gillespie
,
timothy sandefur
,
pacific legal foundation
,
sacket v. epa
,
libertarian
,
libertarianism
,
reason.tv
,
reason magazine
,
reason foundation
    Thumbnail for "Constitutional Thunderdome": Day Two of Obamacare Oral Arguments3:03
    "Constitutional Thunderdome": Day Two of Obamacare Oral Arguments
    ReasonVids
    937 views
    Thumbnail for US School lunches might get healthier… but there’s a catch | Evan Edinger15:35
    US School lunches might get healthier… but there’s a catch | Evan Edinger
    invidious
    454 views
    Thumbnail for J6 - Diversity Officer Aquilino Gonell (under oath):  “I was bleeding from both hands, [had] a maimed foot, hit on the head, sprayed with pepper and bear spray, beaten, punched, pushed, pulled, and assaulted."2:12
    J6 - Diversity Officer Aquilino Gonell (under oath): “I was bleeding from both hands, [had] a maimed foot, hit on the head, sprayed with pepper and bear spray, beaten, punched, pushed, pulled, and assaulted."
    AOUisgay
    447 views
    Thumbnail for Chill Music 24/7 Live Stream • Relaxing Deep House Chill Out Music Mix by We Are Diamond | We Are Diamond1:00
    Chill Music 24/7 Live Stream • Relaxing Deep House Chill Out Music Mix by We Are Diamond | We Are Diamond
    invidious
    302 views
    Thumbnail for ⚽ Copa Libertadores 2025: Botafogo vs. Universidad de Chile | CooperativaFM3:04:51
    ⚽ Copa Libertadores 2025: Botafogo vs. Universidad de Chile | CooperativaFM
    invidious
    71 views
    Thumbnail for Resume Gaps | Mike Rafi - Personal Injury Lawyer0:50
    Resume Gaps | Mike Rafi - Personal Injury Lawyer
    invidious
    177 views
    Thumbnail for BITTER AND FRUSTRATED: DC TAXPAYERS SOUND OFF3:47
    BITTER AND FRUSTRATED: DC TAXPAYERS SOUND OFF
    ReasonVids
    1078 views
    Thumbnail for 🔴 CURIOUS GEORGE 24/7 MARATHON! 🐵 Livestream for Kids ✨ Cartoons for Children 🐵 | Peacock jr1:00
    🔴 CURIOUS GEORGE 24/7 MARATHON! 🐵 Livestream for Kids ✨ Cartoons for Children 🐵 | Peacock jr
    invidious
    401 views
    Thumbnail for Real-time cloth simulation in UE5 and uDraper plugins | hirokazu yokohara2:45
    Real-time cloth simulation in UE5 and uDraper plugins | hirokazu yokohara
    invidious
    538 views
    Thumbnail for Edward Snowden's Lawyer on the Government's War on Whistleblowers12:56
    Edward Snowden's Lawyer on the Government's War on Whistleblowers
    ReasonVids
    923 views
    Thumbnail for Drum Teacher Reaction: Tool - Rosetta Stoned // JOHNKEW Drum Cover (2021 Reaction) | Andrew Rooney Drums16:50
    Drum Teacher Reaction: Tool - Rosetta Stoned // JOHNKEW Drum Cover (2021 Reaction) | Andrew Rooney Drums
    invidious
    40 views
    Thumbnail for Brilliant Take! 🔥 #usa #israel #palestine #politics #news #canada #congress #uk #europe #australia | Breezy Politics1:00
    Brilliant Take! 🔥 #usa #israel #palestine #politics #news #canada #congress #uk #europe #australia | Breezy Politics
    invidious
    157 views
    Thumbnail for How I scaled a website to 10 million users (web-servers & databases, high load, and performance) | TechLead13:04
    How I scaled a website to 10 million users (web-servers & databases, high load, and performance) | TechLead
    invidious
    476 views
    Thumbnail for I found a 9,863,827,097 mile high water slide in GTA 5 | GrayStillPlays15:05
    I found a 9,863,827,097 mile high water slide in GTA 5 | GrayStillPlays
    invidious
    575 views
    Thumbnail for Roblox Squid Game fail 😭 | John Casterline0:33
    Roblox Squid Game fail 😭 | John Casterline
    invidious
    178 views
    Thumbnail for That one unemployed mate on a random thursday: | FunnyMemeSpot0:13
    That one unemployed mate on a random thursday: | FunnyMemeSpot
    invidious
    185 views
    Thumbnail for Jimmy Carter's funeral | CBS6 Albany1:43:08
    Jimmy Carter's funeral | CBS6 Albany
    invidious
    130 views
    Thumbnail for [권순표의 뉴스하이킥] 대통령실, 명품백 정보비공개 이유? 국가 중대 이익을 현저히 해칠 우려 - 헬마우스, 노영희, 신현영, 변상욱, 오윤혜, 김영우 | MBC 라디오 시사2:15:20
    [권순표의 뉴스하이킥] 대통령실, 명품백 정보비공개 이유? 국가 중대 이익을 현저히 해칠 우려 - 헬마우스, 노영희, 신현영, 변상욱, 오윤혜, 김영우 | MBC 라디오 시사
    invidious
    341 views
    Thumbnail for Kerajaan Tidak Pernah Sembunyikan Dokumen Titah Adendum | Buletin Utama, 8 Januari 2025 | Buletin TV359:58
    Kerajaan Tidak Pernah Sembunyikan Dokumen Titah Adendum | Buletin Utama, 8 Januari 2025 | Buletin TV3
    invidious
    146 views
    Thumbnail for A simply stunning team goal 🤤 | Tottenham Hotspur0:36
    A simply stunning team goal 🤤 | Tottenham Hotspur
    invidious
    178 views
    Thumbnail for Los Angeles firefighters rescue man who was trying to save dog from rushing water | ABC News0:35
    Los Angeles firefighters rescue man who was trying to save dog from rushing water | ABC News
    invidious
    341 views
    Thumbnail for Type O Negative – Bloody Kisses (Full Album) [Metal March Listening Party] | RHINO1:03:03
    Type O Negative – Bloody Kisses (Full Album) [Metal March Listening Party] | RHINO
    invidious
    299 views
    Thumbnail for Dost #abrazkhan  #shorts | Abrazkhan - ck910:44
    Dost #abrazkhan #shorts | Abrazkhan - ck91
    invidious
    121 views

points

Permalink
Reply
obamacare
,
supreme court
,
the affordable care act
,
individual mandate
,
scotus
,
nick gillespie
,
timothy sandefur
,
pacific legal foundation
,
sacket v. epa
,
libertarian
,
libertarianism
,
reason.tv
,
reason magazine
,
reason foundation
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle