HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Elizabeth Warren's Plan To Cancel Student Debt Helps the Well-Off

Views: 891
Elizabeth Warren likes to say she's a champion of the little guy. But she recently announced a major policy proposal to provide more than a trillion dollars in aid. Much of that money would disproportionately benefit the relatively well off and well connected.


Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv

Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at Apple Podcasts: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.


The idea is to eliminate student debt up to $50,000 for people with households incomes under $100,000, and more limited debt cancellation for households between $100,000 and $250,000 a year. By her own estimates, the full plan, which also includes funds for Pell Grants and historically black colleges, would cost about $1.25 trillion.

But the nature of college attendance and student loans means that Warren's loan forgiveness plan is actually a massive giveaway to the relatively well-off.

Only about a third of people over 25 have a college degree, making them a comparatively elite group, whose elite status is reinforced by, among other things, the connections they make while at college.

College graduates earn about $1 million more during their lifetimes than non-college graduates, according to a Georgetown University study. A separate study from Pew found college graduates typically earn about $17,500 more annually than people who only had high school degrees.

College graduates aren't, for the most part, super rich. But generally speaking, they are far more comfortable than the majority who lack such degrees. And while many of the people who would benefit from the plan currently have modest incomes, that's partly because many of them are young people with relatively high future earnings potential. This is a plan that would spend taxpayer money to benefit them.

Warren's defenders might respond that it's still a downward transfer, since the whole thing will be paid for by a new tax on the super wealthy.

There are, however, a few problems with using a wealth tax as a financing mechanism.

The first is that the tax might not be constitutional. Even if it is, another problem is that it's likely to raise far less money than projected. That's why most countries that have tried wealth taxes over the last two decades have abandoned them.

The third, as the The Washington Examiner's Philip Klein points out that, is that Warren has also suggested that this same revenue tax could be used to help pay for a whole slew of other progressive policy ideas. Those include Medicare for All, the Green New Deal, and subsidized child care, which, all together, would cost tens of trillions of dollars—far more than even the most generous wealth tax would raise.

Ultimately, what Warren wants to do is tax the wealthy to help the merely well off, rather than prioritize programs that help the truly needy. Warren isn't helping the little guy—she's helping the folks already on top stay that way.

Music: Pomp and Circumstance, by Edward Elgar. Performed by Eastern Wind Symphony. Path to Follow - Jingle Punks https://youtu.be/CEek1N4wSHA


Produced by Todd Krainin. Written and narrated by Peter Suderman.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Judge Andrew Napolitano: President Trump Obstructed15:29
Judge Andrew Napolitano: President Trump Obstructed
ReasonVids
877 views
Thumbnail for Dr David Martin - European Parliament - International COVID Summit III 5-3-2321:27
Dr David Martin - European Parliament - International COVID Summit III 5-3-23
AOUisgay
482 views
Thumbnail for Airbnb and Its Enemies: Who's Afraid of a $10-a-Night Sofa?5:48
Airbnb and Its Enemies: Who's Afraid of a $10-a-Night Sofa?
ReasonVids
944 views
Thumbnail for The MOST private browser (2021) | Naomi Brockwell: NBTV8:14
The MOST private browser (2021) | Naomi Brockwell: NBTV
invidious
341 views
Thumbnail for Mark Bauerlein - Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader?3:22
Mark Bauerlein - Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader?
ReasonVids
830 views
Thumbnail for Anyone else collect Vance cards? 0:26
Anyone else collect Vance cards?
bestofupgoat
63 views
Thumbnail for How a Great School is Breaking the Cycle of Poverty in America's Poorest City5:37
How a Great School is Breaking the Cycle of Poverty in America's Poorest City
ReasonVids
970 views
Thumbnail for Story time village the simpsons1:26
Story time village the simpsons
clips
880 views
Thumbnail for Most realistic Biden robot at Disney Hall of Presidents0:57
Most realistic Biden robot at Disney Hall of Presidents
AOU
1294 views
Thumbnail for Gridlock: Hell on Wheels by Drew Carey and Reason.tv8:59
Gridlock: Hell on Wheels by Drew Carey and Reason.tv
ReasonVids
898 views
Thumbnail for A Joe Biden (War On) Christmas1:37
A Joe Biden (War On) Christmas
ReasonVids
835 views
Thumbnail for Just in case you think Rep Massie is exaggerating, or you're a lvl 1 newfag 1:13
Just in case you think Rep Massie is exaggerating, or you're a lvl 1 newfag
bestofupgoat
391 views
Thumbnail for Timothy P. Carney on "Obamanomics": Crony Capitalism as Progressive Reform8:52
Timothy P. Carney on "Obamanomics": Crony Capitalism as Progressive Reform
ReasonVids
892 views
Thumbnail for De-wig at every opportunity 0:59
De-wig at every opportunity
bestofvoatxyz
385 views
Thumbnail for The Secret Scam of Streetcars5:05
The Secret Scam of Streetcars
ReasonVids
837 views
Thumbnail for How NYC's Landmarks Act Bulldozed the Future3:30
How NYC's Landmarks Act Bulldozed the Future
ReasonVids
1003 views
Thumbnail for Jared Taylor: 'Building a World Brotherhood of Europeans'29:45
Jared Taylor: 'Building a World Brotherhood of Europeans'
AmericanRenaissance
1640 views
Thumbnail for Nadler has dual citizenship with Israel1:14
Nadler has dual citizenship with Israel
bestofvoatxyz
822 views
Thumbnail for E-Cigarettes and the Law: NJOY's Craig Weiss on Proposed Regulations6:59
E-Cigarettes and the Law: NJOY's Craig Weiss on Proposed Regulations
ReasonVids
866 views
Thumbnail for In Defense of Roe3:58
In Defense of Roe
ReasonVids
838 views
Thumbnail for Kennedy Goes on Howard Stern: A Reading by Scott Adsit12:23
Kennedy Goes on Howard Stern: A Reading by Scott Adsit
ReasonVids
908 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian, reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv, higher education, taxation, peter suderman
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle