HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Who Owns Your Life Story? Free Speech Rules (Episode 4)

Views:969
@ReasonVids

Do people need your permission to write about you? What if they want to make a movie about you, or a YouTube video, blog post, whatever? Who owns your name, likeness, voice, and life story? Here's the answer, in four rules.

Well, two rules, one who-knows, and one piece of advice.

Rule 1: People can write books about you, make movies about you, or write articles about you, all without violating your so-called "right of publicity." That right is often defined as an exclusive right to commercial use of your name, likeness, voice, and other "attributes of identity"; but it does not apply to biography, fiction, news coverage, and so on.

The First Amendment protects people's ability to write about others. That's what newspapers do, both about famous people and about ordinary ones who happen to draw the newspaper's attention. It's also why we see unauthorized biographies, whether in print or on the screen, and fiction with real characters, like Midnight in Paris and Forrest Gump. And that's true even though those items are distributed for money.

So, you don't really own your name or likeness or life story, in the sense of having exclusive rights over it. Neither does your biographer. No-one owns it, because everyone is free to use it, at least when they're commenting about you and your life.

Rule 2: People generally can't use your name, likeness, or voice in commercial advertising. In some situations, such use can also violate trademark law, because consumers might be confused into thinking you're endorsing the product.

Exception: If people are advertising books about you or newspapers that mention you, it's OK for them to use your name or picture in doing so. Such ads are treated like the underlying book or newspaper, and are therefore allowed.

This right to prevent the use of a name or likeness in advertising applies not just to living people, but also to recently dead ones. How recent? Depends on the state where the people were living when they died. Some states cover people for 50 years after their death, some more, some less.

Rule 3: When it comes to merchandising, different state and federal courts have reached different results about this, often inconsistent results. Indeed, the Missouri Supreme Court held that people can sue over use of their name in comic books, though courts have consistently rejected this theory for other kinds of books. But this may be an outlier decision; other judges have criticized it, and the California Supreme Court has rejected such a lawsuit, in a comic book case very similar to the Missouri one.

It's also unsettled whether athletes' names and statistics can be used in the big business of sports gaming, whether fantasy sports leagues or sports video games. The Supreme Court could resolve whether and when the First Amendment protects such less traditional communications media against right of publicity claims, but the Justices haven't done that yet.

And a practical note: Even though creators may have the right to freely use people's names in, say, movies about them, it might still be a good idea to get their agreement, if possible.

While filmmakers and authors routinely win right of publicity lawsuits filed against them, there's still some risk and a lot of expense. Safer for the creators to pay some money, if they have it and the person is willing to take it.

Second, biographers can be liable for defamation, if they get some significant facts wrong about a living person.

Third, working with subjects (or their heirs) can give authors access to facts they otherwise wouldn't know.

Fourth, getting the subject's permission can prevent bad publicity, and can enlist the subject into helping promote the work.

All this might be impossible, for instance if a biography would be critical of its subject, so that the subject will refuse to cooperate. In that case, the authors may want to stand on their First Amendment rights, see Rule 1. But if cooperation is possible, it's a good idea.

Finally, all we say here has to do with American law. These days, much of the revenue for movies comes from other countries—and the rules in those countries might be different. Better safe than sorry, many producers and publishers say.


Written by Eugene Volokh, who is a First Amendment law professor at UCLA.
Produced and edited by Austin Bragg, who is not.


----------------

Music: "Lobby Time," by Kevin MacLeod (Incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Harvard Caves to Student Mob6:30
    Stossel: Harvard Caves to Student Mob
    ReasonVids
    998 views
    Thumbnail for Flemming Rose Against the Worldwide Suppression of Speech34:18
    Flemming Rose Against the Worldwide Suppression of Speech
    ReasonVids
    921 views
    Thumbnail for Bubbles4:08
    Bubbles
    videobox
    1999 views
    Thumbnail for Jay Greene on Making Schools Better4:53
    Jay Greene on Making Schools Better
    ReasonVids
    909 views
    Thumbnail for How Libertarian Politician Jeff Hewitt Won in California4:55
    How Libertarian Politician Jeff Hewitt Won in California
    ReasonVids
    891 views
    Thumbnail for Lanny Friedlander: The Eccentric Genius Who Created Reason Magazine8:31
    Lanny Friedlander: The Eccentric Genius Who Created Reason Magazine
    ReasonVids
    941 views
    Thumbnail for Why Capitalism is Better than Socialism8:04
    Why Capitalism is Better than Socialism
    ReasonVids
    933 views
    Thumbnail for Occupy Thanksgiving: A Message of Hope, Redemption, and Dada0:27
    Occupy Thanksgiving: A Message of Hope, Redemption, and Dada
    ReasonVids
    1026 views
    Thumbnail for IJ's Robert McNamara discusses the DC Tours case on Fox2:10
    IJ's Robert McNamara discusses the DC Tours case on Fox
    IJvids
    933 views
    Thumbnail for Should Facebook and Twitter Censor Themselves? A Debate.1:26:12
    Should Facebook and Twitter Censor Themselves? A Debate.
    ReasonVids
    872 views
    Thumbnail for The Inmates Are Running Venezuela’s Prisons. They've Created Autonomous Micro-Dictatorships.16:04
    The Inmates Are Running Venezuela’s Prisons. They've Created Autonomous Micro-Dictatorships.
    ReasonVids
    936 views
    Thumbnail for FUCK YOU BLOODY BENCHOD BASTARD0:38
    FUCK YOU BLOODY BENCHOD BASTARD
    bestofupgoat
    443 views
    Thumbnail for Hey Donald: You Can Be a Citizen of America *and* a Citizen of the World!2:31
    Hey Donald: You Can Be a Citizen of America *and* a Citizen of the World!
    ReasonVids
    1051 views
    Thumbnail for DSP's Pigroach Diet #1 - Mexican Fries (wait, wuat?)7:17
    DSP's Pigroach Diet #1 - Mexican Fries (wait, wuat?)
    memology101
    1349 views
    Thumbnail for Doom II - MAP32: Grosse (Nightmare! 100% Secrets + Items) | decino3:59
    Doom II - MAP32: Grosse (Nightmare! 100% Secrets + Items) | decino
    invidious
    307 views
    Thumbnail for ten minutes of nigger fragility 10:41
    ten minutes of nigger fragility
    bestofupgoat
    515 views
    Thumbnail for Baby Murder Riots: LA edition0:47
    Baby Murder Riots: LA edition
    bestofvoatxyz
    761 views
    Thumbnail for What Happens When I Put My Arm In A Vacuum Chamber? Will It Explode? | The Action Lab7:33
    What Happens When I Put My Arm In A Vacuum Chamber? Will It Explode? | The Action Lab
    science.topic
    120 views
    Thumbnail for Nina Jankowicz could have been a multi-platinum Wizard Rock star—but when duty called, she devoted her talents to eradicating cyber-sexism in Belarus. A modern day Glenn Miller.0:42
    Nina Jankowicz could have been a multi-platinum Wizard Rock star—but when duty called, she devoted her talents to eradicating cyber-sexism in Belarus. A modern day Glenn Miller.
    bestofvoatxyz
    973 views
    Thumbnail for Craig Shirley: How Pearl Harbor - and December 1941 - Made America a Global Power8:09
    Craig Shirley: How Pearl Harbor - and December 1941 - Made America a Global Power
    ReasonVids
    987 views
    Thumbnail for The Libertarian Roots of Police Reform: Q&A with Radley Balko51:21
    The Libertarian Roots of Police Reform: Q&A with Radley Balko
    ReasonVids
    1009 views
    Thumbnail for When San Francisco Stopped Prosecuting Drug Users, Violent Crime Went Down3:33
    When San Francisco Stopped Prosecuting Drug Users, Violent Crime Went Down
    ReasonVids
    925 views
    Thumbnail for Smash Karts10:00
    Smash Karts
    stumble_bro
    495 views
    Thumbnail for Beauty and the beastnigger0:40
    Beauty and the beastnigger
    moviegoats
    571 views
    Thumbnail for 21: Is It Time to Lower the Drinking Age?9:51
    21: Is It Time to Lower the Drinking Age?
    ReasonVids
    874 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle