HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Fake News and the First Amendment: Free Speech Rules (Episode 3)

Views:1047
@ReasonVids

Can the law punish deliberate lies about public matters? Well, it depends. Here are the Six Rules of Fake News:

  1. False statements that tend to damage reputations can generally be punished.

Of course, the law doesn’t call this “fake news”—it calls it “defamation.”

Written defamation is called “libel.” Spoken defamation is called “slander.” Radio and TV broadcasts are usually considered libel, except in Georgia, where they’re called “defamacast.”

Intentional lies about particular people or companies can lead to massive damages awards, including punitive damages. They can lead even to criminal punishment in states that still have “criminal libel laws,” though such prosecutions are pretty rare.

Negligent mistakes about particular people or companies can also lead to damages awards, unless the statements are about public officials or so-called “public figures”—people or businesses who are quite famous or influential.

And in many states, some falsehoods about particular people can lead to damages even if they don’t harm a person’s reputation.

  1. Deliberate lies aimed at getting money can be punished as fraud.

That’s true even for political, religious, or charitable fundraising, which is usually protected by the First Amendment. If you try to get people to donate money to your group, but lie about what it’s doing, you could be sued or even prosecuted.

  1. Deliberate lies as well as honest mistakes in commercial advertising can be punished.

Commercial advertising is generally less protected than other speech, especially when it comes to false statements.

  1. Lies about the government can’t be punished.

The federal government can’t sue you for defamation even if you deliberately lie about something the government has done. Cities or public universities can’t sue for defamation either.


  1. Lies about big picture topics generally can’t be punished, either.

So a law banning Flat-Earth Theory, for instance, would be unconstitutional. Same for laws that try to punish falsehoods about, say, climate change or vaccinations. In these “broad areas,” the Justices say, “any attempt by the state to penalize purportedly false speech would present a grave and unacceptable danger of suppressing truthful speech”

  1. Lies about more specific topics are more complicated.

In 2012, the Court struck down the Stolen Valor Act, which criminalized falsely claiming that you’ve won a military medal; but while six Justices agreed on that result, the reasoning was split into two groups.

Four Justices said that most noncommercial lies are broadly protected by the First Amendment, unless they fit into a few categories such as defamation or fraud or perjury.

But two Justices concluded that lies are only kinda, sorta, sometimes protected. They held that restrictions on such lies “warrant neither near-automatic condemnation ... nor near-automatic approval.”

So whether any particular kind of lie is unprotected was left to be decided case by case, without much guidance from the Supreme Court.

Since it generally takes five Justices out of the nine to set a conclusive precedent, it’s hard to say what’s allowed and what’s not. You’d think a question that’s this fundamental would have been resolved by now, but, uh...no.

So, for instance, some states ban deliberate lies in election campaigns. Is that constitutional?

Not if it’s applied to statements about the government, or about social science, or about history. But what if it’s more specific, like a candidate claiming endorsements that he didn’t actually get? That’s a harder call, and lower courts disagree on whether broad bans on lies in election campaigns are constitutional.

Or what about hoaxes that suck up police resources? Back in 2009, Andrew Scott Haley posted YouTube videos in which he purported to be a serial killer and gave clues to his supposed killings. He was eventually prosecuted for making false statements that he knew would come to the attention of law enforcement and trigger an investigation. The Georgia Supreme Court held that the First Amendment didn’t protect such a hoax. The U.S. Supreme Court refused to consider the case, leaving that issue unresolved outside Georgia.

Written by Eugene Volokh, a First Amendment law professor at UCLA.
Produced and edited by Austin Bragg, who is not.

This is the third episode of Free Speech Rules, a video series on free speech and the law. Volokh is the co-founder of the Volokh Conspiracy, which is hosted at Reason.com.

This is not legal advice.
If this were legal advice, it would be followed by a bill.
Please use responsibly.

Music: "Lobby Time," by Kevin MacLeod (Incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

For full text visit https://reason.com/reasontv/2019/04/10/fake-news-and-the-first-amendment-free-s

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
free speech
,
first amendment
,
fake news
,
#fakenews
    Thumbnail for John McWhorter: America Has Never Been Less Racist45:51
    John McWhorter: America Has Never Been Less Racist
    ReasonVids
    890 views
    Thumbnail for I'm a female cop! Respect me! 1:29
    I'm a female cop! Respect me!
    bestofvoatxyz
    744 views
    Thumbnail for @helena after a first date0:10
    @helena after a first date
    bestofupgoat
    78 views
    Thumbnail for This Zeepkist Level Creator Said They Had An Important Question For Us - Kick or Clutch Ep. 169 | OwlPlague11:02
    This Zeepkist Level Creator Said They Had An Important Question For Us - Kick or Clutch Ep. 169 | OwlPlague
    invidious
    366 views
    Thumbnail for ABC World News Tonight with David Muir Full Broadcast - June 14, 2025 | ABC News19:32
    ABC World News Tonight with David Muir Full Broadcast - June 14, 2025 | ABC News
    invidious
    107 views
    Thumbnail for Minecraft Update Moment | NotVixios0:08
    Minecraft Update Moment | NotVixios
    invidious
    134 views
    Thumbnail for "You're not the boss of me!" BZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ0:22
    "You're not the boss of me!" BZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
    bestofupgoat
    60 views
    Thumbnail for Muzzies help with the lgdtqproblem.0:25
    Muzzies help with the lgdtqproblem.
    bestofvoatxyz
    557 views
    Thumbnail for Wednesday is pizza night ... 1:05
    Wednesday is pizza night ...
    bestofupgoat
    161 views
    Thumbnail for Pro Vaxxtard Gets Steamrolled5:04
    Pro Vaxxtard Gets Steamrolled
    bestofupgoat
    413 views
    Thumbnail for How to invite the fire department over for Christmas without inviting the fire department over for Christmas0:40
    How to invite the fire department over for Christmas without inviting the fire department over for Christmas
    bestofupgoat
    582 views
    Thumbnail for Dear Diary, I ran into @Sal_180 today...0:05
    Dear Diary, I ran into @Sal_180 today...
    bestofupgoat
    119 views
    Thumbnail for Anal Probes Run Amok: Drug-Sniffing Dogs Must Be Stopped.4:18
    Anal Probes Run Amok: Drug-Sniffing Dogs Must Be Stopped.
    ReasonVids
    955 views
    Thumbnail for Just an owl hugging a tree stump0:20
    Just an owl hugging a tree stump
    bestofupgoat
    345 views
    Thumbnail for Gang violence between doctors and engineers forces shopping centre into lockdown1:16
    Gang violence between doctors and engineers forces shopping centre into lockdown
    bestofupgoat
    452 views
    Thumbnail for this is the first time I didnt think the HAKKA was stupid1:30
    this is the first time I didnt think the HAKKA was stupid
    bestofupgoat
    118 views
    Thumbnail for MHW:IB #6  | ワールドのストーリークリアするぞ~! 【にじさんじ/叶】 | Kanae Channel4:08:21
    MHW:IB #6 | ワールドのストーリークリアするぞ~! 【にじさんじ/叶】 | Kanae Channel
    invidious
    307 views
    Thumbnail for ...go back to Africa if you don't like it...1:08
    ...go back to Africa if you don't like it...
    bestofupgoat
    521 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Seattle’s 'Amazon Tax'4:31
    Stossel: Seattle’s 'Amazon Tax'
    ReasonVids
    753 views
    Thumbnail for The truth about women - they're always dissapointed and never satisfied 1:00
    The truth about women - they're always dissapointed and never satisfied
    bestofupgoat
    226 views
    Thumbnail for The Role of Envy in Racial Conflict45:35
    The Role of Envy in Racial Conflict
    AmericanRenaissance
    1005 views
    Thumbnail for Ivermectin to fight RSV? - The Highwire14:56
    Ivermectin to fight RSV? - The Highwire
    bestofsaidit
    815 views
    Thumbnail for Are They Voiced By A Boy Or A Girl? | Sambucha1:00
    Are They Voiced By A Boy Or A Girl? | Sambucha
    invidious
    205 views
    Thumbnail for I'd be singing the same song with her on my arm, lil fella!0:47
    I'd be singing the same song with her on my arm, lil fella!
    bestofupgoat
    102 views
    Thumbnail for Fall Asleep In Less Than 3 Minutes ★ Stress And Anxiety Relief ★ Goodbye Insomnia | Weightless Sleep Meditation1:00
    Fall Asleep In Less Than 3 Minutes ★ Stress And Anxiety Relief ★ Goodbye Insomnia | Weightless Sleep Meditation
    invidious
    355 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
free speech
,
first amendment
,
fake news
,
#fakenews
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle