HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

"They Kidnapped Our Child": Why CPS Needs Transparency Now

Views: 880
In April 2013, police officers and a social worker from Sacramento County's Child Protective Services entered the home of Anna and Alex Nikolayev and took their baby, Sammy, away from them. They had no warrant.

"What they'd done was, basically, kidnapped our child with the help of police," says Alex Nikolayev. The young, first-time parents were not notified of where Sammy was being taken and wouldn't find out for a full 24 hours. According to the Nikolayevs, the dispute stemmed from the parents' desire to obtain a second medical opinion before subjecting Sammy to major heart surgery.

The Nikolayev's story made national headlines thanks to footage from a camcorder Anna Nikolayev set up on the kitchen table. It also caught the attention of California Assemblyman Tim Donnelly, who spearheaded an audit of the agency.

"The secrecy by which CPS operates is a massive problem. Because when you have secrecy and unchecked power, you have a recipe for corruption and abuse," says Donnelly.

The secrecy surrounding CPS stems from the nature of California's juvenile dependency courts, which only allow limited press access and seal all court records. While media and other interested parties can petition the court to open the records, this can be a lengthy process and by no means guarantees results. ReasonTV petitioned the court to open the records in the Nikolayev's case and, almost two months later, we have still not received a ruling from the judge.

The issue of funding is one that many critics of CPS are quick to raise, most prominently and frequently by the late Georgia state senator Nancy Schaefer. While the funding incentives for any government agency are complicated and seemingly impossible to divine, Orange County Social Services Agency Director Michael Riley, who oversees Orange County CPS, testified in a deposition related to Hardwick's case that putting more children into the foster system can boost the agency's budget.

"Let's say you spend ten dollars a year. So, then, for the following year, your base then would be ten dollars," says Riley. The lawyer questioning Riley then points out that failure to use the entire base would result in a lowering of the base for the next year. He then asks Riley if the funding stream is tied to how many children they bring into Orange County's children's home, Orangewood.

"It's tied to the number of children we have in the foster system," says Riley.

We reached out to both Sacramento County and Orange County Social Services Agencies in the production of this story, and representatives with both were happy to talk with us. However, because of the closed dependency courts, neither representative could comment on details of specific cases. The absurdity of this charade reached such heights that Sherri Heller, who runs Sacramento County's Health and Human Services, told us that she could not even confirm nor deny that Sacramento County CPS was even involved in the Nikolayev case, despite widespread reporting and video evidence that it was. It's not just parents and children who suffer from the secrecy. CPS workers and their managers say they are not happy about this situation either and feel that more openness and transparency would help them to communicate their side of the story clearly.

"Most of us in this field are eager for the public to understand what happened and why," says Heller. "It is a source of great dismay to us when we are accused of hiding behind the confidentiality law."

In the immediate wake of the Nikolayev case, parents gathered in Sacramento to support the audit and testify in front of the audit committee. The audit is set to proceed in the next few months, and the auditor will choose three county agencies to examine. But for parents like Deanna Hardwick, who's experienced the power of this agency first-hand, a state-level audit is just the beginning of a broader movement towards transparency and accountability.

"Once the American people are able to be made aware that this is going on, I think that will be a real step forward towards making sure that there's accountability and making sure that the agency is working towards keeping families together rather than separating them," says Hardwick.

About 10 minutes.

Produced by Zach Weissmueller. Camera by Paul Detrick, Tracy Oppenheimer, and Weissmueller.

Visit http://reason.com/reasontv/2013/08/12/they-kidnapped-our-child-why-cps-needs-t for full text, supporting links, and downloadable versions. And subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube Channel to receive automatic notifications when new material goes live.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Stop and Frisk on Trial in NYC: Race, Crime and Constitutional Policing9:54
Stop and Frisk on Trial in NYC: Race, Crime and Constitutional Policing
ReasonVids
1076 views
Thumbnail for Why A Dictatorship Could Crumble: "Young Cubans... have not been brainwashed."10:20
Why A Dictatorship Could Crumble: "Young Cubans... have not been brainwashed."
ReasonVids
873 views
Thumbnail for The Churchill Thrillers: An Interview with Michael and Patrick McMenamin3:06
The Churchill Thrillers: An Interview with Michael and Patrick McMenamin
ReasonVids
796 views
Thumbnail for Retard Alert0:20
Retard Alert
AOUisgay
289 views
Thumbnail for Joel Stein on His "Stupid Quest for Masculinity"6:35
Joel Stein on His "Stupid Quest for Masculinity"
ReasonVids
854 views
Thumbnail for Just niggers niggen0:14
Just niggers niggen
bestofupgoat
88 views
Thumbnail for US State Department veteran Stuart Seldowitz, "If we killed 4,000 Palestinian kids, it wasn't enough"2:06
US State Department veteran Stuart Seldowitz, "If we killed 4,000 Palestinian kids, it wasn't enough"
AOUisgay
436 views
Thumbnail for "Jesus stopped Whites from being like niggers. Niggers are just as good as Whites if they are christian" -Alex Jones 0:32
"Jesus stopped Whites from being like niggers. Niggers are just as good as Whites if they are christian" -Alex Jones
bestofupgoat
439 views
Thumbnail for Tech Campaign Ad #2 | Tech Campaign Ad #20:16
Tech Campaign Ad #2 | Tech Campaign Ad #2
invidious
121 views
Thumbnail for Hot Air's Ed Morrissey on Not-So-Radical Republicans and Life Outside the Beltway8:04
Hot Air's Ed Morrissey on Not-So-Radical Republicans and Life Outside the Beltway
ReasonVids
847 views
Thumbnail for How California Will Legalize Pot in 2016: Learning The Lessons of Prop 197:18
How California Will Legalize Pot in 2016: Learning The Lessons of Prop 19
ReasonVids
828 views
Thumbnail for Why Are Public Schools Fighting To Keep Home School Kids Off Their Teams?9:17
Why Are Public Schools Fighting To Keep Home School Kids Off Their Teams?
ReasonVids
864 views
Thumbnail for A woman drags her victim by her hair and punches her in the face over an argument over locker space on a flight from Turkey to Tunisia.0:27
A woman drags her victim by her hair and punches her in the face over an argument over locker space on a flight from Turkey to Tunisia.
bestofupgoat
407 views
Thumbnail for What Former Presidents Really Thought on Race7:40
What Former Presidents Really Thought on Race
bestofvoatxyz
878 views
Thumbnail for Remy: Blurred Lines (Robin Thicke Anthony Weiner Parody)2:17
Remy: Blurred Lines (Robin Thicke Anthony Weiner Parody)
ReasonVids
839 views
Thumbnail for Delta Smelt & Undocumented Farm Workers: How Federal Policy Is Failing CA's Central Valley7:47
Delta Smelt & Undocumented Farm Workers: How Federal Policy Is Failing CA's Central Valley
ReasonVids
840 views
Thumbnail for Sports Stadiums Are Bad Public Investments. So Why Are Cities Still Paying for Them?4:53
Sports Stadiums Are Bad Public Investments. So Why Are Cities Still Paying for Them?
ReasonVids
1007 views
Thumbnail for Treasure Island - (Russian - English dubbed) Part 137:49
Treasure Island - (Russian - English dubbed) Part 1
AOUisgay
520 views
Thumbnail for Cory Doctorow on Cyber Warfare, Lawbreaking, and His New Novel 'Walkaway'40:37
Cory Doctorow on Cyber Warfare, Lawbreaking, and His New Novel 'Walkaway'
ReasonVids
948 views
Thumbnail for Moms Say, "No More Drug War!"2:58
Moms Say, "No More Drug War!"
ReasonVids
892 views
Thumbnail for how do you get people to actually listen?1:07
how do you get people to actually listen?
bestofupgoat
377 views
Thumbnail for Tap It: The NSA Slow Jam (featuring @goremy)2:47
Tap It: The NSA Slow Jam (featuring @goremy)
ReasonVids
892 views
Thumbnail for “I enjoy looking like a clown” - no shit.0:34
“I enjoy looking like a clown” - no shit.
AOU
5822 views
Thumbnail for Coding Boot Camps Can Get Students Jobs, CA is Busting Them (Nanny of the Month, February 2014)1:39
Coding Boot Camps Can Get Students Jobs, CA is Busting Them (Nanny of the Month, February 2014)
ReasonVids
794 views
Thumbnail for The NSA Wouldn't Let Us in This Building (But We Found Out What's Inside)5:05
The NSA Wouldn't Let Us in This Building (But We Found Out What's Inside)
ReasonVids
868 views

points

Permalink
Reply
cps, child protection (organization sector), child protective services, corruption, abuse, transparency, government transparency, nikoyaevs, deanna hardwick, baby sammy, baby sammy raid, government raid, social workers, police abuse, libertarian, reason magazine
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle