HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Stossel: What Trump's Court Pick Means for Liberty

Views:896
@ReasonVids

Hearings begin today for President Trump's Supreme Court pick, Brett Kavanaugh.

John Stossel wonders whether Kavanaugh will be good for liberty.

---------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
---------


Libertarians are right to worry. Kavanaugh has shown deference to government when it spies on people.

In one case, Kavanaugh allowed the government's "metadata collection program", in which the government stored phone data on millions of Americans.

Kavanaugh even went out of his way give comments on that case, saying the metadata program "serves a critically important special need—preventing terrorist attacks on the United States."

But a government report later found that: "we are aware of no instance in which the program directly contributed to ... disruption of a terrorist attack."

Yes, says Ilya Shaprio, the CATO Institute's senior fellow in constitutional studies, Kavanaugh disagrees with libertarians on national security. But on just about every other issue, Kavanaugh would likely advance liberty.

Shapiro notes that Kavanaugh is one of the best judges in the country at opposing government regulation on individuals and companies. As a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, Kavanaugh tried to strike down lots of regulations: net neutrality, EPA admissions rules, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. He didn’t always succeed, but he argued that they were all bureaucratic overreaches.

Shapiro tells Stossel that Kavanaugh would also likely overturn the "Kelo" eminent domain decision, which allowed governments to take private property for nearly any reason.

Kavanaugh is also good on gun rights. Citing the 2nd Amendment, he tried to overturn a DC ban on all semi-automatic rifles.

The left fears Kavanaugh mostly for other reasons. Protestors shout "hell no, Kavanaugh" at rallies. Senator Kristen Gillibrand warns: "What’s at stake is freedom for LGBTQ Americans, for equal rights, for civil rights."

Senator Bernie Sanders warns he would "tell women they don’t have the constitutional right to control their own bodies."

But their biggest fears are misplaced, Shaprio tells Stossel. Kavanaugh is unlikely to change rulings on Roe v. Wade and gay marriage, because he and Chief Justice John Roberts respect precedent, especially if changing it would disrupt people's lives.

The left can breathe easier on those things, says Shapiro, but he notes that Kavanaugh will likely overturn one thing that is dear to the left: affirmative action.

"Kavanaugh could provide the 5th vote to overturn that 40-year-old experiment with using racial preferences to promote some kind of nebulous diversity."

Should libertarians be happy with Kavanaugh overall, Stossel asks?

“Definitely," Shapiro says. "He’s not going to agree with us all the time, certainly. But no judges or justices do."

The views expressed in this video are solely those of John Stossel; his independent production company, Stossel Productions; and the people he interviews. The claims and opinions set forth in the video and accompanying text are not necessarily those of Reason.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
john stossel
,
brett kavanaugh
,
supreme court
,
cato
Thumbnail for The Coddling of the American Mind: How Overprotective Parenting Led to Fragility on Campus
The Coddling of the American Mind: How Overprotective Parenting Led to Fragility on Campus
ReasonVids
968 views
Thumbnail for Is There Still a Legal Case Against Obamacare? Q&A w Pacific Legal Fdtn's Timothy Sandefur
Is There Still a Legal Case Against Obamacare? Q&A w Pacific Legal Fdtn's Timothy Sandefur
ReasonVids
992 views
Thumbnail for DOMA is Done: Damon Root on a Supreme Win for Gay Rights
DOMA is Done: Damon Root on a Supreme Win for Gay Rights
ReasonVids
864 views
Thumbnail for My pet croc
My pet croc
bestofvoatxyz
486 views
Thumbnail for This is what it’s like flying the Virgin Retreat Suite PT.1 #travel #firstclass #businessclass | Jack's Dining Room
This is what it’s like flying the Virgin Retreat Suite PT.1 #travel #firstclass #businessclass | Jack's Dining Room
invidious
100 views
Thumbnail for Foreign countries
Foreign countries
EricaPolarBear.Archive
247 views
Thumbnail for 3 Reasons Obama Should Kick His Own Ass
3 Reasons Obama Should Kick His Own Ass
ReasonVids
957 views
Thumbnail for We no longer have jewish forced slavery, we have jewish debt slavery.
We no longer have jewish forced slavery, we have jewish debt slavery.
AOUisgay
459 views
Thumbnail for Name one thing
Name one thing
bestofvoatxyz
388 views
Thumbnail for Immovable Object meets Irresistable Force
Immovable Object meets Irresistable Force
voatcatbox
548 views
Thumbnail for Surfing is fun
Surfing is fun
bestofupgoat
138 views
Thumbnail for CATO's David Boaz on What America Can (and Shouldn't) Learn From the French Revolution
CATO's David Boaz on What America Can (and Shouldn't) Learn From the French Revolution
ReasonVids
901 views
Thumbnail for The High Cost of Occupational Licensing — License to Work Ep2
The High Cost of Occupational Licensing — License to Work Ep2
IJvids
1023 views
Thumbnail for Flipping the Parrot (Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Animation)[Paula Peroff] | Mornal
Flipping the Parrot (Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Animation)[Paula Peroff] | Mornal
invidious
442 views
Thumbnail for Dr. Janci Lindsay (audio improved) at South Carolina Senate hearing on DNA plasmid contamination in Covid-19 mRNA vaccines.
Dr. Janci Lindsay (audio improved) at South Carolina Senate hearing on DNA plasmid contamination in Covid-19 mRNA vaccines.
allAheadFull
626 views
Thumbnail for Burton Android debunked #carterpcs #tech #techtok #techfacts #android #ios | CarterPCs
Burton Android debunked #carterpcs #tech #techtok #techfacts #android #ios | CarterPCs
invidious
87 views
Thumbnail for Donald Trump Has the Power to Release Nonviolent Marijuana Offenders from Prison. Will He Act?
Donald Trump Has the Power to Release Nonviolent Marijuana Offenders from Prison. Will He Act?
ReasonVids
967 views
Thumbnail for Easy Ammo & Reloading System in Unity | BMo
Easy Ammo & Reloading System in Unity | BMo
tech.topic
721 views
Thumbnail for Want Equity? Punish White People.
Want Equity? Punish White People.
AmericanRenaissance
798 views
Thumbnail for They Finally Admitted It | Live From The Lair
They Finally Admitted It | Live From The Lair
Terrence Popp
2334 views
Thumbnail for Oy vey!
Oy vey!
bestofupgoat
206 views
Thumbnail for Dead Internet Theory Confirmed: 51% of Traffic Now Non-Human
Dead Internet Theory Confirmed: 51% of Traffic Now Non-Human
invidious
116 views
Thumbnail for Joe Biden: Already Hard at Work Wrecking the Country
Joe Biden: Already Hard at Work Wrecking the Country
AmericanRenaissance
1940 views
Thumbnail for This is Your Brain on the Drug War
This is Your Brain on the Drug War
ReasonVids
873 views
Thumbnail for 'Tongue singing' - Strange
'Tongue singing' - Strange
Gviduser
405 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
john stossel
,
brett kavanaugh
,
supreme court
,
cato
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle