HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

New Orleans Judge's Orders Benefited a Private Company

Views: 275
Today, New Orleans-area resident Marshall Sookram joined Hakeem Meade in a class action lawsuit against a judge on the New Orleans Criminal District Court for violating their right to neutral adjudication.

https://ij.org/press-release/new-orleans-area-residents-file-class-action-lawsuit-over-due-process-violations-in-criminal-proceedings/

Judge Paul A. Bonin previously ordered both men to pretrial ankle monitoring by ETOH Monitoring, LLC (ETOH). What the two men and many other New Orleans-area defendants did not know is that both of ETOH’s executives—one of whom is Judge Bonin’s former law partner—had together contributed over $9,000 to Judge Bonin’s judicial election campaigns and had even loaned money to the judge’s campaign.

The assessment of fees and deprivation of liberty involving a conflict of interest are violations of due process guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution. Now, Hakeem and Marshall are fighting back with the Institute for Justice (IJ) and the Law Office of William Most to ensure that ankle monitoring decisions are made without bias or the appearance of bias. This mission is especially vital now that COVID-19 has led many municipalities to monitor defendants with ankle monitors—and make the defendants pay for the monitoring service—instead of placing them in jail.

“Hakeem was placed on an ankle monitor with a company that has significant ties to the judge deciding his case. This is a direct conflict of interest and is unconstitutional,” IJ Senior Attorney Bill Maurer said. “Louisianans need to trust that their criminal justice system is free from bias or the appearance of bias. This lawsuit will help hold it accountable.”

The personal and financial relationship between Judge Bonin and ETOH was revealed in 2019 in a report by Court Watch NOLA (CWN), a judicial watchdog organization. Pretrial defendants, who were overwhelmingly indigent, had to pay $100 to ETOH for the installation of their monitoring devices and then $10 per day for monitoring. According to the same 2019 report, Judge Bonin also required his staff to “provide the defendant or the defendant’s family members with the contact information for ETOH.” Judge Bonin would sometimes even refuse to release defendants from jail until the family had arranged for ETOH to set up ankle monitoring. While Judge Bonin claims to have stopped the practice, the defendants he oversaw are still being pressured by ETOH to pay their remaining fees to the company.

“Fines and fees have become a mechanism for taking property and money from our society’s most vulnerable people and handing it to government agencies and private companies performing government functions,” said IJ Attorney Jaba Tsitsuashvili. “But the purpose of the criminal justice system is to pursue justice and protect the public, not generate revenue.”

These principles are especially vital because private companies have become enmeshed in the operation of state judicial systems. When private companies perform government functions, they must conform to constitutional standards. The lawsuit seeks to set boundaries on the proper use of private ankle-monitoring companies and other private companies which play a role in the judicial system.

“I’m part of this lawsuit to stop this abuse in the New Orleans court system and to make sure this doesn’t happen to anybody else,” said plaintiff Marshall Sookram.

Hakeem and Marshall are asking the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana to issue an order declaring that judicial decisions that benefit a private party with direct ties to a judge violate the Constitution. The class action lawsuit also seeks to require the company to disgorge the fees it collected from all defendants appearing before Judge Bonin and to cancel outstanding fees.

This case is the latest in IJ’s nationwide initiative to end abusive fines and fees and to ensure that the justice system operates for health and safety, not for profit. To vindicate these principles, IJ is currently litigating fines and fees cases in California (Indio and Norco), Georgia, and Missouri. IJ also launched a nationwide database surveying and grading state laws for their role in facilitating fines and fees abuses. And IJ’s Project on Immunity and Accountability litigates cases to hold government officials and those who act in concert with them accountable for violating peoples’ constitutional rights.
Donate to IJ: https://ij.org/support/give-now/
@IJvidsfollow
Thumbnail for New Study Finds Forfeiture Doesn’t Fight Crime, Is Used to Raise Revenue10:16
New Study Finds Forfeiture Doesn’t Fight Crime, Is Used to Raise Revenue
IJvids
235 views
Thumbnail for That's not how video-conferencing is supposed to work.0:29
That's not how video-conferencing is supposed to work.
publicfreakouts
252 views
Thumbnail for A smooth criminal0:20
A smooth criminal
bestofvoatxyz
1442 views
Thumbnail for FCC's Ajit Pai: Net Neutrality is a "Solution That Won't Work to a Problem That Doesn't Exist"31:16
FCC's Ajit Pai: Net Neutrality is a "Solution That Won't Work to a Problem That Doesn't Exist"
ReasonVids
236 views
Thumbnail for Cities Caught Extracting Millions From Residents Through Fines and Fees Traps37:14
Cities Caught Extracting Millions From Residents Through Fines and Fees Traps
IJvids
223 views
Thumbnail for rare footage of @AOU's girlfriend ಥ‿ಥ0:16
rare footage of @AOU's girlfriend ಥ‿ಥ
x0x7
821 views
Thumbnail for There was an attempt: to remove him from a public area0:26
There was an attempt: to remove him from a public area
publicfreakouts
257 views
Thumbnail for The State of White America10:17
The State of White America
AmericanRenaissance
748 views
Thumbnail for How Anarchism Can Solve Social Problems: Gary Chartier at Freedom Fest 20134:21
How Anarchism Can Solve Social Problems: Gary Chartier at Freedom Fest 2013
ReasonVids
238 views
Thumbnail for Trevor Noah underhandedly tells the Media and the Government their actual job1:46
Trevor Noah underhandedly tells the Media and the Government their actual job
bestofsaidit
319 views
Thumbnail for The Most Haunted Place On Earth: Iraq War Part 3 of 3 | Live From The Lair34:53
The Most Haunted Place On Earth: Iraq War Part 3 of 3 | Live From The Lair
Terrence Popp
525 views
Thumbnail for Slavery is Our ‘Original Sin'?!12:12
Slavery is Our ‘Original Sin'?!
AmericanRenaissance
879 views
Thumbnail for Release the Bipolar2:05
Release the Bipolar
bestofvoatxyz
226 views
Thumbnail for 30 Ways to Say DNC1:01
30 Ways to Say DNC
ReasonVids
232 views
Thumbnail for The Libertarian Roots of Police Reform: Q&A with Radley Balko51:21
The Libertarian Roots of Police Reform: Q&A with Radley Balko
ReasonVids
236 views
Thumbnail for ADL's Double Standards [How blacks are treated in Israel]3:10
ADL's Double Standards [How blacks are treated in Israel]
bestofvoat
1010 views
Thumbnail for The Unauthorized Autobiography of Kim Jong Il: Q&A with Michael Malice54:27
The Unauthorized Autobiography of Kim Jong Il: Q&A with Michael Malice
ReasonVids
297 views
Thumbnail for Military Clothes Are Sexist?! | Live From The Lair24:33
Military Clothes Are Sexist?! | Live From The Lair
Terrence Popp
980 views
Thumbnail for BREAKING! Alex Jones Responds To $4.2 Million Sandy Hook Verdict7:44
BREAKING! Alex Jones Responds To $4.2 Million Sandy Hook Verdict
bestofwolfballs
194 views
Thumbnail for Russia releases video of suspected Moscow car bomber2:19
Russia releases video of suspected Moscow car bomber
bestofvoatxyz
179 views
Thumbnail for Dana Goodyear on the Coming Clash Between Foodies & Regulators8:59
Dana Goodyear on the Coming Clash Between Foodies & Regulators
ReasonVids
199 views

points

Permalink
Reply
ij, institute for justice, freedom, liberty, individual rights, constitution, constitutional law, unconstitutional law, con law, constitutional litigation
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle