HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Alexander Hamilton's Influence on Free Press Law: Free Speech Rules (Episode 10)

Views:889
@ReasonVids

No rules this time - Just a little history.

Alexander Hamilton was many things: aide to General George Washington, Secretary of the Treasury, Major General of the U.S. Army, lover, cheater, duelist, musical phenomenon. But few people know his immensely influential role in American free press law—just months before his fatal duel.

Today, we think of libel as defamatory falsehood: false written statements—especially lies, but sometimes honest mistakes—that injure a person's reputation. And we also think of libel as a civil claim; criminal libel prosecutions are very rare.

In 1700s England, though, criminal libel cases were common, and they covered many written statements that harmed a person's reputation even if they were true. Such statements were outlawed in part because they were seen as likely to produce duels. And, when said about government officials, such defamatory statements—again, even if true—were seen as undermining the government's authority. "The greater the truth, the greater the libel," some said.

American law was based on English law, so many Americans assumed American law would take the same view. In the famous colonial-era 1735 John Peter Zenger trial, the defense had argued that truth must be a defense in libel cases. But though the jury acquitted Zenger, such jury decisions set no legally binding precedent.

Enter Alexander Hamilton, in 1803. Thomas Jefferson was President; Hamilton was a prominent New York lawyer. When Harry Croswell, an anti-Jefferson newspaper editor, was prosecuted in New York state court for libeling Jefferson, Hamilton came to Croswell's defense.

Croswell's publication had alleged that Thomas Jefferson had paid another editor, James Callender, to make scurrilous accusations against Washington and Adams. This allegation of Croswell's injured Jefferson's reputation, the prosecution charged, thus making it a libel—without regard to whether it was true. And it also injured the nation, making it a so-called "seditious libel."

Croswell was convicted, after the trial judge instructed the jury that truth was not a defense in libel cases. Croswell appealed, and Hamilton, representing Croswell, argued that truth should have been a defense:

"The Liberty of the Press consists, in my idea, in publishing the truth, from good motives and for justifiable ends, though it reflect on government, on magistrates, or individuals.  It is essential to say, not only that the measure is bad and deleterious, but to hold up to the people who is the author, that, in this our free and elective government, he may be removed from the seat of power."

Today, that standard actually would diminish First Amendment protection. At least as to matters of public concern, the Court held in 1964, prosecutors must always prove an alleged libel was false, regardless of whether it was said "from good motives and for justifiable ends." But in 1803, Hamilton's position was a great step towards broader legal protection for criticism of government.

And Hamilton's position swept the nation. Not at first: The New York court split 2 to 2, thus leaving Croswell's conviction standing. But Justice James Kent, who would become one of the most influential judges and legal writers of the early 1800s, endorsed Hamilton's views in his opinion. In 1805, the New York Legislature enacted a statute implementing Hamilton's view that truth was always a defense when published "with good motives and for justifiable ends"—phrasing that Hamilton pioneered. In the decades after that, many state constitutions were framed precisely this way. To this day, 20 state constitutions contain Hamilton's formula.

Hamilton and Justice Kent had become close friends in the years before the Croswell case. While they were in Albany for the court sitting that included the Croswell argument, Hamilton, Kent and a few others had dinner together. Over dinner, Hamilton remarked that he thought Aaron Burr was dangerous and untrustworthy. Burr was at the time planning to run for governor of New York, though he ended up being beaten by Morgan Lewis, the trial judge in Croswell's case.

Another man at the dinner reported on these remarks, which were then referred to in an Albany newspaper. Burr demanded that they be retracted. Hamilton refused. Burr challenged Hamilton to a duel. And Hamilton didn't live to see his view of the freedom of the press become part of American law.
--
Written by Eugene Volokh, who is a First Amendment law professor at UCLA.
Produced and edited by Austin Bragg, who is not.
Additional graphics by Joshua Swain

This is the ninth episode of Free Speech Rules, a video series on free speech and the law. Volokh is the co-founder of The Volokh Conspiracy, hosted at Reason.com.

This is not legal advice.
If this were legal advice, it would be followed by a bill.
Please use responsibly.

Music:"Lobby Time," by Kevin MacLeod (Incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for Michael Bloomberg and the Imperious Presidency4:31
    Michael Bloomberg and the Imperious Presidency
    ReasonVids
    875 views
    Thumbnail for 2DADS TV - SURRENDER OUR FUTURE2:45
    2DADS TV - SURRENDER OUR FUTURE
    cheekymusicvideos
    2584 views
    Thumbnail for Brutal Doom Sunlust Map 0113:32
    Brutal Doom Sunlust Map 01
    brutalist_gaming
    1348 views
    Thumbnail for Tying the Tubes | Grunt Speak Shorts9:25
    Tying the Tubes | Grunt Speak Shorts
    Terrence Popp
    707 views
    Thumbnail for #AmericanCarnage: The Dystopian Rhetoric of Trump’s Inauguration Speech0:52
    #AmericanCarnage: The Dystopian Rhetoric of Trump’s Inauguration Speech
    ReasonVids
    911 views
    Thumbnail for Meth, Murder and Incest: A True Story | Ride and Roast31:29
    Meth, Murder and Incest: A True Story | Ride and Roast
    Terrence Popp
    1335 views
    Thumbnail for Remy: Savage (Megan Thee Stallion Coronavirus Bailout Zoom Parody)1:25
    Remy: Savage (Megan Thee Stallion Coronavirus Bailout Zoom Parody)
    ReasonVids
    946 views
    Thumbnail for Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s Green New Deal: A Bizarre Grab-Bag of Terrible Ideas10:18
    Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s Green New Deal: A Bizarre Grab-Bag of Terrible Ideas
    ReasonVids
    875 views
    Thumbnail for 5 Republicans Liberals May Grow to Love in the Trump Era1:46
    5 Republicans Liberals May Grow to Love in the Trump Era
    ReasonVids
    925 views
    Thumbnail for To Those Who Didn't Like My Missile Video:1:43
    To Those Who Didn't Like My Missile Video:
    voatcatbox
    246 views
    Thumbnail for How Kurzgesagt Cooks Propaganda For Billionaires | The Hated One24:13
    How Kurzgesagt Cooks Propaganda For Billionaires | The Hated One
    invidious
    497 views
    Thumbnail for German TV Presenter Pushes For Mandatory Vaccination – Then Collapses Live On-Air0:27
    German TV Presenter Pushes For Mandatory Vaccination – Then Collapses Live On-Air
    AOU
    1284 views
    Thumbnail for "Ensouling silica with sulfur and high voltage schumann frequencies + sunlight to form quartz crystal. The ancient science they've stolen and occulted."3:00
    "Ensouling silica with sulfur and high voltage schumann frequencies + sunlight to form quartz crystal. The ancient science they've stolen and occulted."
    AOUisgay
    473 views
    Thumbnail for Is it satire tho?0:14
    Is it satire tho?
    AOUisgay
    318 views
    Thumbnail for Will Whole Foods Destroy Brooklyn?2:21
    Will Whole Foods Destroy Brooklyn?
    ReasonVids
    925 views
    Thumbnail for The Problem with Hurricane Sandy Aid2:08
    The Problem with Hurricane Sandy Aid
    ReasonVids
    960 views
    Thumbnail for "This Town" Author Mark Leibovich on Shaming D.C.'s Elite12:39
    "This Town" Author Mark Leibovich on Shaming D.C.'s Elite
    ReasonVids
    865 views
    Thumbnail for Wall Street Journal's Stephen Moore on the 2012 Election5:46
    Wall Street Journal's Stephen Moore on the 2012 Election
    ReasonVids
    886 views
    Thumbnail for polite bear0:36
    polite bear
    bestofupgoat
    493 views
    Thumbnail for The Mystery Of israel - Solved! (David Sorensen 2023)1:03:28
    The Mystery Of israel - Solved! (David Sorensen 2023)
    AOUisgay
    305 views
    Thumbnail for Mexicans and Machines: Drew Carey on Nafta7:44
    Mexicans and Machines: Drew Carey on Nafta
    ReasonVids
    1000 views
    Thumbnail for Rawesome Foods Raided... Again!3:37
    Rawesome Foods Raided... Again!
    ReasonVids
    973 views
    Thumbnail for California Tried to Seize Millions of This Inventor’s Fortune. He Fought Back. And Won.7:07
    California Tried to Seize Millions of This Inventor’s Fortune. He Fought Back. And Won.
    ReasonVids
    935 views
    Thumbnail for Germany 20240:21
    Germany 2024
    bestofupgoat
    371 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle