HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Stossel: Debating a Hoaxed Journal Editor

Views:939
@ReasonVids

The editor of a journal that fell for a hoax defends his field.

---------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
---------

Seven academic journals recently published papers that were actually hoaxes designed to show the absurdity found in such academic fields as gender studies, race studies, and queer studies. The hoaxers intentionally submitted papers that were ridiculous. One included gibberish about rape culture in dog parks. Another was a section of Hitler's Mein Kampf re-written with feminist buzzwords.

Six journal editors would not talk to Stossel, but one—Roberto Refinetti, editor in chief of Sexuality and Culture—agreed to an interview.

He condemns what the hoaxers did: "You're deceiving people without much of a reason."

He complains, "If you're going to do your research with people, you have to propose your research, submit to a body called an Institutional Review Board."

One of the hoaxers, Peter Boghossian, was found guilty by his employer (Portland State University) of violating its rules requiring him to get approval for the experiment. Of course, since the Institutional Review Board would have insisted that the researchers inform the journals that they were being tested, the test wouldn't have worked.

Stossel says he thinks the hoaxers had good reason not to go to the review board first. "Their hoax woke us up to the fact that some academic journals publish nonsense," he says.

Refinetti's journal, for instance, published the hoax paper titled, "Going in Through the Back Door: Challenging Straight Male Homohysteria, Transhysteria, and Transphobia Through Receptive Penetrative Sex Toy Use."

The paper touted "encouraging male anal eroticism with sex toys" because it would help make men more feminist.

Sexuality and Culture published that paper after its reviewers praised it glowingly. One called it "an incredibly rich and exciting contribution...timely, and worthy of publication."

Refinetti defends his journal, saying that it publishes mind-expanding questions.

"What is the problem with the subject of the paper? I don't see a problem....It's nothing really absurd or unusual," Refinetti says.

He also says: "Let's question our assumptions, because maybe we're making assumptions that we shouldn't be making....When homosexuality was considered a mental illness. People pushed, the psychiatrists got together, and said...'it's a perfectly fine thing to choose and not to call it mental illness.' So that's the type of thing that a journal in sexuality and culture does, is discuss."

Discussion is good, Stossel agrees. But in journals today, it seems that only certain conclusions are permitted. The hoaxers complain that in many university fields: "A culture has developed in which only certain conclusions are allowed, like those that make whiteness and masculinity problematic."

"I wouldn't be surprised to find out that in some places that is correct," Refinetti agrees.

"Is that a problem?" asks Stossel.

Refinetti replies: "How big of a problem is it? Is it worse than hunger? Is it worse than people shooting each other?"

But a lack of diversity of ideas does make it harder to find truth—and more likely for ridiculous ideas to thrive. Today's colleges have an extreme lack of diversity: A National Association of Scholars report found that professors at top liberal arts colleges are 10 times more likely to be Democrats than Republicans.

Refinetti says that's not surprising.

"I think it's very reasonable—because what is the job of learning?...Being more open to new ideas, which is what being a liberal is," he says.

Stossel pushes back: "This is your left-leaning definition; it's conservatives that proposed changes like school vouchers...privatizing air traffic control."

"That's an interesting point," Refinetti responds. "Then the hypothesis is shut down. See, that's how things work. You show the idea, you discuss the idea, and get it."

Refinetti says his journal publishes multiple viewpoints. It has published articles that question feminist orthodoxy.

Stossel says he's grateful that Refinetti was willing to have a conversation, but he still cheers the hoaxers for revealing that much of what passes for scholarship at colleges is bunk.

The views expressed in this video are solely those of John Stossel; his independent production company, Stossel Productions; and the people he interviews. The claims and opinions set forth in the video and accompanying text are not necessarily those of Reason.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
john stossel
,
grievance studies
,
hoax
,
academic journals
    Thumbnail for Remy: Affluenflammation (Red Hot Chili Peppers Californication Parody)2:43
    Remy: Affluenflammation (Red Hot Chili Peppers Californication Parody)
    ReasonVids
    1064 views
    Thumbnail for How can I talk politics with my earnest lefty friends without them screaming at me?2:35
    How can I talk politics with my earnest lefty friends without them screaming at me?
    ReasonVids
    1014 views
    Thumbnail for Rand-O-Rama: The Long Shelf Life of Ayn Rand's Legacy3:51
    Rand-O-Rama: The Long Shelf Life of Ayn Rand's Legacy
    ReasonVids
    1033 views
    Thumbnail for NEW SCENES & CLIPS! | JURASSIC WORLD REBIRTH1:32
    NEW SCENES & CLIPS! | JURASSIC WORLD REBIRTH
    invidious
    101 views
    Thumbnail for Have you guys seen the new submersible scooter? Deep sea driving FTW0:08
    Have you guys seen the new submersible scooter? Deep sea driving FTW
    bestofupgoat
    537 views
    Thumbnail for Asian woman admits she wants to commit the white genocide0:51
    Asian woman admits she wants to commit the white genocide
    bestofvoatxyz
    805 views
    Thumbnail for 🔵Leo the Truck SEASON 2! Car cartoons full episodes - Leo the Truck LIVE. | Clever Cars1:00
    🔵Leo the Truck SEASON 2! Car cartoons full episodes - Leo the Truck LIVE. | Clever Cars
    invidious
    391 views
    Thumbnail for Democratic Debate Cocktails1:15
    Democratic Debate Cocktails
    ReasonVids
    859 views
    Thumbnail for Margaret Sanger Was Anti-Abortion!?!? Peter Bagge on Planned Parenthood, Eugenics, and "Woman Rebel"6:22
    Margaret Sanger Was Anti-Abortion!?!? Peter Bagge on Planned Parenthood, Eugenics, and "Woman Rebel"
    ReasonVids
    932 views
    Thumbnail for Dating in the Atlasphere: Joshua Zader Brings Love to Ayn Rand's Fans9:59
    Dating in the Atlasphere: Joshua Zader Brings Love to Ayn Rand's Fans
    ReasonVids
    960 views
    Thumbnail for Lemmy is fucking Legend0:55
    Lemmy is fucking Legend
    bestofupgoat
    439 views
    Thumbnail for Jews seethe at anything beautiful0:08
    Jews seethe at anything beautiful
    bestofvoatxyz
    2791 views
    Thumbnail for Dissolving all European nations via mass migration was the intended purpose of the EU all along.1:55
    Dissolving all European nations via mass migration was the intended purpose of the EU all along.
    bestofvoatxyz
    539 views
    Thumbnail for Russell's Paradox - a simple explanation of a profound problem | Jeffrey Kaplan28:28
    Russell's Paradox - a simple explanation of a profound problem | Jeffrey Kaplan
    invidious
    212 views
    Thumbnail for ABC World News Tonight with David Muir Full Broadcast - March 24, 2025 | ABC News19:39
    ABC World News Tonight with David Muir Full Broadcast - March 24, 2025 | ABC News
    invidious
    107 views
    Thumbnail for Just Stop Oil had their own event ruined by counterprotesters armed with balloon mounted rape alarms0:38
    Just Stop Oil had their own event ruined by counterprotesters armed with balloon mounted rape alarms
    bestofvoatxyz
    510 views
    Thumbnail for Fallout's 'Invincible' Sentry Bot | Uranium Fever0:42
    Fallout's 'Invincible' Sentry Bot | Uranium Fever
    invidious
    142 views
    Thumbnail for "it is also a bit insulting to women who have truly been raped." - AugustineOfHippo2 1:00
    "it is also a bit insulting to women who have truly been raped." - AugustineOfHippo2
    bestofvoatxyz
    1055 views
    Thumbnail for 1ミリだけ理解したのでバーニス引く | Mハシ2:52:37
    1ミリだけ理解したのでバーニス引く | Mハシ
    invidious
    238 views
    Thumbnail for Get revived 0:45
    Get revived
    bestofupgoat
    367 views
    Thumbnail for CATO's David Boaz on What America Can (and Shouldn't) Learn From the French Revolution6:49
    CATO's David Boaz on What America Can (and Shouldn't) Learn From the French Revolution
    ReasonVids
    942 views
    Thumbnail for 47 Ways to Say "IRS" ... What do those initials really stand for?1:40
    47 Ways to Say "IRS" ... What do those initials really stand for?
    ReasonVids
    848 views
    Thumbnail for Delete your account 0:12
    Delete your account
    bestofupgoat
    129 views
    Thumbnail for Surgical Note Flap 🎶 #goodtoknow #funfacts #suturing #surgery #vet #medicine #surgeon #surgeonlife | Vetventures0:31
    Surgical Note Flap 🎶 #goodtoknow #funfacts #suturing #surgery #vet #medicine #surgeon #surgeonlife | Vetventures
    invidious
    159 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
john stossel
,
grievance studies
,
hoax
,
academic journals
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle