HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Hospital Technicians Ignore Copyright Law to Fight COVID-19

Views: 248
Hospital techs have turned to a decentralized information-sharing network to repair essential #COVID-19 equipment. Manufacturers have fought to stop them, on the grounds that they're violating copyright laws.

#coronavirus #biomed
------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV?subconfirmation=1
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason

Reason is the leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------

Dressed in his blue medical mask and scrubs, Justin Barbour looks like a doctor on a break from treating COVID-19 patients. He's actually a biomedical technician, or BMET—someone who fixes medical devices. He's on staff at a Houston hospital that he asked that we keep anonymous.

Barbour's job has suddenly become dangerous. "If one of us gets sick, then, obviously, multiple technicians in a room, somebody else is probably gonna get sick, and you could take down a whole hospital just by taking down your biomed staff," he tells Reason.

Barbour, who has been working as a BMET for over a decade, often uses service manuals when repairing equipment, but he lacks a lot of essential documentation. So he turns to online forums and relies on his intuition. During the COVID-19 pandemic, BMETs have turned especially often to this decentralized information-sharing network to repair essential hospital equipment. But they've been using it for years, trading information on Reddit, Facebook, and websites like MedWrench and DotMed.

Medical device manufacturers have responded by imposing software locks, proprietary code, and requirements that users obtain special authorizations. They've also fought against DIY repair services in court. So biomedical technicians have had to think especially creatively—because in a pandemic, one broken machine could be the difference between life and death.

Kyle Wiens, the CEO and founder of the third-party repair company iFixIt, says medical device companies have adopted certain tactics pioneered by Apple.

"Well, we'll sell it to you, but we're not going to let you service it," he says. "We want to be the ones to service it."

Manufacturers frequently claim that the information in manuals is their intellectual property—a result of broadly written copyright laws that date back to the 1990s. These were intended to protect the music and film industries from pirates, which were taking their work and sharing it first through physical bootlegs and then online. 

But in the 2000s, software began to get integrated into phones, household items, cars, farming equipment, and medical devices too. Manufacturers claimed that copyright laws established that they're the only ones the law permits to repair consumer devices.

"There are some manufacturers that won't even sell us parts. It's proprietary and we have no access to it," says Barbour.

BMETs around the world began to rely on Frankshospitalworkshop.com, a website started by a technician in Tanzania named Frank. Frank (who kept his last name private) was having trouble servicing medical devices that had been donated to hospitals in Africa, since he lacked the proprietary keys to make them useable. He figured other people might be in his same position, so he started a website where he posted manuals and wrote about how the equipment worked.

Frank's site was, "from my experience, the most comprehensive, most used resource for medical service information," says Wiens.

Then manufacturers started sending Frank takedown requests. Now, when businesses forbid certain downloads of manuals, his site is limited to featuring the companies' names.

A right-to-repair movement has been fighting to change federal copyright law—or to pass state-level laws that let people fix their own devices. But medical device companies fought back with letters to lawmakers, saying right-to-repair laws could endanger the lives of patients if devices were fixed improperly by untrained personnel.

The trade association AdvaMed, which represents medical device companies, has even lobbied the Food and Drug Administration to regulate third-party device repairs. But after the agency did an assessment in 2018, it concluded that third parties provide high-quality, safe, and effective servicing of medical devices.

iFixit recently announced an initiative to begin collecting service manuals and information about medical devices on its website. They are looking for more info, as well as for people to help organize the information for BMETs.

Produced by Paul Detrick

Watercolor paper: ID 126796034 © Dmytro Synelnychenko | Dreamstime.com; Architect blueprint; Credit: ID 177025853 © Jelena Okjan | Dreamstime.com
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for How China Corrupted the World Health Organization's Response to COVID-195:50
How China Corrupted the World Health Organization's Response to COVID-19
ReasonVids
262 views
Thumbnail for Save Yourself From Marriage | Popp Culture19:43
Save Yourself From Marriage | Popp Culture
Terrence Popp
1067 views
Thumbnail for Does the Left Care About Workers?9:56
Does the Left Care About Workers?
AmericanRenaissance
876 views
Thumbnail for The Dutch aren't happy about Islam taking over the Netherlands1:57
The Dutch aren't happy about Islam taking over the Netherlands
bestofvoatxyz
250 views
Thumbnail for Protesters storm the presidential palace in Sri Lanka's capital.0:53
Protesters storm the presidential palace in Sri Lanka's capital.
bestofvoatxyz
198 views
Thumbnail for Meet the Trans Activists Fighting for Sex Worker Freedom9:07
Meet the Trans Activists Fighting for Sex Worker Freedom
ReasonVids
250 views
Thumbnail for Curb your NASA0:56
Curb your NASA
x0x7
842 views
Thumbnail for Oregon Legalizes a Breakthrough Treatment: Magic Mushrooms7:13
Oregon Legalizes a Breakthrough Treatment: Magic Mushrooms
ReasonVids
237 views
Thumbnail for The First Presidential Debate in 3 Minutes3:17
The First Presidential Debate in 3 Minutes
ReasonVids
249 views
Thumbnail for Kennedy on Whitney Houston, Adele, &...Michelle Obama?2:59
Kennedy on Whitney Houston, Adele, &...Michelle Obama?
ReasonVids
210 views
Thumbnail for Milwaukee Taxi Rally and Press Conference (April 16, 2013)8:19
Milwaukee Taxi Rally and Press Conference (April 16, 2013)
IJvids
281 views
Thumbnail for Reason AMA: Impeachment, Cocktails, Debt, New Zealand, Justin Amash, Prog Rock, Libraries, and More1:34:24
Reason AMA: Impeachment, Cocktails, Debt, New Zealand, Justin Amash, Prog Rock, Libraries, and More
ReasonVids
251 views
Thumbnail for Larry King on Drugs, Cryonics, Airplane Sex Orgies, & Half-Libertarianism31:45
Larry King on Drugs, Cryonics, Airplane Sex Orgies, & Half-Libertarianism
ReasonVids
237 views
Thumbnail for Schwarze Sonne1:30
Schwarze Sonne
bestofvoatxyz
289 views
Thumbnail for Stossel: Ayn Rand–The Author People Love to Hate4:50
Stossel: Ayn Rand–The Author People Love to Hate
ReasonVids
269 views
Thumbnail for RaceJam13:21
RaceJam
murdochmurdoch
817 views
Thumbnail for Raw Footage: "Anti-Racist" Terrorism Caught on Video2:44
Raw Footage: "Anti-Racist" Terrorism Caught on Video
AmericanRenaissance
666 views
Thumbnail for CBD Is Still Banned in States With Legal Weed4:37
CBD Is Still Banned in States With Legal Weed
ReasonVids
277 views
Thumbnail for Chicago man points gun at news crew in broad daylight during live shot about rising crime0:49
Chicago man points gun at news crew in broad daylight during live shot about rising crime
bestofvoatxyz
251 views
Thumbnail for Seagull fishing0:05
Seagull fishing
bestofvoatxyz
308 views
Thumbnail for Remy: People are Outraged!1:41
Remy: People are Outraged!
ReasonVids
256 views
Thumbnail for 2000 Mules1:00
2000 Mules
x0x7
840 views
Thumbnail for 7 Things You Should Know About Free Speech in Schools: Free Speech Rules (Episode 1)3:40
7 Things You Should Know About Free Speech in Schools: Free Speech Rules (Episode 1)
ReasonVids
245 views

points

Permalink
Reply
reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv, right to repair, apple teardown, apple, covid19, coronavirus
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle