HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

How NYC's Landmarks Act Bulldozed the Future

Views: 1004
Once upon a time New York City's builders blithely turned spectacular monuments into dust. Henry James complained about Manhattan’s "restless renewals,” but in the old days nostalgia was for writers and poets. Developers were preoccupied with building the future.

This ethos of creative destruction allowed New York to become the world’s preeminent city. And then fifty years ago this Sunday, Mayor Robert F. Wagner signed the Landmarks Preservation Act. The law made it illegal to destroy any structure that the city’s planning elite deem too important not to save. Today almost a third of the buildings in Manhattan, and more than 33,000 structures citywide, may as well be encased in a life-sized historical diorama.

To illustrate the damage done by this law, let’s imagine that the Landmarks Act had been passed not in 1965, but in 1865, when the spire of Trinity Church still towered over Lower Manhattan. Modern New York wouldn’t exist.

Consider Henry Hardenbergh’s original Waldorf-Astoria, which was an architectural masterpiece and Manhattan’s leading luxury hotel. If the Landmarks Commission had been around in the Jazz Age, surely it would have protected this great structure — and then it never could have been torn down to build the Empire State Building, which occupies the exact same spot.

If the landmarks commission had been around to save architect Stanford White’s majestic Madison Square Garden, the second of four structures with that name, Cass Gilbert’s New York Life Insurance Building couldn't have replaced it. Forget about the hustle of Midtown Manhattan—this entire block would still be home to Columbia University’s pre-1897 campus. The old London Terrace wouldn’t have cleared a path for the new London Terrace, instead of the Woolworth Building, Philip Hone's luxurious townhouse would still stand here right here next to the old American Hotel, and we might still have this old church instead of the celebrated Met Life Tower.

The landmarks commission not only protects individual buildings, but also 114 districts, meaning entire neighborhoods are essentially frozen in time. Manhattan’s Upper West Side became a landmark district in 1990, but what if it had earned that distinction in 1890, to preserve its Gilded Age character? These hulking apartment buildings never would have replaced the distinguished brownstones and mansions that once occupied these blocks. The district certainly would have been expanded one block west to include The Apthorp House, which quartered General Washington among other colonial bigwigs and would still stand right here near 90th Street and Columbus Avenue.

Before landmarking, sure there were plenty of great buildings replaced by plane jane skyscrapers, but that’s also part of how cities grow and evolve. For example, would New York really be better off if Temple Emanu-el still stood right off Times Square?

In 1847, native New Yorker Washington Irving reflected with nostalgia on growing up in a city that was “a mere corner” of what it had become, and that corner “all changed, pulled to pieces.” This 50th anniversary of the landmarks preservation act is an opportunity to mourn the opposite: all the invisible buildings that will never exist because of a misguided law. What if an earlier generation had outlawed the rise of skyscrapers and spread of asphalt pavement? Washington Irving would still feel right at home.

Video written and edited by Jim Epstein.

3 minutes and 30 seconds.

Go to http://reason.com/reasontv for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube Channel to receive automatic notifications when new material goes live.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Conservative Artist Sabo: "My focus was to be mean, nasty, and just as bad as Bill Maher"6:59
Conservative Artist Sabo: "My focus was to be mean, nasty, and just as bad as Bill Maher"
ReasonVids
890 views
Thumbnail for Spin Control Happening Now. Propaganda Getting Ahead of the Story on Flu Deaths.  Influenza cases nosedive by 98% across the globe.0:33
Spin Control Happening Now. Propaganda Getting Ahead of the Story on Flu Deaths. Influenza cases nosedive by 98% across the globe.
bestofsaidit
2687 views
Thumbnail for The Mystery of the Missing Baby Formula4:07
The Mystery of the Missing Baby Formula
ReasonVids
965 views
Thumbnail for Silicon Valley: A Shocking Lack of Diversity7:43
Silicon Valley: A Shocking Lack of Diversity
AmericanRenaissance
1371 views
Thumbnail for Elizabeth Warren's Plan To Cancel Student Debt Helps the Well-Off2:48
Elizabeth Warren's Plan To Cancel Student Debt Helps the Well-Off
ReasonVids
892 views
Thumbnail for Family Farmers Fight Michigan Township For Their Animals5:39
Family Farmers Fight Michigan Township For Their Animals
ReasonVids
976 views
Thumbnail for Timothy P. Carney on "Obamanomics": Crony Capitalism as Progressive Reform8:52
Timothy P. Carney on "Obamanomics": Crony Capitalism as Progressive Reform
ReasonVids
892 views
Thumbnail for Another French civilian killed by the occupying Islamic Army in the Battle of Paris0:28
Another French civilian killed by the occupying Islamic Army in the Battle of Paris
bestofvoatxyz
465 views
Thumbnail for Situational phone awareness0:12
Situational phone awareness
bestofupgoat
235 views
Thumbnail for Cops Against the Drug War: Jerry Cameron of LEAP6:06
Cops Against the Drug War: Jerry Cameron of LEAP
ReasonVids
856 views
Thumbnail for Teclis is a search engine for finding interesting, unique results on 'clean' websites. [interactive]1:00
Teclis is a search engine for finding interesting, unique results on 'clean' websites. [interactive]
bestofsaidit
961 views
Thumbnail for Carteles Unidos leader beat to death by local townfolk.0:14
Carteles Unidos leader beat to death by local townfolk.
LibertyIsTheLaw
811 views
Thumbnail for Separation Is the Solution9:15
Separation Is the Solution
AmericanRenaissance
1380 views
Thumbnail for Remy: Trump-Biden Debate Rap1:16
Remy: Trump-Biden Debate Rap
ReasonVids
943 views
Thumbnail for Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 8)2:33
Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 8)
ReasonVids
906 views
Thumbnail for Neuroeconomist Paul J. Zak  on Markets and the "Molecule of Love"9:46
Neuroeconomist Paul J. Zak on Markets and the "Molecule of Love"
ReasonVids
775 views
Thumbnail for PayPal's misinformation fine an "error"? || Jeffrey Tucker & Radix Verum (47:53) ~ Alison Morrow47:53
PayPal's misinformation fine an "error"? || Jeffrey Tucker & Radix Verum (47:53) ~ Alison Morrow
bestofsaidit
789 views
Thumbnail for Virginia Postrel on Oscar Glamour, Chris Christie, and Whether J.Lo Could be Obama's Mentor10:43
Virginia Postrel on Oscar Glamour, Chris Christie, and Whether J.Lo Could be Obama's Mentor
ReasonVids
850 views
Thumbnail for *DIY Craft Ideas* How to make the "Happy Merchant" puppet with a rubber glove1:07
*DIY Craft Ideas* How to make the "Happy Merchant" puppet with a rubber glove
bestofvoatxyz
1148 views
Thumbnail for Exclusive: Barack Obama Talks Harry Reid, Economy, Legacy with Reason TV1:21
Exclusive: Barack Obama Talks Harry Reid, Economy, Legacy with Reason TV
ReasonVids
794 views
Thumbnail for Iron born!0:36
Iron born!
publicfreakouts
2864 views
Thumbnail for Live Webathon Edition of the Reason Podcast! Ask Us Anything1:31:47
Live Webathon Edition of the Reason Podcast! Ask Us Anything
ReasonVids
793 views
Thumbnail for The Ten Rules of Free Speech and College Students: Free Speech Rules (Episode 7)4:26
The Ten Rules of Free Speech and College Students: Free Speech Rules (Episode 7)
ReasonVids
969 views
Thumbnail for Wende Museum: An Archive of the Cold War4:27
Wende Museum: An Archive of the Cold War
ReasonVids
843 views

points

Permalink
Reply
landmark (literature subject), new york city (city/town/village), free minds, landmarks preservation act, new york city landmarks commission, libertarianism, creative destruction
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle