HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Harbor Point and Baltimore's Taxpayer-Funded Edifice Complex

Views:1030
@ReasonVids

In Baltimore, a small, toxic spit of land that juts out into the Patapsco River is the latest battleground between the free market and government subsidies.

For 20 years, Harbor Point, a 27-acre site of an abandoned chromium factory, has been a dream in the eyes of developers. It's the last big unbuilt site on the city's waterfront and arguably the most sought-after real estate in all of Maryland.

Yes, developers have lusted after the site, but they just didn't want to have pay the full cost of, well, developing it.

In a city as desperate for growth as Baltimore, they don't have to. Baltimore's political class has committed $400 million in public subsidies to a controversial plan that supporters claim will generate 6,000 jobs and build a complex of skyscrapers, residences, and public parks that will forever transform the character of the city.

City officials believe the $1.8 billion-dollar project will spark an economic turnaround. Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake considers Harbor Point a "once-in-a-generation opportunity" to reverse the half-century-long exodus of residents and businesses that have hollowed out Baltimore. Rawlings-Blake and developer Michael Beatty have campaigned relentlessly for the plan, offering promises of urban renewal and jobs in a city with 10.3 percent unemployment.

Yet Baltimore's citizens aren't convinced. The public hearings and frequent street demonstrations outside City Hall have revealed a tale of two cities: sweetheart deals for the well-connected along the waterfront and decades of neglect for the majority of its blue collar residents. The subsidies are a major sticking point, as is the use of an Enterprise Zone for the benefit of wealthy residents. Tax increment financing, known as TIF, will exempt the developer from taxation for a decade. To many residents, Harbor Point is just the latest example of socializing risk and privatizing gain.

Why are the public coffers wide open to wealthy developers? That's the way business has always been done, in Baltimore and elsewhere. Just upriver from Harbor Point, the city's famed Inner Harbor is the result of similar top-down, heavily subsidized development. Decades ago, city politicians spent billions to sweep away Baltimore's crumbling industrial-age infrastructure, replacing it with office towers, popular chain restaurants, museums, and an aquarium, all of which attracts millions of tourists, year after year.

More than just creating a pleasure for daytrippers, the development of the Inner Harbor set a precedent for the nation, as other cities rushed to make their own versions of the scene. In Baltimore, developers lobby politicians for special deals. If they don't get what they want, they give themselves a tax cut by moving their business to the surrounding county, where property taxes are much lower than in Baltimore proper. It's a dynamic that's left large sections of the city abandoned, with only a few tax-exempt institutions such as Johns Hopkins University and the Catholic Church continuing to thrive.

Even the widely praised Inner Harbor has failed to stanch the flow of 300,000 residents who've left Baltimore since 1960. Instead of revitalizing the city's fortunes, the rise of the waterfront has paralleled the decline of basic city functions. Violent crime remains high, public schools underperform, and the cityscape is blighted by the presence of tens of thousands of vacant buildings.

Ironically, the Harbor Point project has overcorme every political obstacle in its way, only to be put on hold pending an environmental review of hexavalent chromium in the soil. Despite that delay, developers and their friends in City Hall remain confident that the project will soon be moving forward and that it will both revive Baltimore's fortunes and the reputation of planners who push corporate welfare. It will likely take a decade before the project is up and running and the rest of us learn whether Harbor Point is just another tax-aided mega-project that fails to provide the economic stimulus its backers promise.

Runs about 6 minutes.

Produced, shot, edited, written, and narrated by Todd Krainin.

Go to http://reason.com/reasontv/2014/01/08/baltimores-edifice-complex for downloadable versions and subscribe to ReasonTV's YouTube Channel to receive notifications when new material goes live.

baltimore (city/town/village)
,
harbor point
,
inner harbor (neighborhood)
,
stephanie rawlings-blake (lawyer)
,
antero pietila
,
tax increment financing
,
michael beatty
,
taxation in the united states (literature subject)
,
urban planning (literary genre)
,
maryland (us state)
,
harbor east (neighborhood)
    Thumbnail for The Dumbest New Ban in 2014: Incandescent Light Bulbs2:30
    The Dumbest New Ban in 2014: Incandescent Light Bulbs
    ReasonVids
    986 views
    Thumbnail for If They’re Gonna Steal All That Deodorant, They Could At Least Use It Sometime.1:00
    If They’re Gonna Steal All That Deodorant, They Could At Least Use It Sometime.
    AOUisgay
    1007 views
    Thumbnail for What Millennials Think About Politics7:04
    What Millennials Think About Politics
    ReasonVids
    941 views
    Thumbnail for Joel Kotkin: Why America Will Still Lead the World in 20509:36
    Joel Kotkin: Why America Will Still Lead the World in 2050
    ReasonVids
    852 views
    Thumbnail for Greg Gutfeld: The Joy of Hate, Liberal Speech Police, & Conservative Punks10:18
    Greg Gutfeld: The Joy of Hate, Liberal Speech Police, & Conservative Punks
    ReasonVids
    1035 views
    Thumbnail for Interview 1763 - Nudge, Nudge, Wink, Wink - #NewWorldNextWeek20:54
    Interview 1763 - Nudge, Nudge, Wink, Wink - #NewWorldNextWeek
    corbettreport_uo
    725 views
    Thumbnail for Cheer up, wagie! Only 30 more years to go! 1:00
    Cheer up, wagie! Only 30 more years to go!
    bestofupgoat
    421 views
    Thumbnail for Adolf Hitler Speech on Freemasonry, Jews6:46
    Adolf Hitler Speech on Freemasonry, Jews
    NachtWaffen
    944 views
    Thumbnail for When the S.H.T.F. and It's Time to G.T.F.O. | Live From The Lair25:49
    When the S.H.T.F. and It's Time to G.T.F.O. | Live From The Lair
    Terrence Popp
    2106 views
    Thumbnail for Recreating Minecraft from 1D to 4D | Digital Secrets7:31
    Recreating Minecraft from 1D to 4D | Digital Secrets
    invidious
    309 views
    Thumbnail for Ο ΠΑΟΚ είναι τώρα η Σίτι της Ελλάδας, χρυσάφι στα πόδια του Μπακασέτα από τον Παναθηναϊκό | SPORT241:29:23
    Ο ΠΑΟΚ είναι τώρα η Σίτι της Ελλάδας, χρυσάφι στα πόδια του Μπακασέτα από τον Παναθηναϊκό | SPORT24
    invidious
    321 views
    Thumbnail for Tiffany - I Think We're Alone Now1:00
    Tiffany - I Think We're Alone Now
    bestofupgoat
    285 views
    Thumbnail for The Rooster Is Too Big | Grunt Speak Highlights5:30
    The Rooster Is Too Big | Grunt Speak Highlights
    Terrence Popp
    1145 views
    Thumbnail for Real Man of Genius: Joe Biden1:29
    Real Man of Genius: Joe Biden
    ReasonVids
    1018 views
    Thumbnail for Keeping New Hampshire Awesome: Q&A with the Free State Project President Carla Gericke6:07
    Keeping New Hampshire Awesome: Q&A with the Free State Project President Carla Gericke
    ReasonVids
    969 views
    Thumbnail for Are Republicans or Democrats More Anti-Science?8:11
    Are Republicans or Democrats More Anti-Science?
    ReasonVids
    1014 views
    Thumbnail for We Built Infinite Storage - Part 90:43
    We Built Infinite Storage - Part 9
    invidious
    79 views
    Thumbnail for Adam Bellow on The New Threats to Freedom4:44
    Adam Bellow on The New Threats to Freedom
    ReasonVids
    825 views
    Thumbnail for Are Fake Prescription Drugs Killing Us?7:03
    Are Fake Prescription Drugs Killing Us?
    ReasonVids
    801 views
    Thumbnail for The Mike Bloomberg Legacy: 12 Years of Little Tyrannies in 2 Minutes!2:07
    The Mike Bloomberg Legacy: 12 Years of Little Tyrannies in 2 Minutes!
    ReasonVids
    894 views
    Thumbnail for How to Stop the Incoming Dystopia!  FIGHT WITH ME FAM! 2:35
    How to Stop the Incoming Dystopia! FIGHT WITH ME FAM!
    bestofvoatxyz
    787 views
    Thumbnail for Odin's ravens destroy Israeli flags.2:19
    Odin's ravens destroy Israeli flags.
    AOUisgay
    554 views
    Thumbnail for #ThanksObama: 5 Scary Powers Trump Will Take Over as President4:22
    #ThanksObama: 5 Scary Powers Trump Will Take Over as President
    ReasonVids
    968 views
    Thumbnail for Woke Best Buy refuses to allow Christian employees to display crosses while requiring them to attend LGBTQ workshops.7:40
    Woke Best Buy refuses to allow Christian employees to display crosses while requiring them to attend LGBTQ workshops.
    AOUisgay
    447 views
    Thumbnail for Robert L. Bradley, Jr.: Obama's Enron Problem9:49
    Robert L. Bradley, Jr.: Obama's Enron Problem
    ReasonVids
    853 views

points

Permalink
Reply
baltimore (city/town/village)
,
harbor point
,
inner harbor (neighborhood)
,
stephanie rawlings-blake (lawyer)
,
antero pietila
,
tax increment financing
,
michael beatty
,
taxation in the united states (literature subject)
,
urban planning (literary genre)
,
maryland (us state)
,
harbor east (neighborhood)
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle