HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

How to Track COVID-19 Without Mass Surveillance

Views:1004
@ReasonVids

Apple and Google's Bluetooth-based app would reportedly be voluntary and anonymous. Privacy advocates say we should accept nothing less.


Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV?sub...

Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason


With lockdowns still in effect across the country, Americans are growing angry and restless. They want to resume their lives.

There's a system that could make that possible without increasing the spread of COVID-19. It's called "contact tracing," and it involves tracking down every in-person interaction that infected individuals have had in the preceding days, and then testing, isolating, and repeating the process. Several countries have phone applications that use Bluetooth or GPS to generate a record of whom individuals have come into contact with. In Singapore, downloading contract-tracing apps is voluntary; China and Israel use GPS to enforce mandatory quarantines and isolation.

In the U.S., Apple and Google have partnered to create a contact-tracking app for iPhones and Android devices.

But these technologies are raising serious privacy concerns.

As in other countries, Butler says, these apps would be used in conjunction with manual data collection done via interviews with public health officials. And he cautions against systems deploying any apps that use GPS to track phones, like those being used in China and Israel. This, he says, "really changes the fundamental dynamic of…the relationship between the government and the citizen."

Attorney Peter van Valkenburgh is the director of research at Coin Center, a nonprofit advocacy group for cryptocurrency and decentralized computing technologies.

He praises aspects of Singapore's Bluetooth-based TraceTogether app, which alerts users when they've been in proximity to someone who recently tested positive for COVID-19 without revealing that person's identity.

But he objects to Singapore's decision to store phone numbers in a central database.

Van Valkenburgh says that cryptocurrency developers, with their expertise in building privacy-preserving systems, could solve that problem. He cites a recent paper from the ZCash Foundation, where van Valkenburgh is a board member, that describes an anonymous and decentralized system for tracking COVID-19 test results. A record of Bluetooth handshakes would never leave a user's phone until that user reported a positive result.

"The data is not shared at all unless and in the event that you are sick," says van Valkenburgh. "And so that's how we keep it private and local."

He says another application of this technology could be in issuing "proof of immunity" certificates for individuals who have developed antibodies that protect them from COVID-19.

In this scenario, health officials would grant digital "tokens" of immunity to qualified individuals, who would then be allowed to engage in otherwise restricted activities such as going to restaurants, driving taxis, and walking around without a mask.

But truly private and decentralized systems are harder to build, and it's not clear that what van Valkenburgh envisions could be ready in the near term. Perhaps the system being developed by Apple and Google will have to be good enough.

The companies didn't respond to our interview requests. But according to the initial proposal, the system relies on Bluetooth handshakes, not GPS, to preserve location privacy. The phone identifiers recycle daily and never leave the device, unless the user reports a positive case. And the whole system is completely voluntary, with "users deciding
whether to contribute to contact tracing."

Apple and Google's software would maintain a central record with identifying information from the phones of those who test positive, but it would stop there, keeping those who were merely exposed anonymous.

Yet even allowing devices to identify each other through Bluetooth is a step toward weaker security that the companies wouldn't consider in the past.

"When we give up a little bit of privacy in favor of security or to address a crisis, we rarely gain that privacy back," says van Valkenburgh. "Maybe if it turns out that we can't build a solution that minimizes those privacy risks, we just shouldn't have this. We should just say, look, there are other ways to fight a pandemic."

The Apple-Google project is set for release in mid-May.

Produced by Zach Weissmueller. Graphics by Isaac Reese. Opening and closing graphic by Lex Villena. 

Music by Kai Engel licensed under a Creative Commons NonCommercial License. 

Photo credits: "Closed Barbershop," Marcelo Wheelock/EFE/Newscom; "Google and Apple Collaborate," Andre. M. Chang/ZUMA Press/Newscom; "Immunity Passport QR Code," Wan Quanchao/Xinua News Agency/Newscom

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
contact tracing
,
surveillance
,
apple google
,
coronavirus
,
covid19
,
immunity passports
,
privacy
,
cryptocurrency
,
zcash
,
decentralization
,
blockchain
    Thumbnail for Eisenhower's Military-Industrial Complex Speech in the Age of Coronavirus2:18
    Eisenhower's Military-Industrial Complex Speech in the Age of Coronavirus
    ReasonVids
    820 views
    Thumbnail for What DeSantis Did to Disney’s Dream City19:17
    What DeSantis Did to Disney’s Dream City
    ReasonVids
    1103 views
    Thumbnail for Reason's DC Staff - Democrats vs. Free Trade3:19
    Reason's DC Staff - Democrats vs. Free Trade
    ReasonVids
    962 views
    Thumbnail for D.C. Escalator Nightmare3:21
    D.C. Escalator Nightmare
    ReasonVids
    849 views
    Thumbnail for El sistema de salud cubano es un desastre23:19
    El sistema de salud cubano es un desastre
    ReasonVids
    964 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Let Them Vape6:16
    Stossel: Let Them Vape
    ReasonVids
    938 views
    Thumbnail for Boardwalk Violinist vs. City Hall: Challenging Ocean City's Noise Ban2:52
    Boardwalk Violinist vs. City Hall: Challenging Ocean City's Noise Ban
    ReasonVids
    1021 views
    Thumbnail for Operation Choke Point: The Government's Covert War on Small Business8:49
    Operation Choke Point: The Government's Covert War on Small Business
    ReasonVids
    894 views
    Thumbnail for When you are very prepared0:33
    When you are very prepared
    bestofvoatxyz
    911 views
    Thumbnail for Is the Tea Party Movement Racist?2:14
    Is the Tea Party Movement Racist?
    ReasonVids
    923 views
    Thumbnail for Spiked's Brendan O'Neill: "The Real Threat To Free Speech Now is Conformism and Cowardice"13:23
    Spiked's Brendan O'Neill: "The Real Threat To Free Speech Now is Conformism and Cowardice"
    ReasonVids
    945 views
    Thumbnail for Mississippi Drug War Blues (Part 2 of 3)7:05
    Mississippi Drug War Blues (Part 2 of 3)
    ReasonVids
    1001 views
    Thumbnail for 3 Reasons to Kill The Dept. of Homeland Security: It's Unnecessary, Inefficient, & Expensive.2:25
    3 Reasons to Kill The Dept. of Homeland Security: It's Unnecessary, Inefficient, & Expensive.
    ReasonVids
    913 views
    Thumbnail for Frithjof Schuon Coomer-Bait1:13
    Frithjof Schuon Coomer-Bait
    SmashTheJourgeoisie
    842 views
    Thumbnail for Environmentalists Would Buy the Land They Want to Protect, If The Government Allowed It4:38
    Environmentalists Would Buy the Land They Want to Protect, If The Government Allowed It
    ReasonVids
    875 views
    Thumbnail for Why The Future Is Better Than You Think15:33
    Why The Future Is Better Than You Think
    ReasonVids
    1032 views
    Thumbnail for Mathematician: Election numbers don’t add up2:42
    Mathematician: Election numbers don’t add up
    bestofpoal
    1878 views
    Thumbnail for Tucker Carlson's Great Replacement Theory Is Spectacularly Wrong5:12
    Tucker Carlson's Great Replacement Theory Is Spectacularly Wrong
    ReasonVids
    982 views
    Thumbnail for Concorde take off on short runway4:33
    Concorde take off on short runway
    bestofupgoat
    133 views
    Thumbnail for The Origin Of Petroleum Oil – hint: not a scarce resource8:02
    The Origin Of Petroleum Oil – hint: not a scarce resource
    bestofupgoat
    487 views
    Thumbnail for How to make roman concrete3:52
    How to make roman concrete
    bestofvoatxyz
    726 views
    Thumbnail for "Father of Video Games" Nolan Bushnell on Learning through Gaming4:34
    "Father of Video Games" Nolan Bushnell on Learning through Gaming
    ReasonVids
    1022 views
    Thumbnail for 🔴EVERY Wheels on the Bus Song LIVE! | Best Cars & Truck Videos for Kids | Best Cars and Truck Videos for Kids1:00
    🔴EVERY Wheels on the Bus Song LIVE! | Best Cars & Truck Videos for Kids | Best Cars and Truck Videos for Kids
    invidious
    284 views
    Thumbnail for Author Paul Cantor on The Economics of Literature6:44
    Author Paul Cantor on The Economics of Literature
    ReasonVids
    932 views
    Thumbnail for [2014] Obama's Full Speech To European Leaders About Russia35:35
    [2014] Obama's Full Speech To European Leaders About Russia
    AOU
    967 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
contact tracing
,
surveillance
,
apple google
,
coronavirus
,
covid19
,
immunity passports
,
privacy
,
cryptocurrency
,
zcash
,
decentralization
,
blockchain
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle