HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

NY Can’t Teach Kids to Read on $30,000 a Year

Views:1022
@ReasonVids

Time for School Choice.
------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV?subconfirmation=1
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------
One of the perennial defenses of mediocre public K-12 schools is that they just don't have enough money to work with. Liberal groups like The Center for American Progress routinely put out videos like this one denouncing the "underfunding of K-12 schools" that call for more and more money to be spent.

In New York, where I live, real per-pupil revenue has increased by a mind-boggling 68 percent between 2002 and 2019. Public schools in the Empire State are now shelling out more than $30,000 per kid. That's more than double the national average, and it doesn't even include the $16 billion extra that New York's system got in combined federal and state COVID-19 relief funding.

Yet New York's public schools are still as terrible as the Mets, the Jets, and the Giants, with only a third or fewer of students up to grade level in eighth grade reading and math, according to their scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), widely considered the gold standard for judging school outcomes. Those scores aren't much different than they were 20 years ago.

In fact, $30,000 a year puts the lie to the argument pushed by unions and progressives that more money will fix schools. More money hasn't helped the rest of the country boost their scores either. According to NAEP, whatever minor improvements in reading and math that were made for students ages 9 and 13 since the early 1970s have flattened since the early 2000s. We're paying more for the same results.

None of this is a mystery. The connection between bigger spending and good outcomes is weak at best, whether we're talking about comparisons among U.S. states or international ones. 

Certainly the new money for New York hasn't gone to fundamentally reform what gets taught, or how, or under what circumstances. According to a report on spending trends in the 21st century by my colleagues at the Reason Foundation (which publishes this website), overall teacher compensation is way up in New York, especially when it comes to benefits like health insurance and pensions, which have grown by 147 percent. Nationwide, a dozen states increased spending on benefits for teachers by over 100 percent and only three states kept the increase below 10 percent. Costs for things like administration, support staff, and transportation are up another 24 percent.

Dumping more money into a broken system is like trying to fix a leaky pipe by pouring more water into it. What needs to happen is a revolution in how education is conceived and delivered. Over the past 20 years, New York has allowed publicly funded charter schools to operate, which is a good thing because it allows for experimentation while insisting on accountability. Unlike conventional public schools that get students (and funding) assigned to them based on their addresses, charters must attract and keep students in order to stay in business. They start with zero dollars to spend. The best charters have massive wait lists even though they get less money per student than traditional public schools. Charters in New York City, for instance, get about 20 percent fewer dollars per kid than typical public schools.

But instead of expanding the number of charters, New York, like most states, caps it. According to the state's official data, there are just 359 charters compared to 4,411 public schools. Worse, New York doesn't allow education savings accounts (ESAs), tax-credit scholarships, and vouchers that would allow more families to escape traditional public schools and pick where their kids go to learn. 

Increasing the amount and variety of school choice, though, is exactly what New York and the country need to be doing (kudos to the 18 states that have started or expanded choice programs). We're not going to seriously improve educational outcomes for our kids if we don't fundamentally change how we educate them.

When you look back 20 years, virtually every other service in our lives has gone through multiple revolutions in terms of what's available and the quality of what's being offered. Public K-12 education is among the very few things that is still basically the same as it was when today's parents and grandparents were in school. The only difference is the price tag, which just keeps going up and up.

Music Credits: “Baseball,” (Instrumental Version) by Dani Jalali via Artlist; “Rancid Life,” (Short Version) by The Mind Sweepers via Artlist

Written by Nick Gillespie, Produced by Regan Taylor

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for ‘Our Children Do Not Belong to the Government’7:28
    ‘Our Children Do Not Belong to the Government’
    ReasonVids
    909 views
    Thumbnail for Rogan nails it1:29
    Rogan nails it
    bestofupgoat
    137 views
    Thumbnail for Reason Saves Cleveland: The Outtake Reel2:46
    Reason Saves Cleveland: The Outtake Reel
    ReasonVids
    909 views
    Thumbnail for 300 - MAGA Version8:04
    300 - MAGA Version
    OscarTurnerArchive
    1554 views
    Thumbnail for Releasing oil from the strategic reserve "has not had an effect really on gasoline prices...how do you increase [oil] refinery capacity?"  Biden advisor Brian Deese: "Great question."1:07
    Releasing oil from the strategic reserve "has not had an effect really on gasoline prices...how do you increase [oil] refinery capacity?" Biden advisor Brian Deese: "Great question."
    bestofvoatxyz
    1131 views
    Thumbnail for Full Version of Shawn Nee Detainment by Los Angeles Sheriff's Department Deputies26:42
    Full Version of Shawn Nee Detainment by Los Angeles Sheriff's Department Deputies
    ReasonVids
    872 views
    Thumbnail for If you don't know what a cargo cult is, you have to watch this.4:13
    If you don't know what a cargo cult is, you have to watch this.
    bestofgoatpen
    3603 views
    Thumbnail for Niglet tries an armed robbery but ends up squealing reeeee0:20
    Niglet tries an armed robbery but ends up squealing reeeee
    bestofvoatxyz
    554 views
    Thumbnail for Once upon a time, you only saw ads like this in dystopian movies from the 80's. This is creepy as fuck.0:40
    Once upon a time, you only saw ads like this in dystopian movies from the 80's. This is creepy as fuck.
    bestofpoal
    4433 views
    Thumbnail for ¿HABRÁ HOMENAJE A MODRIC Y ANCELOTTI? | Sportplus3:13:09
    ¿HABRÁ HOMENAJE A MODRIC Y ANCELOTTI? | Sportplus
    invidious
    55 views
    Thumbnail for Cops pepper spray 15 year old for taking a “defensive stance” - Welcome to Palistine America1:00
    Cops pepper spray 15 year old for taking a “defensive stance” - Welcome to Palistine America
    publicfreakouts
    852 views
    Thumbnail for Alex Epstein and his book Fossil Future fact checked. | TEACHING CLIMATE9:34
    Alex Epstein and his book Fossil Future fact checked. | TEACHING CLIMATE
    science.topic
    96 views
    Thumbnail for MUST SEE: How Bill Gates Monopolized Global Health23:56
    MUST SEE: How Bill Gates Monopolized Global Health
    corbettreport_uo
    2061 views
    Thumbnail for When Can Your Past Bar You From a Job—And When Should It?33:18
    When Can Your Past Bar You From a Job—And When Should It?
    IJvids
    961 views
    Thumbnail for The FDA Has Banned NMN Supplements! | Dr Brad Stanfield3:38
    The FDA Has Banned NMN Supplements! | Dr Brad Stanfield
    invidious
    404 views
    Thumbnail for Romanian Electricians0:46
    Romanian Electricians
    bestofupgoat
    567 views
    Thumbnail for Doctor Visit1:55
    Doctor Visit
    bestofvoatxyz
    2140 views
    Thumbnail for Super Buu vs Agent Venom - MUGEN (Gameplay) S2 • E062:07
    Super Buu vs Agent Venom - MUGEN (Gameplay) S2 • E06
    memology101
    1272 views
    Thumbnail for The Popular "Bayraktar" Song, If You Haven't Heard It Yet2:19
    The Popular "Bayraktar" Song, If You Haven't Heard It Yet
    voatcatbox
    344 views
    Thumbnail for Make no mistake, We are at war.  Act accordingly!1:31
    Make no mistake, We are at war. Act accordingly!
    bestofupgoat
    226 views
    Thumbnail for A pack of VERY good bois take a bite out of schlomo0:14
    A pack of VERY good bois take a bite out of schlomo
    bestofupgoat
    207 views
    Thumbnail for Doxxing Conspirologist’s mother (she charges 10 yuan more than Neri’s mom)0:23
    Doxxing Conspirologist’s mother (she charges 10 yuan more than Neri’s mom)
    bestofupgoat
    434 views
    Thumbnail for Is Nationwide Marijuana Legalization Just Around the Corner?18:55
    Is Nationwide Marijuana Legalization Just Around the Corner?
    ReasonVids
    900 views
    Thumbnail for 【10/14即時新聞】明年掀罷免潮?!罷樑未成 林右昌吞"三連敗"|共軍東部戰區 今展開"聯合利劍2024B軍演"|林佩潔 賴正鎧報新聞 20241014 @中天電視CtiTv | 中天新聞2:00:36
    【10/14即時新聞】明年掀罷免潮?!罷樑未成 林右昌吞"三連敗"|共軍東部戰區 今展開"聯合利劍2024B軍演"|林佩潔 賴正鎧報新聞 20241014 @中天電視CtiTv | 中天新聞
    invidious
    130 views
    Thumbnail for how i'd survive a zombie apocalypse | RoyalPear0:54
    how i'd survive a zombie apocalypse | RoyalPear
    invidious
    109 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle