HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Unions Lost a Major Battle in Their War on the Gig Economy

Views: 991
Nearly 60 percent of Californians approved a proposition to exempt Uber and Lyft from most of Assembly Bill 5.
------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV?sub...
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------
Should Americans be allowed to freelance? Progressive Democrats have been pushing legislation at the state and federal level that would force gig economy companies like Uber and Lyft to make all of their independent contractors full-time employees.

But that movement had a major setback in the 2020 election when California voters came out in favor of Proposition 22, which severely limits the impact of a 2019 law that, as it was originally written, could have wiped out the state's freelance economy.

The law, Assembly Bill 5, had already been weakened by several carve-outs. But Prop 22 deals a massive blow to A.B. 5's original intent because it means that Uber and Lyft drivers will be mostly exempt from its requirements.

Back in May, Democratic presidential contender and former Vice President Joe Biden called attempts "to gut" A.B. 5 "unacceptable," urging Californians to vote no. Nevertheless, in this overwhelmingly blue state, almost 60 percent approved Prop 22 at the ballot box.

When Reason covered A.B. 5 earlier this year, its most vocal opponents turned out to be freelance writers.

Randy Dotinga, a left-leaning San Diego-based freelance journalist, said at the time that "this is a really unusual position for people in creative fields like freelance journalism to be in…By nature, most of us are liberal, progressive Democrats. We're also pro-union for the most part. And here we are saying this goes too far."

Conservative journalist Kassy Dillon agreed, calling A.B. 5's supporters "people who don't get it…They're activists. They're cutting people off from opportunity."

It didn't occur to California lawmakers that many freelancers prefer the flexibility that comes with being an independent contractor.

Like many other companies, Vox, which supported A.B. 5, ended up cutting its staff of independent contractors because it couldn't afford to bring them on full-time.

Labor activists and progressive lawmakers were, in effect, deciding on behalf of workers that if they couldn't have a full-time job with benefits, they would be better off having no job at all.

"For us, this is about focusing on ensuring that jobs are good jobs," Coral Itzcalli, a spokesperson for Mobile Workers Alliance, which is trying to unionize the industry, told Reason. "If we have one or 100 jobs that are paying less than minimum wage, there is absolutely no benefit. I would rather have 50 good jobs than 100 bad paying jobs."

Although the law applied to freelance writers, its real targets were gig economy startups like Uber, Lyft, and DoorDash. Uber and Lyft said that if A.B. 5 were enforced as originally written, it would cause hundreds of thousands of drivers their jobs, and may have even forced the companies to shut down operations in California.

Williamson M. Evers, a political scientist and senior fellow at the Independent Institute, a libertarian think tank, sees A.B. 5 as a trial run for national legislation with the same aim. "Basically this is a unions versus independent workers struggle. The unions are declining, except public employee unions. And so they're desperately thrashing around for people that they could organize."

The ridesharing companies spent over $200 million on Prop 22, trying to convince California voters to exclude them from A.B. 5, while the law's opponents spent roughly $20 million. Proponents of A.B. 5 attribute their defeat to the fact that they were outspent, but Evers is skeptical.

"I don't think money determines political outcomes. In 2016, Hillary Clinton vastly outspent Donald Trump and she lost anyway. It's not really determinative. The Prop 22 people had the better argument, and they took advantage of what they had to make their case to the people."

"I hope that there's some way that the labor movement can look at freelancers of all types, and say this is a valid, honorable profession," Dotinga said. "We are workers, too. And many of us choose this field. We are not exploited. We don't exploit others. We're not scabs. We're small businesses and we deserve to be treated that way."

"The real exploitation is the thing that forces people to work hours they don't want to work and in ways they don't want to work," says Evers.

Produced and narrated by John Osterhoudt.

Photos: Rick Wilking/REUTERS/Newscom; Sam Hodgson/ZUMA Press/Newscom; MIKE BLAKE/REUTERS/Newscom; LUCY NICHOLSON/REUTERS/Newscom; Deccio Serrano/ZUMA Press/Newscom;
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for What's Next for the Libertarian Party After Jo Jorgensen Got 1%?9:28
What's Next for the Libertarian Party After Jo Jorgensen Got 1%?
ReasonVids
930 views
Thumbnail for The End of Play: Why Kids Need Unstructured Time30:34
The End of Play: Why Kids Need Unstructured Time
ReasonVids
867 views
Thumbnail for Bitcoin and the Constitution:  Is Code Speech?39:14
Bitcoin and the Constitution: Is Code Speech?
IJvids
884 views
Thumbnail for Stop Subsidizing Sports!5:02
Stop Subsidizing Sports!
ReasonVids
862 views
Thumbnail for Prosecuting Trump is Backfiring - Blacks are Wide Awake1:41
Prosecuting Trump is Backfiring - Blacks are Wide Awake
bestofupgoat
459 views
Thumbnail for No Man’s Land: Why Military Recruiting Has Tanked | Grunt Speak25:44
No Man’s Land: Why Military Recruiting Has Tanked | Grunt Speak
Terrence Popp
796 views
Thumbnail for Biden Nukes the Insurrection Narrative | Grunt Speak Live2:31:54
Biden Nukes the Insurrection Narrative | Grunt Speak Live
Terrence Popp
1101 views
Thumbnail for Trump Denounces Racism in Charlottesville. Too Little, Too Late.3:25
Trump Denounces Racism in Charlottesville. Too Little, Too Late.
ReasonVids
1060 views
Thumbnail for Nurse Practitioners Can Make Health Care Cheaper (and Doctors Want to Stop Them)5:09
Nurse Practitioners Can Make Health Care Cheaper (and Doctors Want to Stop Them)
ReasonVids
944 views
Thumbnail for Earmarks: The Alien Menace5:38
Earmarks: The Alien Menace
ReasonVids
838 views
Thumbnail for MC Hawking - Bitchslap | Brash Music4:26
MC Hawking - Bitchslap | Brash Music
invidious
482 views
Thumbnail for CPAC 2012: Occupy Protesters & Anti-gay Activists4:44
CPAC 2012: Occupy Protesters & Anti-gay Activists
ReasonVids
831 views
Thumbnail for The Big Bailout5:16
The Big Bailout
ReasonVids
873 views
Thumbnail for Running a Food Truck Shouldn’t be this Hard1:41
Running a Food Truck Shouldn’t be this Hard
IJvids
851 views
Thumbnail for Does the US Have Political Prisoners?9:40
Does the US Have Political Prisoners?
AmericanRenaissance
796 views
Thumbnail for Stossel: Super Bowl of Welfare4:18
Stossel: Super Bowl of Welfare
ReasonVids
706 views
Thumbnail for Walt Disney Classic The Lion King VHS0:05
Walt Disney Classic The Lion King VHS
gggknezz123
301 views
Thumbnail for Why You Should Support Reason: Al Sharpton Edition0:31
Why You Should Support Reason: Al Sharpton Edition
ReasonVids
812 views
Thumbnail for Can Computers Replace Teachers?: Reason's Katherine Mangu-Ward21:38
Can Computers Replace Teachers?: Reason's Katherine Mangu-Ward
ReasonVids
882 views
Thumbnail for The Inmates Are Running Venezuela’s Prisons. They've Created Autonomous Micro-Dictatorships.16:04
The Inmates Are Running Venezuela’s Prisons. They've Created Autonomous Micro-Dictatorships.
ReasonVids
852 views
Thumbnail for Bitcoin's Censorship-Resistance Test: Canada13:24
Bitcoin's Censorship-Resistance Test: Canada
ReasonVids
884 views
Thumbnail for TEKNEIN | Nas Waltz (Untermix) remix - Gypsycrusader theme4:56
TEKNEIN | Nas Waltz (Untermix) remix - Gypsycrusader theme
AOU
1346 views
Thumbnail for New World Order | Megadeth - Topic3:57
New World Order | Megadeth - Topic
invidious
44 views
Thumbnail for Why the Middle Class is Better Off Than You Think4:58
Why the Middle Class is Better Off Than You Think
ReasonVids
914 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian, reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle