HomeUploadUpload DirectRandomAbouttheme toggle

Drop That Red Cup! City Criminalizes College Parties

Views: 208
College life may include studying late in the library, going to class in pajamas, ultimate Frisbee, or engaging in an age-old college tradition: the college house party.

"We've had a couple here, My roommate really likes the Risky Business theme." says Nick Quandt, a resident of Orange, California, and a student at Chapman University. "Sometimes you'll get back to the house around nine o'clock and there'll be a couple freshman at your house that think the party starts at nine o'clock and nobody else gets there till eleven."

The parties happen as often as you'd expect in a college town, but not everyone is happy about them. Orange residents at a city council meeting April 12, 2016, described college students urinating and vomiting in front yards that were not their own and noise that went well into the night. Even city council members like Fred Whitaker have experienced the behavior.

"You had probably 400 kids that were in a backyard about 3 blocks from my house," said Whitaker, who along with the rest of the city council helped to pass a new ordinance that tightens rules on loud and unruly parties which, according to Whitaker, are so bad they affect neighbors' ability to enjoy their own property. He says it come down to the question of "How do you create incentives to not have people affect other people's rights?"

The ordinance sounds reasonable on its face (Who wants someone peeing in their front yard?), until you look at the details. The ordinance makes it unlawful for any person to be "present at, attend or participate in a loud or unruly gathering," and to do so in a way that "contributes" to the gathering. According to city code, the punishment could be hundreds of dollars worth of fines and the violation amounts to a misdemeanor.

"There are important consequences to a misdemeanor conviction or any criminal record," says Erwin Chemerinsky, Dean of the University of California, Irvine, Law School. "This isn't gentle by any means."

Wayne Winthers, the city attorney for Orange gave a little more insight into what contributing might mean at the city council meeting, April 12, saying "The individual has to be doing something more than just walking by at the time ... Some indication that they are contributing to the party. They may be with their red cup or they're jumping up and down to the music or whatever it might be, but, something so an officer has to observe something more than just mere presence."

So holding a red cup or dancing at a loud or unruly party could mean you are guilty of a crime? The ordinance didn't seem specific enough to answer "no" to this sort of question. "It's just so vague," says Quandt. "And also ... blatantly directed at college students."

"I think the reason that you don't want it to be that specific is because the more specific you get it, the more you can game the system," says Whitaker. Instead, the ordinance gives discretion to the officers on the scene to decide if someone is participating in the party. "It's a 'when you see it, you know it' situation," says Whitaker.

"To say we will leave it to the discretion of the officer to decide what's unruly by itself says this ordinance violates the constitution," says Chemerinsky, who also points out that part of the problem with the ordinance is that it is not clearly written, "It says 'to do so in a manner that contributes to the loud or unruly gathering.' I assume just by being there you're contributing to the gathering. Is more required than that? The ordinance doesn't say."

That lack of specificity means practically anyone could be guilty of a criminal behavior. Chemerinsky says that under the constitution, any law must be clear as to what is allowed and what is prohibited. "In fact one of the concerns is that officers would have too much discretion and be able to use it in a discriminatory way."

Read more at http://www.reason.com/reasontv

Music by Goodbye Kumiko, Bird Creek, Kevin MacLeod, The Underscore Orkestra.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Mike Pence is a Conservative Statist: Judge Andrew Napolitano on Trump's VP Pick0:43
Mike Pence is a Conservative Statist: Judge Andrew Napolitano on Trump's VP Pick
ReasonVids
185 views
Thumbnail for It's Time to Legalize Hemp! Q&A with CEO of Dr. Bronner's Magic Soaps2:59
It's Time to Legalize Hemp! Q&A with CEO of Dr. Bronner's Magic Soaps
ReasonVids
187 views
Thumbnail for The Vaccine Separated The Wheat From The Chaff7:57
The Vaccine Separated The Wheat From The Chaff
bestofvoatxyz
315 views
Thumbnail for Snorkel Respirators, 3D-Printed Masks, and Other Grassroots Efforts To Fight COVID-199:11
Snorkel Respirators, 3D-Printed Masks, and Other Grassroots Efforts To Fight COVID-19
ReasonVids
195 views
Thumbnail for Red Bull Is Disgusting. And It Perfectly Captures Why Capitalism Is So Great.34:48
Red Bull Is Disgusting. And It Perfectly Captures Why Capitalism Is So Great.
ReasonVids
193 views
Thumbnail for Inflation is Skyrocketing: Welcome to the Biden Economy! | Styxhexenhammer6668:55
Inflation is Skyrocketing: Welcome to the Biden Economy! | Styxhexenhammer666
bitchute_topics
178 views
Thumbnail for How Much is A College Football Player Worth?7:14
How Much is A College Football Player Worth?
ReasonVids
241 views
Thumbnail for Cops at Uvalde School shooting went in and took their kids out, then went back outside to keep other parents from going in and doing anything to stop the shooter0:27
Cops at Uvalde School shooting went in and took their kids out, then went back outside to keep other parents from going in and doing anything to stop the shooter
bestofvoatxyz
287 views
Thumbnail for Qualified Immunity: Explained3:03
Qualified Immunity: Explained
IJvids
228 views
Thumbnail for Five Ways the Drug War Hurts Kids: A Conversation with Neill Franklin of LEAP8:24
Five Ways the Drug War Hurts Kids: A Conversation with Neill Franklin of LEAP
ReasonVids
154 views
Thumbnail for Sons of Wichita: Q&A with Daniel Schulman About the Koch Brothers14:47
Sons of Wichita: Q&A with Daniel Schulman About the Koch Brothers
ReasonVids
158 views
Thumbnail for How Big Government Backed Bad Science Made Americans Fat18:05
How Big Government Backed Bad Science Made Americans Fat
ReasonVids
200 views
Thumbnail for The 5 Dumbest Laws Restricting the Sale of Booze3:42
The 5 Dumbest Laws Restricting the Sale of Booze
ReasonVids
170 views
Thumbnail for Fitness Crackdown: Santa Monica Gets Tough On Trainers3:56
Fitness Crackdown: Santa Monica Gets Tough On Trainers
ReasonVids
171 views
Thumbnail for Stossel: Harvard Caves to Student Mob6:30
Stossel: Harvard Caves to Student Mob
ReasonVids
222 views
Thumbnail for "Well over 50,000 fraudulent votes cast from phantom voters identified in Wisconsin More than twice the margin on Nov. 3."0:30
"Well over 50,000 fraudulent votes cast from phantom voters identified in Wisconsin More than twice the margin on Nov. 3."
bestofpoal
584 views
Thumbnail for Hasta La Vista, Arnold!: What California's Budget Mess Means for America9:57
Hasta La Vista, Arnold!: What California's Budget Mess Means for America
ReasonVids
178 views
Thumbnail for 10 Years to Life for Medical Marijuana: The Trial of Aaron Sandusky6:32
10 Years to Life for Medical Marijuana: The Trial of Aaron Sandusky
ReasonVids
174 views
Thumbnail for 3 of the Most F*cked Up Ways the Feds are Controlling Sex Work5:41
3 of the Most F*cked Up Ways the Feds are Controlling Sex Work
ReasonVids
192 views
Thumbnail for Ben Swann: Pizzagate Reality Check5:47
Ben Swann: Pizzagate Reality Check
LibertyIsTheLaw
3968 views
Thumbnail for Beware of "fellow" Patriots1:38
Beware of "fellow" Patriots
bestofvoatxyz
250 views
Thumbnail for Where are the Black Libertarians?3:11
Where are the Black Libertarians?
ReasonVids
162 views
Thumbnail for Jefferson Memorial Dance Dance Revolution - 6/4/20111:41
Jefferson Memorial Dance Dance Revolution - 6/4/2011
ReasonVids
172 views
Thumbnail for FEDS Seized Over $2 BILLION at U.S. Airports from 2000-20161:27
FEDS Seized Over $2 BILLION at U.S. Airports from 2000-2016
IJvids
212 views
Thumbnail for The Drug War in Guatemala: A Conversation with Giancarlo Ibarguen4:51
The Drug War in Guatemala: A Conversation with Giancarlo Ibarguen
ReasonVids
168 views

points

Permalink
Reply
college, party, parties, red cups, solo, orange, criminalize, house party, animal house, broken windows theory, misdemeanor, chapman university
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle