HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

In Defense of Roe

Views:912
@ReasonVids

The last 50 years have been marked by a remarkably stable social consensus balancing the rights of women and fetuses. Let's not throw that away.
----------------
https://reason.com/video/2022/05/12/in-defense-of-roe/
----------------
One of the biggest misconceptions about Roe v. Wade is that it ushered in an era of deeply divided, hyper-polarized opinions about abortion rights. Though an advocate for reproductive freedom, future Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg famously called the landmark decision a "heavy-handed judicial intervention that was difficult to justify," a ruling that "appears to have provoked, not resolved, conflict."

But that's just not true.

Regardless of heated and occasionally violent opposition from radical pro-lifers, for most Americans, Roe led to a half-century of remarkably stable cultural consensus about how to balance the rights of women with the rights of fetuses or, as pro-lifers prefer, unborn children. 

Attitudes toward abortion have stayed constant since Roe was decided, with just 19 percent of Americans agreeing that it should be banned in all circumstances, two percentage points lower than in 1975 when Gallup started asking the question. Eighty percent agree it should be legal in all or some circumstances, which is four percentage points higher than in 1975. That consistency is all the more remarkable when you realize that when Roe was decided, 30 states banned abortion completely and only 20 allowed it under some circumstances.

Roe held that the state could "could regulate (but not outlaw) abortions in the interests of the mother's health" in the second trimester of pregnancy and ban abortions only in the third trimester of pregnancy as a fetus developed more "potentiality of human life." Its successor case, Planned Parenthood v. Casey, affirmed a right to an abortion until a fetus became viable outside the womb.

Unlike slavery and civil rights, abortion is not an issue that lends itself to absolute moral clarity. There are obviously two sets of rights involved, but exactly when legal personhood for the fetus begins has always been contested, as seen in historic laws that banned abortion only after "quickening." 

The cultural genius of Roe is that it created broad parameters that reflect how we think about pregnancy and abortion: At some point during gestation, the fetus becomes a person with a right to life and liberty, but drawing that line will always be a compromise and imprecise. Honest brokers on both sides of the abortion debate will acknowledge that the opposing side has a case. 

Survey data show that Roe was remarkably effective at balancing the rights of the fetus and the mother in a way that fits with our societal values. Sixty percent of Americans support abortion in the first three months of pregnancy and only 13 percent in the final three months. Even more telling is data showing that 93 percent of abortions are performed before the 13th week of pregnancy, and just 1 percent are done after 21 weeks. 

Abortion policy is about creating a workable, pragmatic compromise that allows people to live their lives on their own terms and peaceably argue for their point of view. Ending Roe risks allowing states to outlaw abortion altogether—13 states have "trigger laws" that will automatically ban abortion if the decision is overturned—or to try and ban out-of-state travel for women seeking the procedure.

But individual freedom trumps federalism. Though abortion will never be a clear-cut issue, once we have broad societal agreement on how to delineate between the interests of the mother and the interests of the fetus, women across the country deserve basic protections for their bodily autonomy and privacy.

Keeping abortion legal for at least part of pregnancy doesn't mean that pro-lifers won't be able to reduce its incidence. The abortion rate has declined for decades despite the procedure's availability. So has the unwanted pregnancy rate. These are outcomes worth celebrating, as they reflect women being in more control of their own bodies.

Overthrowing Roe and Casey would threaten that progress and broad consensus by stoking a new culture war in which states rush to ideological extremes that run roughshod over the rights of women or fetuses, depending on the state, some of which are already trying to restrict access to their residents' ability to receive or even fund abortions performed elsewhere.

Post-Roe America would be one with fewer rights and, likely, more political division. There's no perfect policy on abortion, but in 1973, the court struck a compromise that most Americans continue to endorse. That victory, I fear, is about to be undone.

Written and narrated by Nick Gillespie. Edited by Regan Taylor.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for Libertarian PBS4:51
    Libertarian PBS
    ReasonVids
    1027 views
    Thumbnail for Too Big to Fail 2.0: This Time It's Personal Finance and Just About Everything Else8:49
    Too Big to Fail 2.0: This Time It's Personal Finance and Just About Everything Else
    ReasonVids
    920 views
    Thumbnail for Radical Pakistani Cleric Burns Couches to honour Prophet Muhammad8:30
    Radical Pakistani Cleric Burns Couches to honour Prophet Muhammad
    knockitoff
    1520 views
    Thumbnail for Zakir Naik Claims Muhammad Was a Gay Necrophile15:56
    Zakir Naik Claims Muhammad Was a Gay Necrophile
    WarmPotato
    2162 views
    Thumbnail for How To Lose A Country In 30 Days | Grunt Speak Highlights11:08
    How To Lose A Country In 30 Days | Grunt Speak Highlights
    Terrence Popp
    2109 views
    Thumbnail for E-Cigarettes and the Law: NJOY's Craig Weiss on Proposed Regulations6:59
    E-Cigarettes and the Law: NJOY's Craig Weiss on Proposed Regulations
    ReasonVids
    911 views
    Thumbnail for Perhaps that 2.8 we had yesterday should have been an 8.20:17
    Perhaps that 2.8 we had yesterday should have been an 8.2
    bestofvoatxyz
    450 views
    Thumbnail for SomePkmn-LovingDude9:13
    SomePkmn-LovingDude
    kanneknezz
    275 views
    Thumbnail for Blake Lively, Alan Arkin in 2009's The Private Lives Of Pippa Lee | 4K3:22
    Blake Lively, Alan Arkin in 2009's The Private Lives Of Pippa Lee | 4K
    invidious
    286 views
    Thumbnail for Better than being slapped in the face with a wet fish0:03
    Better than being slapped in the face with a wet fish
    bestofvoatxyz
    485 views
    Thumbnail for Biden’s phone call with Poroshenko in 2016. [They] never wanted Trump looking into Ukraine from the beginning.. which is why [They] asked them to keep quiet. He knew all along.1:02
    Biden’s phone call with Poroshenko in 2016. [They] never wanted Trump looking into Ukraine from the beginning.. which is why [They] asked them to keep quiet. He knew all along.
    AOU
    1152 views
    Thumbnail for Welcome to the Moshpit0:25
    Welcome to the Moshpit
    bestofupgoat
    272 views
    Thumbnail for Comedy, College, and the Fight to Save Free Speech: Can We Take a Joke?7:05
    Comedy, College, and the Fight to Save Free Speech: Can We Take a Joke?
    ReasonVids
    954 views
    Thumbnail for Nukes Going Off in Ukraine?? Feb. 16, 20220:19
    Nukes Going Off in Ukraine?? Feb. 16, 2022
    voatcatbox
    692 views
    Thumbnail for Cerebral Vascular accident aka CV-192:30
    Cerebral Vascular accident aka CV-19
    AOU
    1793 views
    Thumbnail for Lolipop dance1:16
    Lolipop dance
    MerkinMuffly
    10483 views
    Thumbnail for Badass danish girl, 1969...wait for it. | Jesper Nordin0:37
    Badass danish girl, 1969...wait for it. | Jesper Nordin
    invidious
    383 views
    Thumbnail for What Happens To Vac-man In a Vacuum Chamber? (Stretch Armstrong's Nemesis)! | The Action Lab9:11
    What Happens To Vac-man In a Vacuum Chamber? (Stretch Armstrong's Nemesis)! | The Action Lab
    science.topic
    95 views
    Thumbnail for 김어준의 겸손은힘들다 뉴스공장 2025년 6월 6일 금요일 [탁현민, 박수현, 박주민, 양부남, 김승원, 강유정, THE살롱, 홍사훈, 주진우, 노영희, 봉지욱, 임현정] | 김어준의 겸손은힘들다 뉴스공장3:08:18
    김어준의 겸손은힘들다 뉴스공장 2025년 6월 6일 금요일 [탁현민, 박수현, 박주민, 양부남, 김승원, 강유정, THE살롱, 홍사훈, 주진우, 노영희, 봉지욱, 임현정] | 김어준의 겸손은힘들다 뉴스공장
    invidious
    22 views
    Thumbnail for What If Hololive was a Terrible Kid's Channel? | Pipkin Pippa Ch.【Phase Connect】7:05
    What If Hololive was a Terrible Kid's Channel? | Pipkin Pippa Ch.【Phase Connect】
    invidious
    524 views
    Thumbnail for Car Out10:00
    Car Out
    stumble_bro
    442 views
    Thumbnail for This Track is HAZARDOUS! | TwoFace11:50
    This Track is HAZARDOUS! | TwoFace
    doom.topic
    465 views
    Thumbnail for Uber and the Great Taxicab Collapse7:44
    Uber and the Great Taxicab Collapse
    ReasonVids
    967 views
    Thumbnail for G.EDWARD GRIFFIN - THE COMMUNIST TAKEOVER OF AMERICA - Author of "The Creature from Jekkyl Island"8:07
    G.EDWARD GRIFFIN - THE COMMUNIST TAKEOVER OF AMERICA - Author of "The Creature from Jekkyl Island"
    bestofvoatxyz
    836 views
    Thumbnail for Lori Ann Vendetti & Property Rights4:29
    Lori Ann Vendetti & Property Rights
    IJvids
    921 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle