HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Wheat, Weed, and ObamaCare: How the Commerce Clause Made Congress All-Powerful

Views: 975
Update: U.S. District Judge Roger Vinson ruled that because the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act's individual mandate to purchase health insurance is unconstitutional, the entire law "must be declared void." Judge Vinson cites this Reason.tv video on page 47 of his decision.
---

The Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution grants Congress the power to "regulate commerce . . . among the several States," and for more than 100 years federal lawmakers invoked it for a very narrow purpose—to prevent states from imposing trade barriers on each other. But today members of Congress act as if it gives them the authority to do just about anything—including forcing you to eat your vegetables.


During her Supreme Court confirmation hearings, Elena Kagan seemed to accept that the Commerce Clause could, in theory, give Congress the power to dictate what Americans eat. And what about ObamaCare's "individual mandate," which forces Americans to purchase health insurance? ObamaCare opponents are lining up to challenge its constitutionality, but supporters say it's justified—you guessed it—under the Commerce Clause.


How did a clause intended as a restriction on states wind up giving Congress a green light to regulate noncommercial, local, and purely private behavior? How will ObamaCare stand up against the legal challenges brought by the states? Legal titans John Eastman (Chapman University Law Professor) and Erwin Chemerinsky (Founding Dean, University of California, Irvine School of Law) slug it out to to determine whether or not Congress has been abusing the commerce clause.


Produced by Austin Bragg. Approximately 10 minutes.


Scroll down for HD, iPod, and audio versions of all our videos and subscribe to Reason.tv's YouTube channel to receive automatic notification when new material goes live.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Filling Up Prisons Without Fighting Crime: Mark Kleiman on America's Criminal Justice System7:04
Filling Up Prisons Without Fighting Crime: Mark Kleiman on America's Criminal Justice System
ReasonVids
874 views
Thumbnail for The Machine: The Truth Behind Teachers Unions4:30
The Machine: The Truth Behind Teachers Unions
ReasonVids
953 views
Thumbnail for Brian Doherty on The Forgotten History of the Antiwar Right7:37
Brian Doherty on The Forgotten History of the Antiwar Right
ReasonVids
859 views
Thumbnail for 3D Printing, Guns, & Sex Toys: Q&A with 3D Systems CEO Avi Reichental3:22
3D Printing, Guns, & Sex Toys: Q&A with 3D Systems CEO Avi Reichental
ReasonVids
830 views
Thumbnail for Fighting Youth Discrimination: Q&A with NYRA President Jeffrey Nadel4:30
Fighting Youth Discrimination: Q&A with NYRA President Jeffrey Nadel
ReasonVids
809 views
Thumbnail for Gov. Gary Johnson Among the Occupy Wall Street Protesters5:21
Gov. Gary Johnson Among the Occupy Wall Street Protesters
ReasonVids
799 views
Thumbnail for LA County Sheriffs Hassle Photographer, Trample Constitution, Get Lauded by Bosses9:57
LA County Sheriffs Hassle Photographer, Trample Constitution, Get Lauded by Bosses
ReasonVids
824 views
Thumbnail for Mark Collet on fire at anti-refugee protest.0:39
Mark Collet on fire at anti-refugee protest.
bestofvoatxyz
544 views
Thumbnail for Hasta La Vista, Arnold!: What California's Budget Mess Means for America9:57
Hasta La Vista, Arnold!: What California's Budget Mess Means for America
ReasonVids
865 views
Thumbnail for Unify original content2:38
Unify original content
bestofupgoat
302 views
Thumbnail for Why gynoids should never be in positions of authority, ever, for any reason at any time 0:23
Why gynoids should never be in positions of authority, ever, for any reason at any time
bestofupgoat
369 views
Thumbnail for Drugs Win the 2020 Election!3:03
Drugs Win the 2020 Election!
ReasonVids
924 views
Thumbnail for The Power of Nazi Propaganda5:46
The Power of Nazi Propaganda
ReasonVids
908 views
Thumbnail for IJ Launches the Center for Judicial Engagement3:33
IJ Launches the Center for Judicial Engagement
IJvids
878 views
Thumbnail for Armageddon - BCM3:54
Armageddon - BCM
AOUisgay
426 views
Thumbnail for The agenda is to make the mentally unstable validated and accepted, and to have young boys/men think that this is normal and healthy.0:58
The agenda is to make the mentally unstable validated and accepted, and to have young boys/men think that this is normal and healthy.
AOU
1551 views
Thumbnail for The Glorious Death of America's Worst School System5:13
The Glorious Death of America's Worst School System
ReasonVids
1067 views
Thumbnail for Ralph Nader on "Spoiling" the Election for Al Gore0:50
Ralph Nader on "Spoiling" the Election for Al Gore
ReasonVids
889 views
Thumbnail for Banning Bikini Baristas, Big Dogs, and Energy Drinks! (Nanny of the Month, March 2013)1:33
Banning Bikini Baristas, Big Dogs, and Energy Drinks! (Nanny of the Month, March 2013)
ReasonVids
836 views
Thumbnail for What Will Recreational Marijuana Legalization Mean for California? Q&A with Lynne Lyman19:33
What Will Recreational Marijuana Legalization Mean for California? Q&A with Lynne Lyman
ReasonVids
921 views
Thumbnail for The Democrats' Deceptive Narrative on Immigration2:59
The Democrats' Deceptive Narrative on Immigration
ReasonVids
949 views
Thumbnail for Console Connect: Making life easier for network engineers | Console Connect0:46
Console Connect: Making life easier for network engineers | Console Connect
invidious
278 views
Thumbnail for Is California Over?3:07
Is California Over?
ReasonVids
870 views
Thumbnail for Ending the Classroom Factory Model: How Technology Will Personalize Education4:55
Ending the Classroom Factory Model: How Technology Will Personalize Education
ReasonVids
811 views

points

Permalink
Reply
reason.tv, reason.com, reason foundation, reason magazine, obama, obamacare, individual, mandate, individual mandate, health, care, healthcare, commerce, clause, constitution, wickard, austin bragg, supreme, court, john, eastman, erwin, chemerinsky
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle