HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Is Money Speech? Free Speech Rules (Episode 5)

Views: 965
Can the government restrict people's ability to spend money on speech?

Here are the Four Rules of Free Speech and Money.

----------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at Apple Podcasts: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------

Rule 1: Generally, your right to speak includes the right to spend money to speak. The government can't limit, for instance, a newspaper's budget, even if it thinks newspapers have too much influence over elections and politicians. The government can't stop the National Rifle Association or the Sierra Club from spending money to praise the candidates they like,and it can't limit what other Americans spend, either.

Sometimes people frame the question as "Is money speech?" But that's not right. Here's an analogy: The Sixth Amendment protects criminal defendants' right to hire a lawyer. Say the government said, "You can hire any lawyer you like, but you can't pay them more than $1000" (It would be unfair, the theory goes, for rich people to hire better lawyers than poor people can.) That restriction would violate the Sixth Amendment—but not because "money is a lawyer." but because the right to a lawyer includes the right to spend money on a lawyer.

The same is true for most other rights. The Supreme Court has held that people have a right to send their children to private school. If the government were to say, "you can't spend more than $1000 per year on private schooling," that would violate the right to educate your children; but again, not because "money is an education," but because the right to educate your children includes the right to spend money on schooling.

Justice Breyer, who's actually open to substantial restrictions on spending money for speech, put this well:

"A decision to contribute money to a campaign is a matter of First Amendment concern—not because money is speech (it is not); but because it enables speech."

So restrictions on pending money to speak, the Supreme Court has held, are restrictions on speech, and are thus generally unconstitutional.

Rule #2: The government can, though, limit direct contributions to candidates, as opposed to just spending money to speak about candidates. In 1976, for instance, the Supreme Court upheld a cap on contributions to federal candidates. The Court has also upheld even lower caps (as low as $250) for state and local candidates.

Part of the reasoning behind that conclusion is that contribution restrictions limit speech less than expenditure restrictions, precisely because restrictions on contributions to candidates still leave people free to say whatever they like independently of the candidate.

Rule #3: The government may also bar nonprofit organizations from spending tax-deductible contributions on political campaigning. The charitable tax deduction is viewed as a sort of a subsidy. Say you're in the 40% tax bracket; if you give $1000 to a charity, you save $400 in taxes. That contribution is thus equivalent to your paying $600 non-tax-exempt to the charity, and the government forking over the $400.

Based on this subsidy theory, the Supreme Court has held that the government may attach conditions to this tax deduction. One such condition is that groups (whether religious or secular) that collect tax-deductible money aren't supposed to use it to endorse or oppose political candidates. If they want to engage in such speech, they can—just with money they get without the tax exemption.

That's why many groups, such as the ACLU, the NRA, the Sierra Club, actually have two related groups—a so-called "501(c)(3)" group that collects tax-deductible donations and can't use them for political campaigning, and a "501(c)(4)" group that collects non-tax-deductible donations that it can use for politics.

Rule #4: The government may completely bar people who aren't citizens or lawful permanent residents from spending money to advocate for or against candidates. Though non-citizens present in the U.S. generally have broad First Amendment rights, a federal court held that these rights can be limited when it comes to spending even small sums of money related to elections. The Supreme Court upheld that decision, though the Justices didn't issue a written opinion.


Written by Eugene Volokh, who is a First Amendment law professor at UCLA.
Produced and edited by Austin Bragg, who is not.
Additional graphics by Joshua Swain.

----------------

Music: "Lobby Time," by Kevin MacLeod (Incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Shark Tank's Kevin O'Leary Explains Donald Trump's Success34:49
Shark Tank's Kevin O'Leary Explains Donald Trump's Success
ReasonVids
978 views
Thumbnail for Deek Jackson & The Love World Order23:42
Deek Jackson & The Love World Order
AOU
1574 views
Thumbnail for Drunk kids1:08
Drunk kids
bestofvoatxyz
1520 views
Thumbnail for A new take on an old trick0:06
A new take on an old trick
bestofvoatxyz
1785 views
Thumbnail for Why Hitler Invaded Poland6:48
Why Hitler Invaded Poland
bestofvoatxyz
774 views
Thumbnail for Oakland Joins the World's Biggest Pot Shop to Battle the Feds—The End of the War on Weed?6:51
Oakland Joins the World's Biggest Pot Shop to Battle the Feds—The End of the War on Weed?
ReasonVids
957 views
Thumbnail for Richard Epstein: Obamacare's Collapse, the 2016 Election, & More1:06:40
Richard Epstein: Obamacare's Collapse, the 2016 Election, & More
ReasonVids
882 views
Thumbnail for Epic Troll: YouTuber Screams At City Council Meeting While Portraying An Extreme Leftist5:53
Epic Troll: YouTuber Screams At City Council Meeting While Portraying An Extreme Leftist
AOU
798 views
Thumbnail for Obama's War That Isn't a War2:36
Obama's War That Isn't a War
ReasonVids
1016 views
Thumbnail for Pull Yourself Forward1:16
Pull Yourself Forward
amybird
1925 views
Thumbnail for Wiseman: Democracy edition0:56
Wiseman: Democracy edition
bestofvoatxyz
1221 views
Thumbnail for Jimmy Song: Bitcoin, Universities, and Christian Theology49:23
Jimmy Song: Bitcoin, Universities, and Christian Theology
ReasonVids
854 views
Thumbnail for Whole Foods' John Mackey on Why He Became a Vegan & Supporting Gary Johnson24:33
Whole Foods' John Mackey on Why He Became a Vegan & Supporting Gary Johnson
ReasonVids
916 views
Thumbnail for Brutal Doom Sunlust Map 0113:32
Brutal Doom Sunlust Map 01
brutalist_gaming
1326 views
Thumbnail for City Zones Popular Mechanic Shop out of Business2:51
City Zones Popular Mechanic Shop out of Business
IJvids
923 views
Thumbnail for Gary Johnson: 'I Always Thought Telling the Truth Would Rule the Day. And It Doesn't.'30:58
Gary Johnson: 'I Always Thought Telling the Truth Would Rule the Day. And It Doesn't.'
ReasonVids
932 views
Thumbnail for Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales Already Solved the Internet's Problems30:49
Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales Already Solved the Internet's Problems
ReasonVids
921 views
Thumbnail for What a shitshow1:22
What a shitshow
Dismiss
1202 views
Thumbnail for How Anarchism Can Solve Social Problems: Gary Chartier at Freedom Fest 20134:21
How Anarchism Can Solve Social Problems: Gary Chartier at Freedom Fest 2013
ReasonVids
988 views
Thumbnail for NYC Zoomer Plays IRL Minecraft0:08
NYC Zoomer Plays IRL Minecraft
bestofupgoat
29 views
Thumbnail for Don't Expect Unions To Make a Comeback4:26
Don't Expect Unions To Make a Comeback
ReasonVids
874 views
Thumbnail for The Top 6 Craziest Things Cops Spent Forfeiture Money On1:08
The Top 6 Craziest Things Cops Spent Forfeiture Money On
IJvids
902 views
Thumbnail for Stossel: 100 years of Communist Disaster5:16
Stossel: 100 years of Communist Disaster
ReasonVids
926 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian, reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle