HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Sackett v. EPA: How One Couple's Battle Against the Feds Might Protect Your Land

Views:1003
@ReasonVids

The decision in the Supreme Court case Sackett v. EPA, due later this spring, could very well affect the meaning of property rights and due process in the United States. So how did a small-town couple from Northern Idaho ever become the center of such a momentous case? Reason.tv talked with the Sacketts and their attorney to find out.

Mike Sackett dreamed of building a home on Idaho's Priest Lake ever since he camped there with friends in high school.

"I remember coming home, told my mom and dad that I was going to move to Priest Lake, and they just said, 'Oh, no you're not.' And I said, 'Oh yeah. Yeah I am,'" Sackett said.

Years later, Sackett realized that dream when he and his wife, Chantelle Sackett, bought a plot of land near Priest Lake and started to build. After securing the necessary permits from local authorities, the Sacketts were only three days into the process of clearing the land when officials from the EPA showed up and put their dreams on hold.

The EPA informed the Sacketts that they suspected they were building on wetlands and had to cease work immediately. The Sacketts were stunned because their property was a completely landlocked lot within an existing subdivision. When Chantelle Sackett asked for evidence, the EPA pointed her to the National Fish and Wildlife Wetlands Inventory, which showed them that their lot... was not on an existing wetland.

The EPA responded issued what's known as a compliance order, which said that the Sacketts were in violation of the Clean Water Act and subject to fines of up to $37,500 a day.

"You go to bed with that on your mind every night," said Mike Sackett, who owns a contracting company. "It's been painful personally. It's been painful on our business."

The EPA refused to offer any documentation or evidence for its position, even after the Sacketts hired their own scientists to refute the wetlands claim. Feeling they had no other choice, they tried to take the EPA to court. Unfortunately, not even this was an option, because the EPA maintained that a compliance order is nothing more than a warning and that they cannot be challenged until they actually enforce the fines, which were racking up by the day.

"The only way the Sacketts could get judicial review that way, was by ignoring the compliance order," said Damien Schiff, attorney for the Pacific Legal Foundation, which took up the Sacketts' case. "EPA still might just sit on its hands and let the possible fines pile up."

Schiff and the Pacific Legal Foundation lost to the EPA in lower courts, but this afforded them the opportunity to take the case to the Supreme Court, which heard arguments in early January 2012. Schiff and the Sacketts both felt heartened by what transpired there.

"I was surprised by some of the questions that came from the justices," said Mike Sackett. "They were questions that we would've asked."

If the Sacketts do win in the Supreme Court, they will then have the opportunity to actually challenge the EPA's compliance order in the lower courts. Just having the opportunity to challenge that, says Schiff, would be a major victory for property rights and for due process of law.

"The agency says it doesn't want to go into court, it shouldn't have to go into court," said Schiff. "The chutzpah, the arrogance, is, frankly, almost unimaginable."

About 7.30 minutes. Produced by Zach Weissmueller. Camera by Sharif Matar. Additional camera by Paul Detrick, Tracy Oppenheimer, and Weissmueller. Additional footage courtesy of the Pacific Legal Foundation. Music: "Water" by Big Blood, "City Night Line" by Cobra avec Panther, "The River Who Drinks All I've Had" by Makunouchi Bento, "Film 1" by Torture Super Sonic.

Visit http://reason.tv for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason.tv's YouTube channel, http://www.youtube.com/subscriptioncenter?adduser=ReasonTV, to receive automatic notifications when new material goes live.

epa
,
property rights
,
battle
,
environmentalism
,
libertarian
,
pacific legal foundation
,
supreme court
,
due process
,
big government
,
overreach
,
green police
,
america
,
reason magazine
,
nick gillespie
,
zach weissmueller
,
sharif matar
,
radical environmentalism
    Thumbnail for Journalist Sam Slovick on Occupy LA: Scenes From a New Revolution9:37
    Journalist Sam Slovick on Occupy LA: Scenes From a New Revolution
    ReasonVids
    811 views
    Thumbnail for The Soros Biden Partnership in Ukraine1:13
    The Soros Biden Partnership in Ukraine
    LibertyIsTheLaw
    45447 views
    Thumbnail for Nanny of The Month, May 2010: Anti-Raw-Milk Crusader Stephanie Rose1:14
    Nanny of The Month, May 2010: Anti-Raw-Milk Crusader Stephanie Rose
    ReasonVids
    786 views
    Thumbnail for Remy: I'll Be Missing You (Puff Daddy Incandescent Light Bulb Parody)2:30
    Remy: I'll Be Missing You (Puff Daddy Incandescent Light Bulb Parody)
    ReasonVids
    957 views
    Thumbnail for Density or Sprawl? How To Solve the Urban Housing Crisis15:04
    Density or Sprawl? How To Solve the Urban Housing Crisis
    ReasonVids
    1038 views
    Thumbnail for Why Elizabeth Warren's Wealth Tax Won't Work5:21
    Why Elizabeth Warren's Wealth Tax Won't Work
    ReasonVids
    1077 views
    Thumbnail for Dear Diary, I ran into @Sal_180 today...0:05
    Dear Diary, I ran into @Sal_180 today...
    bestofupgoat
    81 views
    Thumbnail for Democratic Debate Cocktails1:15
    Democratic Debate Cocktails
    ReasonVids
    746 views
    Thumbnail for Banning Sex Toys?! Nanny of the Month, September '091:06
    Banning Sex Toys?! Nanny of the Month, September '09
    ReasonVids
    877 views
    Thumbnail for Success in Life is Up to You | Live From The Lair15:20
    Success in Life is Up to You | Live From The Lair
    Terrence Popp
    458 views
    Thumbnail for I made Sonic 1000x faster in GTA 5 | GrayStillPlays19:11
    I made Sonic 1000x faster in GTA 5 | GrayStillPlays
    invidious
    288 views
    Thumbnail for Pull Yourself Forward1:16
    Pull Yourself Forward
    amybird
    1954 views
    Thumbnail for Black Americans Failed by Good Intentions: An Interview with Jason Riley20:40
    Black Americans Failed by Good Intentions: An Interview with Jason Riley
    ReasonVids
    976 views
    Thumbnail for "Economics Teaches Us Humility": Q&A with George Mason University's Pete Boettke9:19
    "Economics Teaches Us Humility": Q&A with George Mason University's Pete Boettke
    ReasonVids
    912 views
    Thumbnail for The Green Party's Jill Stein: Why Choose Between a 'Fascist' and a 'Warmonger'?10:32
    The Green Party's Jill Stein: Why Choose Between a 'Fascist' and a 'Warmonger'?
    ReasonVids
    933 views
    Thumbnail for Judge Napolitano: How Teddy Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson Destroyed Constitutional Freedom14:03
    Judge Napolitano: How Teddy Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson Destroyed Constitutional Freedom
    ReasonVids
    994 views
    Thumbnail for Abolish the Electoral College? A Soho Forum Debate1:30:55
    Abolish the Electoral College? A Soho Forum Debate
    ReasonVids
    788 views
    Thumbnail for Man inside polling area has been filling out BLANK BALLOTS for over an hour, and stamping them, with a uniformed officer standing right there.0:41
    Man inside polling area has been filling out BLANK BALLOTS for over an hour, and stamping them, with a uniformed officer standing right there.
    AOU
    1525 views
    Thumbnail for Kevin Rian vs Lucifeller - M.U.G.E.N.1:36
    Kevin Rian vs Lucifeller - M.U.G.E.N.
    memology101
    1207 views
    Thumbnail for And now ... the News™5:43
    And now ... the News™
    voatcatbox
    471 views
    Thumbnail for Focus on Yourself, Dudes | Live From The Lair15:32
    Focus on Yourself, Dudes | Live From The Lair
    Terrence Popp
    730 views
    Thumbnail for The Growing Power of the Presidency12:50
    The Growing Power of the Presidency
    ReasonVids
    1006 views
    Thumbnail for Can California Survive?: Reason's Carl DeMaio and Adrian Moore33:55
    Can California Survive?: Reason's Carl DeMaio and Adrian Moore
    ReasonVids
    912 views
    Thumbnail for "I escaped a North Korean prison camp" - Shin Dong-hyuk's Survivor Story4:08
    "I escaped a North Korean prison camp" - Shin Dong-hyuk's Survivor Story
    ReasonVids
    913 views
    Thumbnail for Indians waiting for the train in Melbourne 0:10
    Indians waiting for the train in Melbourne
    bestofupgoat
    366 views

points

Permalink
Reply
epa
,
property rights
,
battle
,
environmentalism
,
libertarian
,
pacific legal foundation
,
supreme court
,
due process
,
big government
,
overreach
,
green police
,
america
,
reason magazine
,
nick gillespie
,
zach weissmueller
,
sharif matar
,
radical environmentalism
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle