HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Sackett v. EPA: How One Couple's Battle Against the Feds Might Protect Your Land

Views:1042
@ReasonVids

The decision in the Supreme Court case Sackett v. EPA, due later this spring, could very well affect the meaning of property rights and due process in the United States. So how did a small-town couple from Northern Idaho ever become the center of such a momentous case? Reason.tv talked with the Sacketts and their attorney to find out.

Mike Sackett dreamed of building a home on Idaho's Priest Lake ever since he camped there with friends in high school.

"I remember coming home, told my mom and dad that I was going to move to Priest Lake, and they just said, 'Oh, no you're not.' And I said, 'Oh yeah. Yeah I am,'" Sackett said.

Years later, Sackett realized that dream when he and his wife, Chantelle Sackett, bought a plot of land near Priest Lake and started to build. After securing the necessary permits from local authorities, the Sacketts were only three days into the process of clearing the land when officials from the EPA showed up and put their dreams on hold.

The EPA informed the Sacketts that they suspected they were building on wetlands and had to cease work immediately. The Sacketts were stunned because their property was a completely landlocked lot within an existing subdivision. When Chantelle Sackett asked for evidence, the EPA pointed her to the National Fish and Wildlife Wetlands Inventory, which showed them that their lot... was not on an existing wetland.

The EPA responded issued what's known as a compliance order, which said that the Sacketts were in violation of the Clean Water Act and subject to fines of up to $37,500 a day.

"You go to bed with that on your mind every night," said Mike Sackett, who owns a contracting company. "It's been painful personally. It's been painful on our business."

The EPA refused to offer any documentation or evidence for its position, even after the Sacketts hired their own scientists to refute the wetlands claim. Feeling they had no other choice, they tried to take the EPA to court. Unfortunately, not even this was an option, because the EPA maintained that a compliance order is nothing more than a warning and that they cannot be challenged until they actually enforce the fines, which were racking up by the day.

"The only way the Sacketts could get judicial review that way, was by ignoring the compliance order," said Damien Schiff, attorney for the Pacific Legal Foundation, which took up the Sacketts' case. "EPA still might just sit on its hands and let the possible fines pile up."

Schiff and the Pacific Legal Foundation lost to the EPA in lower courts, but this afforded them the opportunity to take the case to the Supreme Court, which heard arguments in early January 2012. Schiff and the Sacketts both felt heartened by what transpired there.

"I was surprised by some of the questions that came from the justices," said Mike Sackett. "They were questions that we would've asked."

If the Sacketts do win in the Supreme Court, they will then have the opportunity to actually challenge the EPA's compliance order in the lower courts. Just having the opportunity to challenge that, says Schiff, would be a major victory for property rights and for due process of law.

"The agency says it doesn't want to go into court, it shouldn't have to go into court," said Schiff. "The chutzpah, the arrogance, is, frankly, almost unimaginable."

About 7.30 minutes. Produced by Zach Weissmueller. Camera by Sharif Matar. Additional camera by Paul Detrick, Tracy Oppenheimer, and Weissmueller. Additional footage courtesy of the Pacific Legal Foundation. Music: "Water" by Big Blood, "City Night Line" by Cobra avec Panther, "The River Who Drinks All I've Had" by Makunouchi Bento, "Film 1" by Torture Super Sonic.

Visit http://reason.tv for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason.tv's YouTube channel, http://www.youtube.com/subscriptioncenter?adduser=ReasonTV, to receive automatic notifications when new material goes live.

epa
,
property rights
,
battle
,
environmentalism
,
libertarian
,
pacific legal foundation
,
supreme court
,
due process
,
big government
,
overreach
,
green police
,
america
,
reason magazine
,
nick gillespie
,
zach weissmueller
,
sharif matar
,
radical environmentalism
    Thumbnail for Journalist Sam Slovick on Occupy LA: Scenes From a New Revolution9:37
    Journalist Sam Slovick on Occupy LA: Scenes From a New Revolution
    ReasonVids
    857 views
    Thumbnail for #QuiapoChurch 8AM #OnlineMass • 15 APRIL 2025 • #HOLYTUESDAY #MartesSanto | Quiapo Church49:06
    #QuiapoChurch 8AM #OnlineMass • 15 APRIL 2025 • #HOLYTUESDAY #MartesSanto | Quiapo Church
    invidious
    107 views
    Thumbnail for 【マシュマロ】リスナーさんの質問を1秒で読む人と親切に読む人で配信します。 | すたぽら【公式】1:00
    【マシュマロ】リスナーさんの質問を1秒で読む人と親切に読む人で配信します。 | すたぽら【公式】
    invidious
    211 views
    Thumbnail for Online Privacy & Security 101: How To Actually Protect Yourself? | Wolfgang's Channel15:42
    Online Privacy & Security 101: How To Actually Protect Yourself? | Wolfgang's Channel
    invidious
    413 views
    Thumbnail for I Know Who The Battle BUS DRIVER Is. | Aid0:56
    I Know Who The Battle BUS DRIVER Is. | Aid
    invidious
    161 views
    Thumbnail for Honest Government Ad | Canada 2025 Election3:30
    Honest Government Ad | Canada 2025 Election
    invidious
    92 views
    Thumbnail for Buletin Utama, 21 Oktober 2024 | Buletin TV31:00
    Buletin Utama, 21 Oktober 2024 | Buletin TV3
    invidious
    211 views
    Thumbnail for Pink Floyd - Eclipse (50th Anniversary Competition Winner's Video) | Pink Floyd1:59
    Pink Floyd - Eclipse (50th Anniversary Competition Winner's Video) | Pink Floyd
    invidious
    314 views
    Thumbnail for ТРАМПОФРЕНИЯ-2. ПЯТЬДЕСЯТ ОТТЕНКОВ КОРИЧНЕВОГО | Игорь Яковенко57:26
    ТРАМПОФРЕНИЯ-2. ПЯТЬДЕСЯТ ОТТЕНКОВ КОРИЧНЕВОГО | Игорь Яковенко
    invidious
    103 views
    Thumbnail for Mob Vote 2022 mobs are ... revealed. | Phoenix SC1:47
    Mob Vote 2022 mobs are ... revealed. | Phoenix SC
    invidious
    461 views
    Thumbnail for 【Stanley】11/16  韓服  看起來沒有人想贏  鬼轉隨機選角  急速godown ! | Stanley 史丹利3:37:41
    【Stanley】11/16 韓服 看起來沒有人想贏 鬼轉隨機選角 急速godown ! | Stanley 史丹利
    invidious
    167 views
    Thumbnail for TRACKMANIA BUGS COMPILATION | Woterek3:09
    TRACKMANIA BUGS COMPILATION | Woterek
    invidious
    361 views
    Thumbnail for IBIZA SUMMER MIX 2023 ↠ Dubai, Bali, Greece, Iceland, Paradise 🌴 SUMMER MIX 2023 | Green Sound1:00
    IBIZA SUMMER MIX 2023 ↠ Dubai, Bali, Greece, Iceland, Paradise 🌴 SUMMER MIX 2023 | Green Sound
    invidious
    398 views
    Thumbnail for When style is important - Vanity Stats | Viva La Dirt League2:46
    When style is important - Vanity Stats | Viva La Dirt League
    invidious
    421 views
    Thumbnail for Pão de queijo 🇧🇷.                                               #cheesebread #busezeynep | Buse Zeynep0:40
    Pão de queijo 🇧🇷. #cheesebread #busezeynep | Buse Zeynep
    invidious
    134 views
    Thumbnail for Unai Emery BOTTLES IT LATE! Manchester City 2-1 Aston Villa Highlights | The Football Terrace54:44
    Unai Emery BOTTLES IT LATE! Manchester City 2-1 Aston Villa Highlights | The Football Terrace
    invidious
    79 views
    Thumbnail for Quickparts - Digital Manufacturing On Demand | Quickparts 1:53
    Quickparts - Digital Manufacturing On Demand | Quickparts
    invidious
    325 views
    Thumbnail for Fake Dopamine vs. Real Dopamine | FunnyMemeSpot0:21
    Fake Dopamine vs. Real Dopamine | FunnyMemeSpot
    invidious
    84 views
    Thumbnail for Mazda Brought Back The Rotary Engine! | Engineering Explained14:07
    Mazda Brought Back The Rotary Engine! | Engineering Explained
    invidious
    337 views
    Thumbnail for Rammstein - Sonne (Industrial Dance remix by Alambrix) [Unofficial] | Feuer und Elektro: A Tribute to Rammstein6:25
    Rammstein - Sonne (Industrial Dance remix by Alambrix) [Unofficial] | Feuer und Elektro: A Tribute to Rammstein
    invidious
    460 views
    Thumbnail for Beatiful Christmas Ambience 🎄 Relaxing Christmas Music Fireplace 🔥 Merry Christmas 2024 | Healing Relaxation1:00
    Beatiful Christmas Ambience 🎄 Relaxing Christmas Music Fireplace 🔥 Merry Christmas 2024 | Healing Relaxation
    invidious
    374 views
    Thumbnail for SEN vs. KRU | VCT Americas Stage 2 - W2D15:11:16
    SEN vs. KRU | VCT Americas Stage 2 - W2D1
    invidious
    293 views
    Thumbnail for 🔴Live |  | Schedule 1 | Wentiferous Wednesday | #drougs #LETSBUNGULATE | TheBurntPeanut9:02:41
    🔴Live | | Schedule 1 | Wentiferous Wednesday | #drougs #LETSBUNGULATE | TheBurntPeanut
    invidious
    169 views
    Thumbnail for Smart Battery Case iPhone 17 Air | UFD Tech0:58
    Smart Battery Case iPhone 17 Air | UFD Tech
    invidious
    127 views
    Thumbnail for See George W. Bush's viral facial expressions at inauguration | TODAY0:57
    See George W. Bush's viral facial expressions at inauguration | TODAY
    invidious
    130 views

points

Permalink
Reply
epa
,
property rights
,
battle
,
environmentalism
,
libertarian
,
pacific legal foundation
,
supreme court
,
due process
,
big government
,
overreach
,
green police
,
america
,
reason magazine
,
nick gillespie
,
zach weissmueller
,
sharif matar
,
radical environmentalism
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle