HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

7 Things You Should Know About Free Speech in Schools: Free Speech Rules (Episode 1)

Views:901
@ReasonVids

Watch the first episode of Free Speech Rules, a new video series on free speech and the law. The first episode looks at the seven things you should know about how the First Amendment is applied in schools, from black armbands to 'Bong Hits 4 Jesus.'

--------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at Apple Podcasts: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------

Here are the Seven Rules of Free Speech in Schools

  1. Political and religious speech is protected (Mostly)

Students, from first grade to twelfth, can’t be punished based on their political or religious speech. As the Supreme Court said in the Tinker case, “It can hardly be argued that ... students ... shed their constitutional rights... at the schoolhouse gate.”

This protects, for instance,
Wearing black armbands to protest a war
Distributing religious messages to classmates between classes.
Or criticizing a teacher over lunch.

  1. Disruptive speech is not protected

But schools can punish speech that “materially disrupts schoolwork,” for instance because it prompts fights.

That’s why some lower courts have let schools ban clothing that displays Confederate flags, and in one case even clothing that displays an American flag on Cinco de Mayo, when that display led to violence.

That’s a kind of “heckler’s veto,” where threats against a speaker are used by the government to justify restricting the speaker rather than the threateners. Usually the government can’t impose such a heckler’s veto—but the rule in schools seems to be different.

  1. Vulgar or sexual speech is not protected

Schools can also punish students for using vulgarities or sexual innuendos.

  1. Praising drugs is not protected

Schools can punish speech that seems to praise drug use, and probably also alcohol use and other crimes, at least when the speech doesn’t seem political. That’s from Morse v. Frederick, where the Supreme Court said a school could suspend a student for holding up a banner that read “BONG HiTS 4 JESUS.”

So “legalize marijuana” is probably okay; while “marijuana is awesome” probably isn’t.

  1. Official school newspapers are the school’s own speech

You may have the right to speak at school, but you don’t have the right so speak in the school newspaper. Courts see the newspaper as the school’s own speech, even if students are the ones who write it. The principal has ultimate control over what goes in the newspaper, and can delete or edit any article for pretty much any reason.

  1. This Only Applies to Public Schools

Everything said so far deals with public schools. Under the so-called “state action doctrine” the First Amendment doesn’t limit private schools, even ones that get tax breaks or government funds.

The first words of the First Amendment are “Congress shall make no law ...”—that applies to the federal government. The Fourteenth Amendment basically says no “state” shall violate people’s rights—that applies the First Amendment to state and local governments. But the Constitution generally doesn’t constrain private property owners, private landlords, private schools, or anyone else.

  1. California is different

And...it’s all different in California. Sure, everything is different in California, but what I mean is that everything I’ve said so far is the constitutional minimum that all states must provide. Some states have passed laws that provide more protection to students. In California, for instance,

High school students generally can’t be punished for their speech even if it provokes other students into acting disruptively.
They generally can’t be punished for speech about drugs or alcohol, or even vulgar speech And public school newspapers are mostly free from being censored by the administration. Student newspapers are protected in some other states, too

Indeed, in California, all the student speech protections -- but not the student newspaper speech protections -- apply to private high school students as well (but not in religious high schools.)

That’s the law of free speech in school, cobbled together by the Court and a few legislatures over the last 50 years or so.

Written by Eugene Volokh, a First Amendment law professor at UCLA.
Produced and edited by Austin Bragg, who is not.

This is not legal advice.
If this were legal advice, it would be followed by a bill.
Please use responsibly.

For full text, visit https://reason.com/reasontv/2018/12/13/free-speech-rules-free-speech-in-schools

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for A Crackdown on Cash and Bitcoin? Curbing Crime vs. Empowering the Surveillance State1:33:03
    A Crackdown on Cash and Bitcoin? Curbing Crime vs. Empowering the Surveillance State
    ReasonVids
    723 views
    Thumbnail for Larry King on Ferguson Policing... and Nudity1:24
    Larry King on Ferguson Policing... and Nudity
    ReasonVids
    906 views
    Thumbnail for How California Will Legalize Pot in 2016: Learning The Lessons of Prop 197:18
    How California Will Legalize Pot in 2016: Learning The Lessons of Prop 19
    ReasonVids
    853 views
    Thumbnail for Expect Fully Legal Weed Within 5 Years, Says Former Top Pharma Lobbyist & Congressman Billy Tauzin6:19
    Expect Fully Legal Weed Within 5 Years, Says Former Top Pharma Lobbyist & Congressman Billy Tauzin
    ReasonVids
    899 views
    Thumbnail for What We Saw at the Stewart-Colbert Rally to Restore Sanity5:54
    What We Saw at the Stewart-Colbert Rally to Restore Sanity
    ReasonVids
    865 views
    Thumbnail for Steve Forbes: Why the Left is Wrong about the Morality of Capitalism0:38
    Steve Forbes: Why the Left is Wrong about the Morality of Capitalism
    ReasonVids
    809 views
    Thumbnail for Scientist shows Jab effects in autopsies. Don't believe it ? See for yourself.13:34
    Scientist shows Jab effects in autopsies. Don't believe it ? See for yourself.
    AOU
    4057 views
    Thumbnail for California's High-Speed Rail Disaster Is a 'Shot Across the Bow for the Green New Deal'4:20
    California's High-Speed Rail Disaster Is a 'Shot Across the Bow for the Green New Deal'
    ReasonVids
    871 views
    Thumbnail for Ask a Mexican Already! Q&A with Gustavo Arellano7:10
    Ask a Mexican Already! Q&A with Gustavo Arellano
    ReasonVids
    936 views
    Thumbnail for Q&A: Eyal Press on Beautiful Souls, Nonconformists Who Stand Up to Power5:01
    Q&A: Eyal Press on Beautiful Souls, Nonconformists Who Stand Up to Power
    ReasonVids
    862 views
    Thumbnail for Victimizing the Vulnerable: Eminent Domain Abuse in National City, Calif.3:44
    Victimizing the Vulnerable: Eminent Domain Abuse in National City, Calif.
    IJvids
    830 views
    Thumbnail for Translating...0:59
    Translating...
    bestofupgoat
    492 views
    Thumbnail for Oblivion NPC dialogue gets intimate | Siugi0:33
    Oblivion NPC dialogue gets intimate | Siugi
    invidious
    405 views
    Thumbnail for When your eyes light up I think aboiut our future family together and our DT class we had in 04'1:22
    When your eyes light up I think aboiut our future family together and our DT class we had in 04'
    cankerstank
    445 views
    Thumbnail for [김종배의 시선집중][FULL][언론어때] 노희범 변호사 - 尹 탄핵심판 10차 변론기일 종료ㅣ유최안 전 부지회장 - 대우조선 하청노조 파업 1심 선고, MBC 250221 방송 | MBC 라디오 시사2:24:20
    [김종배의 시선집중][FULL][언론어때] 노희범 변호사 - 尹 탄핵심판 10차 변론기일 종료ㅣ유최안 전 부지회장 - 대우조선 하청노조 파업 1심 선고, MBC 250221 방송 | MBC 라디오 시사
    invidious
    91 views
    Thumbnail for Remy: The Equality Song1:50
    Remy: The Equality Song
    ReasonVids
    907 views
    Thumbnail for Hillary Celebrates Facebook Friends Day0:23
    Hillary Celebrates Facebook Friends Day
    ReasonVids
    925 views
    Thumbnail for The goyim mustn't know!0:49
    The goyim mustn't know!
    AOU
    1160 views
    Thumbnail for Olympics 1936.3:09
    Olympics 1936.
    bestofupgoat
    237 views
    Thumbnail for An Economist Walks Into a Brothel: What Prostitutes and Big-Wave Surfers Can Teach Us About Risk7:06
    An Economist Walks Into a Brothel: What Prostitutes and Big-Wave Surfers Can Teach Us About Risk
    ReasonVids
    785 views
    Thumbnail for Food Truck Owners Fight for Right to Compete in Carolina Beach1:47
    Food Truck Owners Fight for Right to Compete in Carolina Beach
    IJvids
    820 views
    Thumbnail for Chiropractors In The Area Are Booked Solid. 0:16
    Chiropractors In The Area Are Booked Solid.
    AOUisgay
    410 views
    Thumbnail for Freaks (1932) - One of Us! Scene (6/9) | Movieclips3:22
    Freaks (1932) - One of Us! Scene (6/9) | Movieclips
    invidious
    210 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Happy Thanksgiving!4:09
    Stossel: Happy Thanksgiving!
    ReasonVids
    702 views
    Thumbnail for 3 Reasons Not to Fund Art with Taxes2:51
    3 Reasons Not to Fund Art with Taxes
    ReasonVids
    911 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle