HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Will Regulation Ruin School Choice in New Orleans?

Views:873
@ReasonVids

Here’s the paradox of pre-Katrina New Orleans: For its ten million pie-eyed vacationers trolling the sticky streets of the French Quarter, the city was a pulsating, profit-making pleasure dome. For a few bucks, the city would happily serve up just about anything you could scarf down.

Yet right across the Mississippi River, the Orleans Parish School Board made the Department of Motor Vehicles look like a model of efficiency. A toxic swamp of fraud and incompetence, the school board was tilting on the edge of bankruptcy, when Hurricane Katrina wiped out much of the city, taking the bureaucracy with it.

School choice swept in as a replacement, and nine years later, test scores and graduation rates are on the rise. With red tape cut, and the teachers union largely out of the picture, the quality of public education has made steady gains in the Big Easy. “We’re going to be the first mostly black city to outperform its mostly white state in the history of this country,” says Julie Lause, principal of Harriet Tubman Charter School in Algiers.

The reform of New Orleans’ public schools is arguably the greatest turnaround story in the history of American public education. But the nation's first all-charter district is fragile, and the reforms behind its success could be pushed back – or even reversed over time. “It’s something we have to be very careful of,” warns Neerav Kingsland, a school choice advocate with New Schools for New Orleans. “A system like this could be undermined by a death by a thousand regulatory cuts.”

The city continues to struggle to find the right balance between regulation and autonomy. Although the old education bureaucracy has been drastically downsized from the pre-Katrina era, new regulations are chipping away at the freedoms enjoyed by students and schools alike.

Some of the new rules address issues of equity, while others set limits on the very idea of school choice. The school board has standardized the application procedure for all charter schools. Student discipline procedures are now adjudicated at the state level, with common standards for suspensions and expulsions at every charter school. More controversially, students can no longer transfer to another charter school after six weeks into the semester – a prohibition that seems to strike at the very notion of school choice.

Can libertarian concerns about freedom find a balance with progressive notions of fairness – without threatening nine years of hard-won educational gains? So far, the progress in New Orleans is hard to deny, and has silenced most critics.

But there's much more work to be done. Today, only a few New Orleans schools have earned Lousiania's highest marks for quality education. Many charter schools are on the verge of failing, and some will have to be closed. “We’re not yet there, we’re not yet perfect,” says Lause. “We aren’t an A-school system yet. But I think we’re on the way.”

Runs about 7:30 minutes.

Produced, shot, narrated, and edited by Todd Krainin.

Go to http://reason.com/reasontv/2014/12/05/new-orleans-charter-schools for downloadable versions and subscribe to ReasonTV's YouTube Channel to receive notifications when new material goes live.

regulation (organization sector)
,
new orleans (city/town/village)
,
louisiana (us state)
,
education in the united states (literature subject)
,
school choice (literature subject)
,
libertarianism (political ideology)
,
hurricane katrina (tropical cyclone)
,
charter schools in the united states (school category)
,
reason (magazine)
,
neerav kingsland
,
bureaucracy (quotation subject)
,
bobby jindal (u.s. congressperson)
    Thumbnail for Remy: Arkansas Badonkadonk (Hillary Clinton Trace Adkins Honky Tonk Badonkadonk Parody)1:54
    Remy: Arkansas Badonkadonk (Hillary Clinton Trace Adkins Honky Tonk Badonkadonk Parody)
    ReasonVids
    973 views
    Thumbnail for Before the crucifix this is supposedly a common christian symbol. I think I heard about this once before in catholic school. Let's bring it back!1:02
    Before the crucifix this is supposedly a common christian symbol. I think I heard about this once before in catholic school. Let's bring it back!
    bestofupgoat
    211 views
    Thumbnail for Everything You Want to Know About John McCain's Sex Scandal4:23
    Everything You Want to Know About John McCain's Sex Scandal
    ReasonVids
    910 views
    Thumbnail for 23 Tax Facts and Tips in Two and a Half Minutes2:44
    23 Tax Facts and Tips in Two and a Half Minutes
    ReasonVids
    874 views
    Thumbnail for Wait for it.....0:20
    Wait for it.....
    AOU
    1332 views
    Thumbnail for Joe Biden's $2 Trillion Green New Deal Is Just a Worn-Out Democratic Jobs Program3:57
    Joe Biden's $2 Trillion Green New Deal Is Just a Worn-Out Democratic Jobs Program
    ReasonVids
    902 views
    Thumbnail for Should All Drugs Be Legal? A Soho Forum Debate1:25:04
    Should All Drugs Be Legal? A Soho Forum Debate
    ReasonVids
    737 views
    Thumbnail for Adam Carolla rips Los Angeles!0:19
    Adam Carolla rips Los Angeles!
    ReasonVids
    964 views
    Thumbnail for INJUSTICE 2 Walkthrough Gameplay Part 13 - Superman (Story Mode) | theRadBrad16:12
    INJUSTICE 2 Walkthrough Gameplay Part 13 - Superman (Story Mode) | theRadBrad
    invidious
    395 views
    Thumbnail for Low IQ Snowflake has to call the cops for other people having different opinions2:12
    Low IQ Snowflake has to call the cops for other people having different opinions
    Pizzacake
    1941 views
    Thumbnail for The Half-Baked Baller 0:57
    The Half-Baked Baller
    bestofvoatxyz
    664 views
    Thumbnail for Beef pie with ruff puff pastry 🍂✨ | Ballerina Farm1:00
    Beef pie with ruff puff pastry 🍂✨ | Ballerina Farm
    invidious
    105 views
    Thumbnail for Kickstart Government Twitter Accounts: Uncle Sam Needs Your Help!2:01
    Kickstart Government Twitter Accounts: Uncle Sam Needs Your Help!
    ReasonVids
    829 views
    Thumbnail for Dad Drops Son a Mile From Home. Goes to Jail.5:46
    Dad Drops Son a Mile From Home. Goes to Jail.
    ReasonVids
    1140 views
    Thumbnail for Libertarian To Be Elected? An Interview with Libertarian City Councilman Ed Coleman3:59
    Libertarian To Be Elected? An Interview with Libertarian City Councilman Ed Coleman
    ReasonVids
    943 views
    Thumbnail for Can I Survive 100 Days in Hardcore Survival Mode? - Perfectly Balanced Fallout 4 Challenge | The Spiffing Brit3:23:11
    Can I Survive 100 Days in Hardcore Survival Mode? - Perfectly Balanced Fallout 4 Challenge | The Spiffing Brit
    invidious
    291 views
    Thumbnail for Where are the Black Libertarians?3:11
    Where are the Black Libertarians?
    ReasonVids
    852 views
    Thumbnail for Full Alex Jones/Ye/Fuentes vid, no commercials - Great discussion3:07:32
    Full Alex Jones/Ye/Fuentes vid, no commercials - Great discussion
    bestofvoatxyz
    760 views
    Thumbnail for How does the military feel about backing this fool of a president.0:31
    How does the military feel about backing this fool of a president.
    bestofupgoat
    534 views
    Thumbnail for Texas City Officials Think They Can Throw You in Jail for Criticizing Them | Institute for Justice5:33
    Texas City Officials Think They Can Throw You in Jail for Criticizing Them | Institute for Justice
    invidious
    380 views
    Thumbnail for Every Apartment needs this Upgrade! (WhatsApp/Telegram Notifications) | GreatScott!10:05
    Every Apartment needs this Upgrade! (WhatsApp/Telegram Notifications) | GreatScott!
    invidious
    433 views
    Thumbnail for Georgia Law Enforcement Often Refuses to Report Forfeiture Funds, a Violation of GA Law2:58
    Georgia Law Enforcement Often Refuses to Report Forfeiture Funds, a Violation of GA Law
    IJvids
    942 views
    Thumbnail for @bushcuck shoots a gun for the first time0:34
    @bushcuck shoots a gun for the first time
    bestofupgoat
    410 views
    Thumbnail for Harvey Weinstein's Downfall Marks the Rise of Sexual Equality3:32
    Harvey Weinstein's Downfall Marks the Rise of Sexual Equality
    ReasonVids
    767 views

points

Permalink
Reply
regulation (organization sector)
,
new orleans (city/town/village)
,
louisiana (us state)
,
education in the united states (literature subject)
,
school choice (literature subject)
,
libertarianism (political ideology)
,
hurricane katrina (tropical cyclone)
,
charter schools in the united states (school category)
,
reason (magazine)
,
neerav kingsland
,
bureaucracy (quotation subject)
,
bobby jindal (u.s. congressperson)
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle