HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

The Medical Conflict of Interest Mania: Dr. Thomas Stossel on Physician Regulation

Views:1003
@ReasonVids

If the real-world consequences weren't so severe, Dr. Thomas Stossel's favorite anecdote would be a forgettable joke, instead of an unfortunate comment on the current practice of medicine.

The anecdote goes like this:

An enterprising reporter is writing a story about medical conflict of interest. He approaches Dr. Stossel, who's been extolling the benefits of a drug invented by Pfizer.

"I see, Dr. Stossel, you got $2,000 from Pfizer!"

"Yeah, it's because I add value," replies Stossel. "If I didn't, I'd be a reporter."

Dr. Stossel tells the joke, not with a smile, but with a weary glower of frustration. He is, after all, describing an uphill battle, fought against the mainstream media and his fellow doctors, that has occupied a significant part of his working life. It is the task of convincing the public that medical conflict of interest laws are hurting the practice of medicine.

Stossel knows a few things about the intersection of medicine and money. He's the American Cancer Society professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School and an accomplished researcher of cellular biology. He spoke at Reason Weekend in St. Petersburg, Florida, to deliver a contrarian take on a subject that has drawn national media attention: the excessive regulation of financial arrangements between physicians and the pharmaceutical industry.

Stossel cites the unintended consequences of legislation like the Physician Payments Sunshine Act, which was enacted as part of Obamacare. Greater transparency in medical care may seem like a worthy goal, but only when its supporters fail to account for the full cost of the law. The legislation, he says, is "300 pages of legal gibberish," which mandates disclosure of payments as low as $10 to doctors. Billions of dollars every year will be spent on compliance with these regulations -- money that will be diverted away from medical research that improves our lives.

Over the last ten years, new legal strategies based on charges of "false claims" are used to comply with the law or pressure companies to quickly settle lawsuits. Underlying these accusations is the threat of debarment, a set of harsh financial penalties, which Stossel describes as, "arguably the most damaging aspect of the conflict of interest mania."

Above all, Stossel hopes to discredit allegations that the for-profit medical industry is fundamentally criminal. He argues that marketing practices employed by pharmaceutical companies do not distort physicians' ability to discern fact from fiction. On the contrary, marketing can encourage doctors to learn about the latest developments in medicine. In the absence of conflict of interest regulation, researchers were better rewarded for successful drug development. Steady declines in rates of mortality from cancer, heart disease, and HIV-AIDS over the last decades would not have occurred if financial arrangements were as corrupting a force as critics have charged.

Having spent much of the last ten years trying to persuade people otherwise, today Dr. Stossel is pessimistic about the future of medical conflict of interest regulations. "We've been wimps, especially the industry," he says of a medical establishment that's afraid to stand up for its own interests as well as the public good.

As a result, Stossel's message has struggled to gain traction against an army of what he calls "instigators" (well-meaning activists) and "enablers" (institutional authorities). Yet he continues to lecture, speak before Congress, and write opinion articles, hoping that a solution may someday arise from the general public.

Runs about 31 minutes.

Edited by Todd Krainin. Cameras by Paul Feine and Zach Weismueller.

Visit http://reason.com/reasontv/2014/06/18/the-medical-conflict-of-interest-mania-d for downloadable versions of this video, and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube channel for daily content like this.

conflict of interest (literature subject)
,
medicine (field of study)
,
pharmaceutical industry (industry)
,
ethics (quotation subject)
,
reason (magazine)
,
regulation (organization sector)
,
stossel (tv program)
,
john stossel (tv writer)
,
libertarianism (political ideology)
,
regulation
,
physician (profession)
    Thumbnail for Nirvana's Krist Novoselic on Punk, Politics, & Why He Dumped the Dems55:45
    Nirvana's Krist Novoselic on Punk, Politics, & Why He Dumped the Dems
    ReasonVids
    949 views
    Thumbnail for Classical Christmas Music & Fireplace 24/7 | Orchestral Christmas Music1:00
    Classical Christmas Music & Fireplace 24/7 | Orchestral Christmas Music
    invidious
    321 views
    Thumbnail for When you've run out of platforms0:09
    When you've run out of platforms
    bestofvoatxyz
    792 views
    Thumbnail for What Afghans Think About Bergdahl, the Taliban, and U.S. Intervention: Q&A with Author Anand Gopal6:10
    What Afghans Think About Bergdahl, the Taliban, and U.S. Intervention: Q&A with Author Anand Gopal
    ReasonVids
    819 views
    Thumbnail for Nigger confused by alien technology1:29
    Nigger confused by alien technology
    voatcatbox
    1264 views
    Thumbnail for Virginia Postrel: How to Reform Health Care Without Killing Innovation9:35
    Virginia Postrel: How to Reform Health Care Without Killing Innovation
    ReasonVids
    871 views
    Thumbnail for The Relentless Revolution: Joyce Appleby on the History of Capitalism8:03
    The Relentless Revolution: Joyce Appleby on the History of Capitalism
    ReasonVids
    836 views
    Thumbnail for Generation Opportunity, Politics, and Millennials: Q/A with Evan Feinberg5:51
    Generation Opportunity, Politics, and Millennials: Q/A with Evan Feinberg
    ReasonVids
    954 views
    Thumbnail for "The Slants:" A Band Name Too Racist to Trademark!8:03
    "The Slants:" A Band Name Too Racist to Trademark!
    ReasonVids
    995 views
    Thumbnail for Freedomain Radio's Stefan Molyneux on the Inevitable Growth of the State5:32
    Freedomain Radio's Stefan Molyneux on the Inevitable Growth of the State
    ReasonVids
    878 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Save Lives, Sell Organs5:09
    Stossel: Save Lives, Sell Organs
    ReasonVids
    753 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Harvard Caves to Student Mob6:30
    Stossel: Harvard Caves to Student Mob
    ReasonVids
    956 views
    Thumbnail for Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 4)2:47
    Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 4)
    ReasonVids
    855 views
    Thumbnail for Robert E Lee statue gets melted0:13
    Robert E Lee statue gets melted
    AOUisgay
    435 views
    Thumbnail for Climate change in Ireland reaches crisis levels as yet another migrant centre succumbs to spontaneous combustion 0:09
    Climate change in Ireland reaches crisis levels as yet another migrant centre succumbs to spontaneous combustion
    bestofupgoat
    198 views
    Thumbnail for Rebuilding Men From Mediocrity | Live From The Lair27:42
    Rebuilding Men From Mediocrity | Live From The Lair
    Terrence Popp
    725 views
    Thumbnail for The Woke Bolshevik Revolution - ROBERT SEPEHR18:03
    The Woke Bolshevik Revolution - ROBERT SEPEHR
    AOU
    1009 views
    Thumbnail for EPA is shut down by SCOTUS. Does not have power to set climate standards4:11
    EPA is shut down by SCOTUS. Does not have power to set climate standards
    SingularityJett
    819 views
    Thumbnail for Red Cop / Blue Cop2:10
    Red Cop / Blue Cop
    ReasonVids
    930 views
    Thumbnail for Banker (Billy Eilish - Bad Guy - Parody)3:34
    Banker (Billy Eilish - Bad Guy - Parody)
    judenhass
    1870 views
    Thumbnail for Liquid Oxygen vs Candle | Cody'sLab0:26
    Liquid Oxygen vs Candle | Cody'sLab
    invidious
    396 views
    Thumbnail for 200+ years of them pesky British 1:12
    200+ years of them pesky British
    bestofupgoat
    59 views
    Thumbnail for Native Americans burn netanyahu effigy0:40
    Native Americans burn netanyahu effigy
    bestofupgoat
    156 views
    Thumbnail for Remy: Obamacare Video Contest Song1:31
    Remy: Obamacare Video Contest Song
    ReasonVids
    850 views
    Thumbnail for The Future of Legal Pot Under Trump: Marijuana Entrepreneurs Speak Out6:07
    The Future of Legal Pot Under Trump: Marijuana Entrepreneurs Speak Out
    ReasonVids
    898 views

points

Permalink
Reply
conflict of interest (literature subject)
,
medicine (field of study)
,
pharmaceutical industry (industry)
,
ethics (quotation subject)
,
reason (magazine)
,
regulation (organization sector)
,
stossel (tv program)
,
john stossel (tv writer)
,
libertarianism (political ideology)
,
regulation
,
physician (profession)
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle