HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Surveillance State: Maryland is Listening to You

Views:983
@ReasonVids

Do you know that your local city bus might be listening to your conversations?

Depending on where you live, the sidewalks could be recording your every step. And your lampposts and subway cars may be watching you, too.

Once a paranoid notion of science fiction, perpetual state surveillance is fast becoming the new normal. In some cases, the technology is being activated without the consent of the public.

When the Maryland legislature considered a bill to turn on audio recording devices inside its statewide fleet of 758 buses, it set off a fierce debate in the Senate. Delegate Melvin Stukes argued that audio surveillance is a powerful tool to help fight crime, and individuals cannot expect privacy on public transportation. Opposing him was senator James Brochin, who warned of an assault on civil liberties and the frigtening potential for government abuse.

But make no mistake, this was more than a clash of two powerful state politicians. This was a struggle between two cherished American values: privacy versus security. It's a conflict that's playing out in communities all across the United States.

So far, surveillance is winning. After the Maryland legislature rejected three bills that sought to activate audio surveillance in buses across the state, the transit authority turned them on anyway, on the advice of the state attorney general.

Do citizens get any say in the matter? In a 1967 ruling, Katz v. United States, the Supreme Court affirmed that the individual right to privacy depends largely on a set of norms that are determined by society. In other words, if you have a reasonable expectation of privacy -- even if you're in a public place -- then you are entitled to it.

Surveys show strong and growing public support for some kinds of surveillance. An April 2013 New York Times poll shows that 78% of respondents approved the use of video cameras in public places. Terrorist incidents like Boston Marathon bombings have made the public ever more receptive to cameras in the name of fighting crime. (The poll didn't ask about audio recording.)

A recent study by the Urban Institute concludes that surveillance has a significant effect on reducing crime. Baltimore, a city with the fourth highest murder rate in the nation, has benefitted from video cameras, as have Chicago, and Washington, D.C.

Yet downsides remain. Even in the young history of audio-visual surveillance, the ACLU notes that the technology has already been abused. Members of law enforcement have used information gleaned from cameras to blackmail, spy, and harrass citizens. And if these crimes seem relatively minor now, imagine how a future J. Edgar Hoover would make use of the all-seeing eye, with its powers of voice matching and face recognition.

It's a worrisome prospect. Senator Brochin, who accepts video cameras while condemning audio surveillance, is quick to remind us how eavesdropping poses a threat to an open, democratic society. Citing the widespread use of covert listening devices in authoritarian countries, he remains concerned about what the future is going to look -- and sound -- like.

Surveillance technology has certainly become powerful, and promises to become more so. But when and whether that technonology is used -- that power still remains with us.

Runs about 8:12 minutes.

Produced, shot, and edited by Todd Krainin.

Go to http://reason.com/reasontv/2013/06/06/surveillance-state-maryland-is-listening for downloadable versions and subscribe to ReasonTV's YouTube Channel to receive notifications when new material goes live.

james brochin
,
melvin stukes
,
reason (periodical)
,
camera (invention)
,
privacy (issue)
,
surveillance
,
nsa warrantless surveillance controversy (event)
,
fourth amendment (constitutional amendment)
,
baltimore (city/town/village)
,
maryland (us state)
,
annapolis (city/town/village)
,
crime
,
security
,
surveillance state
,
todd krainin
,
democracy (political philosophy)
,
libertarianism (school of thought)
,
wiretapping
,
minority report (film)
,
eavesdropping
,
katz v. united states
    Thumbnail for Rep. Thomas Massie on Turd Sandwiches, Govt Surveillance, IRS Scandals43:45
    Rep. Thomas Massie on Turd Sandwiches, Govt Surveillance, IRS Scandals
    ReasonVids
    908 views
    Thumbnail for DSP Attempts It - Coping with Being a Dinosaur and Busy Schedule13:46
    DSP Attempts It - Coping with Being a Dinosaur and Busy Schedule
    memology101
    1200 views
    Thumbnail for DSPGaming HONEST Channel Trailer11:57
    DSPGaming HONEST Channel Trailer
    memology101
    1371 views
    Thumbnail for Lanny Friedlander: The Eccentric Genius Who Created Reason Magazine8:31
    Lanny Friedlander: The Eccentric Genius Who Created Reason Magazine
    ReasonVids
    914 views
    Thumbnail for The tragic tale of Germany's biggest LOL cow | Interesting Stuff From Around The World34:27
    The tragic tale of Germany's biggest LOL cow | Interesting Stuff From Around The World
    invidious
    482 views
    Thumbnail for The Fallacy of Net Neutrality: Thomas Hazlett on the FCC & Consumer Protection6:18
    The Fallacy of Net Neutrality: Thomas Hazlett on the FCC & Consumer Protection
    ReasonVids
    922 views
    Thumbnail for Cory Doctorow on Cyber Warfare, Lawbreaking, and His New Novel 'Walkaway'40:37
    Cory Doctorow on Cyber Warfare, Lawbreaking, and His New Novel 'Walkaway'
    ReasonVids
    1015 views
    Thumbnail for Union Jobs vs. Children's Lives: Which side are you on?7:30
    Union Jobs vs. Children's Lives: Which side are you on?
    ReasonVids
    962 views
    Thumbnail for Republicans will cancel you for talking about this 2:45
    Republicans will cancel you for talking about this
    bestofupgoat
    201 views
    Thumbnail for How To Unlock A Door With A Hairpin 😮 | Zack D. Films0:33
    How To Unlock A Door With A Hairpin 😮 | Zack D. Films
    invidious
    125 views
    Thumbnail for Mods you better delete this antisemitic rant before the ADL is yet again is forced to DDoS your severs.8:21
    Mods you better delete this antisemitic rant before the ADL is yet again is forced to DDoS your severs.
    bestofupgoat
    498 views
    Thumbnail for The Court of Mob Rule | Grunt Speak Live2:56:12
    The Court of Mob Rule | Grunt Speak Live
    Terrence Popp
    1226 views
    Thumbnail for They're Putting it Directly Into Our Heads0:49
    They're Putting it Directly Into Our Heads
    bestofupgoat
    487 views
    Thumbnail for Jews seethe at anything beautiful0:08
    Jews seethe at anything beautiful
    bestofvoatxyz
    2737 views
    Thumbnail for NY Can’t Teach Kids to Read on $30,000 a Year3:19
    NY Can’t Teach Kids to Read on $30,000 a Year
    ReasonVids
    1013 views
    Thumbnail for Border Patrol Said 5 Bullets Were “Munitions of War” and Seized this American’s Truck3:28
    Border Patrol Said 5 Bullets Were “Munitions of War” and Seized this American’s Truck
    IJvids
    950 views
    Thumbnail for I wouldn't go to France0:56
    I wouldn't go to France
    bestofupgoat
    364 views
    Thumbnail for Would More Gun Control Lead to More Crime? A Debate1:37:24
    Would More Gun Control Lead to More Crime? A Debate
    ReasonVids
    733 views
    Thumbnail for Based Cat0:06
    Based Cat
    AOUisgay
    447 views
    Thumbnail for We Don't Need No (Public) Education: Sheldon Richman on the Separation of School and State5:38
    We Don't Need No (Public) Education: Sheldon Richman on the Separation of School and State
    ReasonVids
    858 views
    Thumbnail for What the U.S. Media Get Wrong About Brexit: Daniel Hannan34:25
    What the U.S. Media Get Wrong About Brexit: Daniel Hannan
    ReasonVids
    923 views
    Thumbnail for 2020 so far...0:18
    2020 so far...
    Boojibs
    2826 views
    Thumbnail for Granny Theft Auto0:35
    Granny Theft Auto
    publicfreakouts
    742 views
    Thumbnail for prescient2:50
    prescient
    bestofupgoat
    287 views
    Thumbnail for Highlights: Gakpo & Salah goals in City win! | Liverpool vs Man City (2-0) | Liverpool FC2:00
    Highlights: Gakpo & Salah goals in City win! | Liverpool vs Man City (2-0) | Liverpool FC
    invidious
    128 views

points

Permalink
Reply
james brochin
,
melvin stukes
,
reason (periodical)
,
camera (invention)
,
privacy (issue)
,
surveillance
,
nsa warrantless surveillance controversy (event)
,
fourth amendment (constitutional amendment)
,
baltimore (city/town/village)
,
maryland (us state)
,
annapolis (city/town/village)
,
crime
,
security
,
surveillance state
,
todd krainin
,
democracy (political philosophy)
,
libertarianism (school of thought)
,
wiretapping
,
minority report (film)
,
eavesdropping
,
katz v. united states
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle