HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

The Guardians of Free Speech

Views: 978
Because of the social media circus surrounding the Johnny Depp/Amber Heard defamation trial, it was easy to overlook one of the principal—yet least likely—actors in the courtroom drama: the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), which ghostwrote and placed the 2018 Washington Post op-ed by Heard about surviving domestic abuse that was the basis of the trial.

https://reason.com/video/2022/06/23/as-the-aclu-recedes-from-its-core-mission-fire-expands-to-fill-the-void/
-------------------

It's only the latest example of how the group has in recent years strayed from its original mission of defending speech, no matter how vile. Awash with money after former President Donald Trump was elected, the ACLU transformed into an organization that championed progressive causes, undermining the principled neutrality that helped make it a powerful advocate for the rights of clients ranging from Nazis to socialists.

It questioned the due process rights of college students accused of sexual assault and harassment under Title IX rules. It ran partisan ads against Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh and for Georgia gubernatorial candidate Stacey Abrams, a move that current Executive Director Anthony Romero told The New York Times was a mistake. The ACLU also called for the federal government to forgive $50,000 per borrower in student loans.

As the ACLU recedes from its mission, enter another free speech organization, the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, or FIRE. Founded in 1999 to combat speech codes on college campuses, FIRE is expanding to go well beyond the university and changing its name to the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression. The group has raised $29 million toward a three-year "litigation, opinion research and public education campaign aimed at boosting and solidifying support for free-speech values."

"I think there have been better moments for freedom of speech when it comes to the culture," says FIRE's president, Greg Lukianoff. "When it comes to the law, the law is about as good as it's ever been. But when it comes to the culture, our argument is that it's gotten a lot worse and that we don't have to accept it."

Lukianoff tells Reason that FIRE's new initiatives have been in the works for years, but gained urgency during the COVID lockdowns. "Pretty much from day one, people have been asking us to take our advocacy off campus to an extent nationally," he says. "But 2020 was such a scarily bad year for freedom of speech on campus and off, we decided to accelerate that process." Despite 80 percent of campuses being closed and doing instruction remotely, Lukianoff says that FIRE received 50 percent more requests for help from college students and faculty. He also points to The New York Times' editorial page editor, James Bennet, getting squeezed out after running an article by Sen. Tom Cotton (R–Ark.) and high-profile journalists such as Bari Weiss, Andrew Sullivan, and Matt Yglesias "stepping away from their publications, saying that the environment was too intolerant."

FIRE is also expanding its efforts beyond legal advocacy and into promoting what Lukianoff calls "the culture of free speech." As Politico reports, it will spend $10 million "in planned national cable and billboard advertising featuring activists on both ends of the political spectrum extolling the virtues of free speech."

He says that people in their 40s and 50s grew up in a country where the culture of free speech was embedded in colloquial sayings and common attitudes. "Things like everyone's entitled to their opinion, which is something you heard all the time when we were kids. It's a free country, to each their own, statements of deep pluralism, like the idea that you should walk a mile in a man's shoes," he explains. "All of these things are great principles for taking advantage of pluralism, but they've largely sort of fallen out of usage due to a growing skepticism about freedom of speech, particularly on campus, that's been about 40 years in the making."

Lukianoff has nothing negative to say about the ACLU (in fact, he used to work there) and stresses that FIRE has worked with the organization since "day one" and continues to do so. But unlike the ACLU, FIRE isn't at risk of turning into a progressive advocacy organization, partly because its staff is truly bipartisan.

That pluralistic pride extends to the groups funding FIRE, too. Lukianoff thinks that despite the rise of cancel culture, most Americans still understand the value of free speech, but they need to be encouraged to stand up for it. FIRE's polling, he says, reveals that "it's really a pretty small minority, particularly pronounced on Twitter, that is anti-free-speech philosophically and thinks that people should shut up and conform."

For that reason, he's upbeat that FIRE will succeed in helping to restore belief in the value and function of free speech.

Interview by Nick Gillespie. Edited by Regan Taylor.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for CDC: The Movie (COVID parody)2:36
CDC: The Movie (COVID parody)
ReasonVids
907 views
Thumbnail for Pierre Poilievre will Boycott World Economic Forum if Elected Prime Minister ~ Clyde Do Something12:18
Pierre Poilievre will Boycott World Economic Forum if Elected Prime Minister ~ Clyde Do Something
bestofsaidit
1020 views
Thumbnail for More Americans Trust IRS Than Facebook with Privacy: Reason-Rupe Poll September 20134:23
More Americans Trust IRS Than Facebook with Privacy: Reason-Rupe Poll September 2013
ReasonVids
847 views
Thumbnail for Bring the First Amendent Into the 21st Century says Freedom of the Press Foundation's Trevor Timm8:00
Bring the First Amendent Into the 21st Century says Freedom of the Press Foundation's Trevor Timm
ReasonVids
838 views
Thumbnail for The Swing Vote: Why Independents Will Decide the 2012 Election6:41
The Swing Vote: Why Independents Will Decide the 2012 Election
ReasonVids
903 views
Thumbnail for How to Dodge a DUI Test and the Legality of New Saliva Swabs6:48
How to Dodge a DUI Test and the Legality of New Saliva Swabs
ReasonVids
928 views
Thumbnail for simpin' ain't easy0:12
simpin' ain't easy
bestofvoatxyz
1511 views
Thumbnail for Bezos, Branson, and the Billionaire-Funded Race To Make Space a Bargain2:28
Bezos, Branson, and the Billionaire-Funded Race To Make Space a Bargain
ReasonVids
887 views
Thumbnail for Intervention: A Success Story!3:08
Intervention: A Success Story!
ReasonVids
891 views
Thumbnail for Fat naked sheboon attacks KFC0:33
Fat naked sheboon attacks KFC
AOU
5295 views
Thumbnail for Sawzall1:16
Sawzall
bestofupgoat
144 views
Thumbnail for Chicago Entrepreneurs: Pitch Your Business Idea & Win Funding!1:01
Chicago Entrepreneurs: Pitch Your Business Idea & Win Funding!
IJvids
905 views
Thumbnail for Victoreeeeeeeee!0:15
Victoreeeeeeeee!
AOU
913 views
Thumbnail for Poems About Animals5:05
Poems About Animals
birdpoem
1135 views
Thumbnail for Oakland vs. Government Surveillance! Defeating the Domain Awareness Center.7:28
Oakland vs. Government Surveillance! Defeating the Domain Awareness Center.
ReasonVids
907 views
Thumbnail for Coming Soon to an Airport Near You: Prison-style strip searches?2:44
Coming Soon to an Airport Near You: Prison-style strip searches?
ReasonVids
896 views
Thumbnail for Is China Moving Toward a Gold Standard? Peter Schiff on the Chinese Market Crash2:54
Is China Moving Toward a Gold Standard? Peter Schiff on the Chinese Market Crash
ReasonVids
766 views
Thumbnail for Rail to Nowhere: Honolulu, Hawaii's Train Boondoggle8:40
Rail to Nowhere: Honolulu, Hawaii's Train Boondoggle
ReasonVids
988 views
Thumbnail for Brutal Doom Mods Comparison | Alptraum12:09
Brutal Doom Mods Comparison | Alptraum
invidious
344 views
Thumbnail for Kiyosaki - 11:00 "I want to be the boyfriend, not the ex-husband" savage!14:04
Kiyosaki - 11:00 "I want to be the boyfriend, not the ex-husband" savage!
AOU
1342 views
Thumbnail for What We Saw at the Occupy Wall Street Protest6:04
What We Saw at the Occupy Wall Street Protest
ReasonVids
745 views
Thumbnail for Cuddle Crackdown! Police Think Snugglers are Actually Hookers: Don't cops have better things to do?2:01
Cuddle Crackdown! Police Think Snugglers are Actually Hookers: Don't cops have better things to do?
ReasonVids
894 views
Thumbnail for Stossel: Sugar’s Sweetheart Deal5:04
Stossel: Sugar’s Sweetheart Deal
ReasonVids
917 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian, reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle