HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Police Blew Up their Home, Courts Say They Are Owed Nothing

Views:939
@IJvids

If the government needs to destroy your home to build a freeway or a school, the Constitution entitles you to just compensation. But what if the government needs to destroy your home for some other reason—say, to capture a fugitive who has randomly taken refuge in your house while fleeing the police? Does the government owe you anything?

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

https://ij.org/case/lech-v-city-of-greenwood/

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Shockingly, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit held in a ruling this October that as long as the government uses its “police power” to destroy property, it cannot be required to provide compensation for that property under the U.S. Constitution’s Takings Clause. Today, the Institute for Justice, the nation’s premier defender of property rights, announced that it will file a petition for rehearing by the entire Tenth Circuit (known as rehearing en banc).

“The simple rule of the Constitution is that the government cannot arbitrarily single out private citizens to bear the costs of something that should rightly be the burden of society as a whole,” explained IJ Attorney Jeffrey Redfern. “If the government requires a piece of property to be destroyed, then the government should pay for it—and that’s just as true regardless of whether the people doing the destroying are the local school board or the local police.”

The case was brought by Leo, Alfonsina and John Lech, seeking compensation for the destruction of a home Leo and Alfonsina owned (and in which their son John lived with his own family) in Greenwood Village, Colo. In 2015, an armed shoplifter fleeing the police broke into the home (apparently at random) and refused to come out. After taking gunfire from the shoplifter, the police resorted to more strenuous means of attack, including explosives, high-caliber ammunition, and a battering ram mounted on a tank-like vehicle called a BearCat. The fugitive was apprehended, but the home was totaled.

The Lechs’ case, originally brought by Colorado attorney Rachel Maxam, who continues to represent the family alongside IJ, argued that the complete destruction of the house was a “taking” that required compensation under the U.S. Constitution. But a three-judge panel disagreed, ruling that actions by law enforcement officials could never amount to a “taking,” no matter what, and so the appropriate amount of compensation was zero dollars.

“The police are allowed to destroy property if they need to in order to do their jobs safely,” said IJ Senior Attorney Robert McNamara. “But if the government destroys someone’s property in order to benefit the public, it is only fair that the public rather than an innocent property owner pay for that benefit.”

“This whole affair has quite simply totally destroyed our lives,” said Leo Lech. “My son’s family was very literally thrown out into the street with the clothes on their back, offered $5,000, and told to ‘go deal with it.’”

“Property rights are the foundation of our rights,” said IJ President and General Counsel Scott Bullock. “The court’s ruling that government officials can purposefully destroy someone’s home without owing a dime in compensation is not just wrong. It is dangerous, and it is un-American. The Institute for Justice is committed to seeing it overturned, for the Lechs and for the protection of property owners across America.”
Donate to IJ: https://ij.org/support/give-now/

ij
,
institute for justice
,
freedom
,
liberty
,
individual rights
,
constitution
,
constitutional law
,
unconstitutional law
,
con law
,
constitutional litigation
    Thumbnail for When Can the Gov't Lock You in Your House? Quarantines and the Constitution23:04
    When Can the Gov't Lock You in Your House? Quarantines and the Constitution
    IJvids
    1014 views
    Thumbnail for These Inspectors Think “Open for Business” Means “No Warrant Required”30:22
    These Inspectors Think “Open for Business” Means “No Warrant Required”
    IJvids
    998 views
    Thumbnail for Glenn Greenwald: "A real subversion, not only of privacy, but of democracy itself"1:03
    Glenn Greenwald: "A real subversion, not only of privacy, but of democracy itself"
    ReasonVids
    912 views
    Thumbnail for If You Don't See Black, You Don't See Me original content1:20
    If You Don't See Black, You Don't See Me original content
    bestofupgoat
    530 views
    Thumbnail for 20 Years After 9-1110:44
    20 Years After 9-11
    AmericanRenaissance
    855 views
    Thumbnail for Let's Compensate Bone Marrow Donors2:14
    Let's Compensate Bone Marrow Donors
    IJvids
    994 views
    Thumbnail for NOTÍCIAS DO CRUZEIRO: ARBITRAGEM DA CBF, LEONARDO JARDIM, WANDERSON, DINENNO E ALEXANDRE MATTOS | Seis a um1:00
    NOTÍCIAS DO CRUZEIRO: ARBITRAGEM DA CBF, LEONARDO JARDIM, WANDERSON, DINENNO E ALEXANDRE MATTOS | Seis a um
    invidious
    111 views
    Thumbnail for The Proof Is Out There: Unexplained Lightning Phenomenon Caught On Camera (Season 1) | History | HISTORY4:29
    The Proof Is Out There: Unexplained Lightning Phenomenon Caught On Camera (Season 1) | History | HISTORY
    invidious
    299 views
    Thumbnail for Bear jumps in after guy0:58
    Bear jumps in after guy
    bestofupgoat
    142 views
    Thumbnail for Egyptian Dissident Cynthia Farahat: The Middle East Is Hungry for Free Markets and Free Speech14:19
    Egyptian Dissident Cynthia Farahat: The Middle East Is Hungry for Free Markets and Free Speech
    ReasonVids
    849 views
    Thumbnail for Jews Celebrating Tens of Thousands of Dead Whites to Commemorate Purim ("Victory Over Enemies" Holiday) 0:27
    Jews Celebrating Tens of Thousands of Dead Whites to Commemorate Purim ("Victory Over Enemies" Holiday)
    bestofvoatxyz
    659 views
    Thumbnail for ZOO0:14
    ZOO
    bestofupgoat
    116 views
    Thumbnail for The-Joy-Of-ᗅᗺᗷᗅ59:28
    The-Joy-Of-ᗅᗺᗷᗅ
    AOUisgay
    532 views
    Thumbnail for Prime Time PEEKABOO / Hugo Talks (Billy Corgan is a mason) [8.40]9:03
    Prime Time PEEKABOO / Hugo Talks (Billy Corgan is a mason) [8.40]
    bestofsaidit
    734 views
    Thumbnail for Can We Throw Satellites to Space? - SpinLaunch ~ Real Engineering42:13
    Can We Throw Satellites to Space? - SpinLaunch ~ Real Engineering
    bestofsaidit
    782 views
    Thumbnail for Do we have more to fear from an unrestrained majority or narrow special interests?2:29
    Do we have more to fear from an unrestrained majority or narrow special interests?
    ReasonVids
    932 views
    Thumbnail for Hinga Thanks You For Your Support0:50
    Hinga Thanks You For Your Support
    IJvids
    882 views
    Thumbnail for Building Haiti Right Here in the United States10:56
    Building Haiti Right Here in the United States
    AmericanRenaissance
    876 views
    Thumbnail for 🔴 수면을 위한 빗소리 - 편안한 빗소리와 블랙스크린으로 쉽게 잠들어 보세요. / 불면증, 깊은 잠, 휴식, 명상, 백색소음 | Relaxing Time for you1:00
    🔴 수면을 위한 빗소리 - 편안한 빗소리와 블랙스크린으로 쉽게 잠들어 보세요. / 불면증, 깊은 잠, 휴식, 명상, 백색소음 | Relaxing Time for you
    invidious
    293 views
    Thumbnail for This City Thinks Monopolies are Great1:37
    This City Thinks Monopolies are Great
    IJvids
    1030 views
    Thumbnail for UFC champ sends holes back to the kitchen 2:06
    UFC champ sends holes back to the kitchen
    bestofupgoat
    517 views
    Thumbnail for No one should need a college degree to work in a day care1:12
    No one should need a college degree to work in a day care
    IJvids
    1005 views
    Thumbnail for Is this what they meant by 'Russian Disinformation'??0:31
    Is this what they meant by 'Russian Disinformation'??
    bestofupgoat
    166 views
    Thumbnail for School in Haryana faces backlash over children reenacting Pahalgam terror attack… | Brut India0:56
    School in Haryana faces backlash over children reenacting Pahalgam terror attack… | Brut India
    invidious
    83 views
    Thumbnail for The Mike Bloomberg Legacy: 12 Years of Little Tyrannies in 2 Minutes!2:07
    The Mike Bloomberg Legacy: 12 Years of Little Tyrannies in 2 Minutes!
    ReasonVids
    940 views

points

Permalink
Reply
ij
,
institute for justice
,
freedom
,
liberty
,
individual rights
,
constitution
,
constitutional law
,
unconstitutional law
,
con law
,
constitutional litigation
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle