HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

High-Speed Rail Advocates Should Pay Attention to California’s Costly Disaster

Views: 913
President Biden signaled he's open to spending money on faster rail as a part of his $2.2 trillion infrastructure plan. But if you take a look at California's high-speed rail project, you may not think that's a great idea.

------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV?subconfirmation=1
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason

Reason is the leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------

With a Democrat in the White House and a $2.2 trillion infrastructure plan on the table, excitement about high-speed rail is on the rise again. A map by graphic designer and transit advocate Alfred Twu, featuring possible routes for bullet train lines crisscrossing the U.S., has been making the rounds on Twitter. The map was the subject of a recent Vox article that was tweeted out by Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.

"Gen Z is dreaming big," he wrote. "It's time we all did the same."

"I want her so fucking much," which was accompanied by a picture of Twu's map, was how one viral tweet summed up the prevailing mood back in January of 2020.

But anyone taking the promise of high-speed rail seriously should consider California's disastrous attempt to build a bullet train in recent years—the project is unfinished and over budget, and one of its key political backers has turned against it.

Building high-speed rail requires bulldozing neighborhoods and disrupting communities, and would be a drain on a state's finances if completed. In 2009, President Barack Obama proposed building 8,600 miles of high-speed rail and received $10.1 billion from Congress toward that goal. The money went to upgrading Amtrak instead.

The Cato Institute's Randal O'Toole estimates that based on the costs and setbacks of the California project, building 8,600 miles of high-speed rail would have cost "well over $1 trillion dollars."

Buttigieg's definition of "dreaming big" is applying 20th-century technology to 21st-century problems.

When funding for the initial part of the California High-Speed Rail line was voted on in 2008, it was supposed to link Los Angeles with San Francisco for about $33 billion and take about a decade to complete. As the years dragged on, the cost ballooned to $100 billion at one point and the project had to be scaled back significantly to a shorter section between Merced and Bakersfield in California's Central Valley.

Even with all the setbacks, including a lack of private investment that champions of the California rail line were always banking on, local California politicians continue to push for federal dollars.

During the 2020 presidential campaign, Joe Biden promised to make sure that America had the "cleanest, safest, and fastest rail system in the world." Buttigieg and Congress should pay more attention to California's costly disaster than a map circulating on Twitter.

Produced by Paul Detrick

Music: "Hall of the Mountain King" by Kevin MacLeod, Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Photos: Murray/ZUMAPRESS/Newscom, Oliver Contreras / Pool via CNP / SplashNews/Newscom, Ken Cantrell/ZUMA Press/Newscom, Gary Reyes/TNS/Newscom, Photo 98224660 © Blackzheep | Dreamstime.com, Photo 136151613 © Cougarsan | Dreamstime.com
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Melissa Chen on Fighting Wokeness at Home and Radicalism Abroad1:04:38
Melissa Chen on Fighting Wokeness at Home and Radicalism Abroad
ReasonVids
795 views
Thumbnail for Ben & Jerry's Co-Founder Won't Vote for Hillary0:36
Ben & Jerry's Co-Founder Won't Vote for Hillary
ReasonVids
899 views
Thumbnail for Crucified by the Church25:16
Crucified by the Church
AmericanRenaissance
1417 views
Thumbnail for Slip of the tongue0:59
Slip of the tongue
bestofvoatxyz
1613 views
Thumbnail for The TSA's 12 Signs You Might Be a Terrorist3:10
The TSA's 12 Signs You Might Be a Terrorist
ReasonVids
888 views
Thumbnail for Hayleigh McEnany Makes Fake News Reporter Regret Trying To Bait Her With Question About Pro-Trump Violence1:52
Hayleigh McEnany Makes Fake News Reporter Regret Trying To Bait Her With Question About Pro-Trump Violence
AOU
1460 views
Thumbnail for Border Patrol Said 5 Bullets Were “Munitions of War” and Seized this American’s Truck3:28
Border Patrol Said 5 Bullets Were “Munitions of War” and Seized this American’s Truck
IJvids
904 views
Thumbnail for Barbara Branden on the Passion of Ayn Rand7:38
Barbara Branden on the Passion of Ayn Rand
ReasonVids
879 views
Thumbnail for Let's Compensate Bone Marrow Donors2:14
Let's Compensate Bone Marrow Donors
IJvids
884 views
Thumbnail for The Best and Worst Christmas Films (Libertarian Edition)3:33
The Best and Worst Christmas Films (Libertarian Edition)
ReasonVids
910 views
Thumbnail for Steve Forbes on Trump, Taxes, and 100 Years of Forbes Magazine16:35
Steve Forbes on Trump, Taxes, and 100 Years of Forbes Magazine
ReasonVids
964 views
Thumbnail for Former black block activist explains why Antifa are the tools of fascists.3:04
Former black block activist explains why Antifa are the tools of fascists.
bestofsaidit
1196 views
Thumbnail for Uppity coon gets beat the fuck down 0:37
Uppity coon gets beat the fuck down
bestofupgoat
71 views
Thumbnail for Absolutely brilliant parody of transwomen in an adaptation of the classic YMCA song - "Y Chromosome" | Mr Menno5:11
Absolutely brilliant parody of transwomen in an adaptation of the classic YMCA song - "Y Chromosome" | Mr Menno
bestofsaidit
1147 views
Thumbnail for The Simpsons Mr. Sparkle Commercial2:17
The Simpsons Mr. Sparkle Commercial
clips
879 views
Thumbnail for Based Swedish man tired of welfare leech niggers is not having it anymore.1:09
Based Swedish man tired of welfare leech niggers is not having it anymore.
AOU
6057 views
Thumbnail for Treat the customer like they treat you0:24
Treat the customer like they treat you
bestofvoatxyz
2215 views
Thumbnail for Prison for Smokers, Permits for Strippers! (Nanny of the Month, Jan '13)1:08
Prison for Smokers, Permits for Strippers! (Nanny of the Month, Jan '13)
ReasonVids
868 views
Thumbnail for The Psychology of Hate Crime Hoaxes10:20
The Psychology of Hate Crime Hoaxes
AmericanRenaissance
1671 views
Thumbnail for Assassin's Creed: Games with a Libertarian View of the World4:45
Assassin's Creed: Games with a Libertarian View of the World
ReasonVids
817 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian, reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv, high speed rail, biden, boondoggle, trains, gavin newsom, jerry brown, california, infrastructure, 2 trillion, shinkansen
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle