HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Don’t Jail Trump for January 6

Views:970
@ReasonVids

As the latest testimony at the January 6 committee hearings makes clear, there is no doubt that former President Donald Trump is morally responsible for the attack on the U.S. Capitol.
---------
https://reason.com/?posttype=video&p=8194521

But there's a big difference between being morally responsible and being criminally liable, and anyone who thinks this is going to end with Trump being prosecuted for incitement, and then going to prison, desperately needs a reality check.

Eyewitness testimony from the January 6 hearings earlier this week does show that Trump wanted his supporters to march to the Capitol. "I will be making a Big Speech at 10AM on January 6th at the Ellipse (South of the White House)," he wrote in a draft tweet that was never sent "Please arrive early, massive crowds expected. March to the Capitol after. Stop the Steal!!"

On December 19, he tweeted: "​Big protest in D.C. on January 6th. Be there, will be wild!"

During his actual speech just before the attack, Trump told his supporters to "fight like hell" and to march to the Capitol "peacefully and patriotically." Shortly after, the protests got out of hand, and some members of the crowd smashed the windows of the Capitol, pushed past police, and invaded the building.

It's fair to hold Trump responsible for that; if he had not stoked the mob's anger by falsely claiming, repeatedly, that Democrats were stealing the election from him, there would have been no riot.

But do Trump's actions meet the legal definition of incitement to violence? No.

Under federal law, incitement is defined as "urging or instigating other persons to riot." The landmark 1969 Supreme Court case Brandenburg v. Ohio established that speech must be both likely to incite "imminent lawless action" and "directed" at achieving that result.

Trump's words inspired lawless action but didn't specifically call on the mob to engage in it. Asking his supporters to march to the Capitol is protected by the First Amendment.

Now some media commentators have said that recent testimony from Cassidy Hutchinson, a former White House aide, changes the equation: She said under oath that Trump knew that some of the protesters were armed with weapons, and didn't seem to care.

But that isn't legally relevant. People don't lose their First and Second Amendment rights just because they're exercising them at the same time.

We should be glad that these rights are protected by the Constitution. You may not like Trump. Personally, I think he's unfit for office. But we don't want to live in a country where people can be sent to jail because they said the wrong thing. Everybody benefits from a legal regime in which the rights to speak, to protest, and to be armed are vigorously protected.

So let's not send Trump to jail. Let's just never send him back to the White House.

Written and produced by Robby Soave; edited by Regan Taylor.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 8)2:33
    Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 8)
    ReasonVids
    950 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Trump's Steel Tariffs Will Hurt Americans4:34
    Stossel: Trump's Steel Tariffs Will Hurt Americans
    ReasonVids
    960 views
    Thumbnail for California's Legal Weed Is So Heavily Taxed and Regulated That the Black Market Might Survive10:58
    California's Legal Weed Is So Heavily Taxed and Regulated That the Black Market Might Survive
    ReasonVids
    1033 views
    Thumbnail for Why Gay Marriage is Winning2:29
    Why Gay Marriage is Winning
    ReasonVids
    901 views
    Thumbnail for Grace VanderWaal, Sofie Dossi, And The Most Talented Kids! Wow! - America’s Got Talent | America's Got Talent13:43
    Grace VanderWaal, Sofie Dossi, And The Most Talented Kids! Wow! - America’s Got Talent | America's Got Talent
    agt.topic
    713 views
    Thumbnail for The Tavistock Institute: Destroying The World One Lie At A Time | HelioWave28:06
    The Tavistock Institute: Destroying The World One Lie At A Time | HelioWave
    bestofvoatxyz
    683 views
    Thumbnail for The Paleo Diet Delusion: Paleofantasy's Marlene Zuk on Dietary Myths5:30
    The Paleo Diet Delusion: Paleofantasy's Marlene Zuk on Dietary Myths
    ReasonVids
    916 views
    Thumbnail for Eugene Jarecki on His Drug-War Doc The House I Live In and Why Prohibition is Doomed9:16
    Eugene Jarecki on His Drug-War Doc The House I Live In and Why Prohibition is Doomed
    ReasonVids
    837 views
    Thumbnail for Kelly Thomas Verdict: Father, Protesters Speak Out Against Not Guilty Verdicts3:15
    Kelly Thomas Verdict: Father, Protesters Speak Out Against Not Guilty Verdicts
    ReasonVids
    927 views
    Thumbnail for Coongresswoman LaMonica McIver starts singing a song of dindu nuffin when confronted about her crimes on live tv 0:28
    Coongresswoman LaMonica McIver starts singing a song of dindu nuffin when confronted about her crimes on live tv
    bestofupgoat
    46 views
    Thumbnail for CAPTAIN KIRK TO BROTHER JED7:40
    CAPTAIN KIRK TO BROTHER JED
    ReasonVids
    876 views
    Thumbnail for Tyler Cowen on Creating Your Own Economy8:16
    Tyler Cowen on Creating Your Own Economy
    ReasonVids
    888 views
    Thumbnail for What We Saw at the Democratic Presidential Debate in Brooklyn3:12
    What We Saw at the Democratic Presidential Debate in Brooklyn
    ReasonVids
    873 views
    Thumbnail for How To Share the Restroom with a Trans Person0:27
    How To Share the Restroom with a Trans Person
    ReasonVids
    885 views
    Thumbnail for Is Money Speech? Free Speech Rules (Episode 5)4:02
    Is Money Speech? Free Speech Rules (Episode 5)
    ReasonVids
    995 views
    Thumbnail for "Startup Cities," Honduras, and Experiments in Freedom. Professor Tom W. Bell Talks With Reason.24:20
    "Startup Cities," Honduras, and Experiments in Freedom. Professor Tom W. Bell Talks With Reason.
    ReasonVids
    958 views
    Thumbnail for @SJohnsonVoiceOvers's 4 favorite moments from Jets vs. @browns! #nflcreatoroftheweek | NFL0:22
    @SJohnsonVoiceOvers's 4 favorite moments from Jets vs. @browns! #nflcreatoroftheweek | NFL
    invidious
    337 views
    Thumbnail for What Was Life Actually Like In Ancient Roman London? | Life and Death Roman London | History Hit51:34
    What Was Life Actually Like In Ancient Roman London? | Life and Death Roman London | History Hit
    invidious
    295 views
    Thumbnail for Rigged coin toss in Iowa - Disappearing from youtube0:16
    Rigged coin toss in Iowa - Disappearing from youtube
    koleslow
    2917 views
    Thumbnail for Victoria Police try to BAN media from filming their violent conduct1:00
    Victoria Police try to BAN media from filming their violent conduct
    bestofpoal
    1469 views
    Thumbnail for the loneliest block ever. | camman180:38
    the loneliest block ever. | camman18
    invidious
    114 views
    Thumbnail for Andrew Campanella on National School Choice Week 20130:57
    Andrew Campanella on National School Choice Week 2013
    ReasonVids
    851 views
    Thumbnail for Scooby Doo and the Rampoo Joo - BCM4:31
    Scooby Doo and the Rampoo Joo - BCM
    AOUisgay
    490 views
    Thumbnail for How Eva Moskowitz Outmuscled the Teachers Union16:52
    How Eva Moskowitz Outmuscled the Teachers Union
    ReasonVids
    990 views
    Thumbnail for Save money on Amazon — It's like a magic button for shopping | Save money on Amazon — It's like a magic button for shopping0:25
    Save money on Amazon — It's like a magic button for shopping | Save money on Amazon — It's like a magic button for shopping
    invidious
    372 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle