HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Why Hate Speech Laws Backfire

Views:1114
@ReasonVids

Here's a brutal irony about regulating hate speech: Such laws often end up hurting the very people they are supposed to protect.
------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV?subconfirmation=1
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------
That's one of the central lessons in Jacob Mchangama's important new book, Free Speech: A History from Socrates to Social Media. Mchangama heads up the Danish think tank Justitia. He's worried about a proposal that would make hate speech a crime under European Union (EU) law and give bureaucrats in Brussels sweeping powers to prosecute people spewing venom at religious and ethnic minorities, members of the LGBT+ community, women, and others. 

Europe's history with such laws argues against them. In the 1920s, Germany's Weimar Republic strictly regulated the press and invoked emergency powers to crack down on Nazi speech. It censored and prosecuted the editor of the anti-Semitic Nazi paper Der Stürmer, Julius Streicher, who used his trial as a platform for spreading his views and his imprisonment as a way of turning himself into a martyr and his cause into a crusade. When the Nazis took power in the early '30s, Mchangama stresses, they expanded existing laws and precedents to shut down dissent and freedom of assembly.

Contemporary scholarship suggests that there can be a "backlash effect" when governments shut down speech, leading otherwise moderate people to embrace fringe beliefs. Mchangama points to a 2017 study published in the European Journal of Political Research that concluded extremism in Western Europe was fueled in part by "extensive public repression of radical right actors and opinions."

In 1965, the United Kingdom passed a law banning "incitement to racial hatred," but one of the very first people prosecuted under it was a black Briton who called whites "vicious and nasty people" in a speech. More recently, Mchangama notes that radical feminists in England "have been charged with offending LGBT+ people because they insist there are biological differences between the sexes. In France, 'an LGBT+ rights organization was fined for calling an opponent of same-sex marriage a 'homophobe.'" 

"Once the principle of free speech is abandoned," warns Mchangama, "any minority can end up being targeted rather than protected by laws against hatred and offense."

That's what happened in Canada in the 1990s after the Supreme Court there ruled that words and images that "degrade" women should be banned. The decision was based in part on the legal theories of feminist author Andrea Dworkin, whose books on why pornography should be banned were briefly seized by Canadian customs agents under the laws she helped to inspire.

First Amendment rights are still popular in the United States, with 91 percent of us in a recent survey agreeing that "protecting free speech is an important part of American democracy." But 60 percent of us also said that the government should prohibit people from sharing a racist or bigoted idea.

Hearing hateful words and ideas outrages and discomforts most of us, but Mchangama's history of free speech underscores that state suppression can grant those words and ideas more power and influence. And that the best antidote to hate in a free and open society is not to hide from it but to openly—and persuasively—confront it.

Listen to my Reason Interview podcast with Jacob Mchangama at https://reason.com/podcast/2022/02/16/jacob-mchangama-how-hate-speech-laws-punish-minorities/.

Written by Nick Gillespie. Edited by Regan Taylor.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for The Right to Bear Arms Is Still a Check on Tyranny1:45
    The Right to Bear Arms Is Still a Check on Tyranny
    ReasonVids
    998 views
    Thumbnail for The Cruelty of the $15 Minimum Wage9:37
    The Cruelty of the $15 Minimum Wage
    ReasonVids
    990 views
    Thumbnail for More Money Doesn't Make Better Schools - Q&A with E3's Derrell Bradford1:03
    More Money Doesn't Make Better Schools - Q&A with E3's Derrell Bradford
    ReasonVids
    851 views
    Thumbnail for Raver girl cat fight with bonus KO0:16
    Raver girl cat fight with bonus KO
    bestofvoatxyz
    863 views
    Thumbnail for Another uppity nigress dragged off a plane- invokes Groid Floyd, goes full Gollum mode 1:40
    Another uppity nigress dragged off a plane- invokes Groid Floyd, goes full Gollum mode
    bestofupgoat
    449 views
    Thumbnail for Oh God, I messed up. | Phoenix SC3:29
    Oh God, I messed up. | Phoenix SC
    invidious
    384 views
    Thumbnail for Remy: Closer (Trump Inauguration Chainsmokers Parody)2:20
    Remy: Closer (Trump Inauguration Chainsmokers Parody)
    ReasonVids
    979 views
    Thumbnail for NYC Apartment residents say they are being terrorized, beaten by "teens"2:08
    NYC Apartment residents say they are being terrorized, beaten by "teens"
    bestofvoatxyz
    937 views
    Thumbnail for Monsanto Making Areas Radioactive in Idaho | Radioactive Drew12:00
    Monsanto Making Areas Radioactive in Idaho | Radioactive Drew
    invidious
    460 views
    Thumbnail for What if Everyone played Golf? + more videos | #aumsum #kids #children #education #whatif | AumSum What-If3:39
    What if Everyone played Golf? + more videos | #aumsum #kids #children #education #whatif | AumSum What-If
    invidious
    345 views
    Thumbnail for Golden retriever showers0:09
    Golden retriever showers
    bestofvoatxyz
    549 views
    Thumbnail for Andrew Garfield’s Quote…🥹❤️ | BoltMotivation0:49
    Andrew Garfield’s Quote…🥹❤️ | BoltMotivation
    invidious
    160 views
    Thumbnail for Pure Bloods Microwaved6:44
    Pure Bloods Microwaved
    bestofvoatxyz
    753 views
    Thumbnail for A McDonalds meal from nearly 30 years ago0:50
    A McDonalds meal from nearly 30 years ago
    bestofupgoat
    482 views
    Thumbnail for The New (and Old) Attacks on Free Thought: Jonathan Rauch on Kindly Inquisitors1:01:28
    The New (and Old) Attacks on Free Thought: Jonathan Rauch on Kindly Inquisitors
    ReasonVids
    740 views
    Thumbnail for Preparing You for Death Stranding 2 | videogamedunkey4:23
    Preparing You for Death Stranding 2 | videogamedunkey
    invidious
    175 views
    Thumbnail for Captain America vs Superman (Man of Steel) - MUGEN (Gameplay) S2 • E191:21
    Captain America vs Superman (Man of Steel) - MUGEN (Gameplay) S2 • E19
    memology101
    1391 views
    Thumbnail for This is Your Brain on Acid (Seriously)15:21
    This is Your Brain on Acid (Seriously)
    ReasonVids
    964 views
    Thumbnail for US Offers China A Grand Bargain | PDS News Clips0:43
    US Offers China A Grand Bargain | PDS News Clips
    invidious
    194 views
    Thumbnail for White Unity3:10
    White Unity
    bestofupgoat
    451 views
    Thumbnail for Errol Morris on Donald Rumsfeld, The Unknown Known, and Evidence-Based Journalism41:30
    Errol Morris on Donald Rumsfeld, The Unknown Known, and Evidence-Based Journalism
    ReasonVids
    938 views
    Thumbnail for Sleeping koala0:08
    Sleeping koala
    bestofupgoat
    432 views
    Thumbnail for THIS IS WHY I BACK THE BOYS IN BLUE!!! FUCK YOU CHILD KILLERS!!!!1:28
    THIS IS WHY I BACK THE BOYS IN BLUE!!! FUCK YOU CHILD KILLERS!!!!
    bestofupgoat
    188 views
    Thumbnail for The Women Who Would Be Veep8:48
    The Women Who Would Be Veep
    AmericanRenaissance
    1434 views
    Thumbnail for I see these stories all the time...0:38
    I see these stories all the time...
    bestofupgoat
    264 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle