HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Bureaucrats Are Trying to 'Control' School Choice

Views: 944
Reason's Matt Welch says controlling the choices of parents to send their kids to the school they want doesn't lead to a better education for students.
------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV?subconfirmation=1
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason

Reason is the leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------

School choice has proven consistently popular among one very dependable constituency: parents. And unpopular among another: unionized teachers. The rapid spread of school choice over the past 20 years has triggered an increasingly fierce union pushback, setting up an inevitable clash.

Enter an insidious yet helpfully descriptive new term in policymaking: "controlled choice." Yes, parents still get to "choose" their desired schools, but public education bureaucrats get to "control" the final outcome. And lately, from New York to San Francisco, Charlotte to Polk County, the main criteria that matters is not student performance, but race.

"New York City Schools Got A Little Less Segregated This Week," my local City Councilman in Brooklyn, Brad Lander, wrote at the beginning of this school year. "The Winner Is Everyone." Well, about that.

In 2007, the Supreme Court barred school districts from assigning students to schools based on race. So instead they use income as the primary determinant, and characterize the resulting admissions changes as "desegregation." The goal is to have poorer kids, homeless kids, and English-language learners spread evenly among schools, while crossing fingers that parents won't bolt and all schools will improve. 

When this system was tried in my kids' Brooklyn school district, it ended up being hellishly complicated. The team that designed New York City's school-picking algorithm literally won the Nobel Prize for Economics. Fun fact: One of those designers didn't like where the system placed his kid so he opted out and chose a charter. And I don't blame him!

The good news this year is that some kids who had never even considered some of the high-performing schools both applied and were admitted in higher numbers. School choice for the win!

But turns out parents don't much enjoy being controlled. One-size-fits-all schemes may look good on paper to progressives, but when applied to their own special snowflakes, suddenly lefty parents start sounding as skeptical of central planning as F.A. Hayek, or at least quietly eyeing the exits. After more than a half-decade of increasing enrollment, my district's 6th grade class shrunk by a whopping 7 percent this year.

What happens in Brooklyn, alas, doesn't stay in Brooklyn. The same policy process is underway in Queens, and parents are already revolting. The New York City school chancellor is not winning many new converts to these changes with his habit of calling skeptical parents "racist." Meanwhile the city is considering a mandate that would require every traditional public school have roughly the same racial, ethnic, and socioeconomic makeup within 10 years. Good luck with that. 

For full text, go to Reason.com:
https://reason.com/video/bureaucrats-are-trying-to-control-school-choice/

Written by Matt Welch. Edited by Paul Detrick. Shot by Jim Epstein.

"Beatles Unite" by Rachel K Collier is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
Source: https://www.youtube.com/audiolibrarydownload?vid=6dbb8a988dd32449
Artist: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCiHnYgtOn8u9YovYplMeXcw

Photo of council member Brad Lander; Credit: Erik McGregor/Sipa USA/Newscom; Photos of school funding protest; Credit: JIM RUYMEN/UPI/Newscom; Photos of protesters; Credit: JIM RUYMEN/UPI/Newscom; Chalkboard background; ID 83840626 © Oleksandr Shpak | Dreamstime.com; Photo of Alvin E. Roth; Credit: Rolf Vennenbernd/dpa/picture-alliance/Newscom; Photo of Brooklyn Bridge; Credit: David Agüero Muñoz/Westend61 GmbH/Newscom; Photo of Richard Carranza; Credit: Gabriele Holtermann-Gorden/ZUMA Press/Newscom; Brooklyn Bridge; Credit: ID 17307689 © Sinan Durdu | Dreamstime.com; Photo of charter school rally; Credit: Johnny Milano/Polaris/Newscom
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Inside the Campaign to Legalize Magic Mushrooms in California9:29
Inside the Campaign to Legalize Magic Mushrooms in California
ReasonVids
917 views
Thumbnail for Sackett v. EPA: How One Couple's Battle Against the Feds Might Protect Your Land7:39
Sackett v. EPA: How One Couple's Battle Against the Feds Might Protect Your Land
ReasonVids
976 views
Thumbnail for Stossel: End Racial Preferences at Colleges?4:23
Stossel: End Racial Preferences at Colleges?
ReasonVids
879 views
Thumbnail for Enjoying the sun0:07
Enjoying the sun
bestofupgoat
415 views
Thumbnail for Porker of The Month (August 2010): Rep. Hal Rogers!1:14
Porker of The Month (August 2010): Rep. Hal Rogers!
ReasonVids
813 views
Thumbnail for Would You Let Your Kids Walk All Alone in New York City?4:23
Would You Let Your Kids Walk All Alone in New York City?
ReasonVids
825 views
Thumbnail for Secrets of McDonald's12:33
Secrets of McDonald's
AOU
1702 views
Thumbnail for Was Italy's $1 Home Scheme Worth It? | True Cost | Insider News13:45
Was Italy's $1 Home Scheme Worth It? | True Cost | Insider News
invidious
248 views
Thumbnail for Jordan Peterson interrupts soviet general (C&C RA2) | Benzenas0:14
Jordan Peterson interrupts soviet general (C&C RA2) | Benzenas
invidious
323 views
Thumbnail for Pull Yourself Forward1:16
Pull Yourself Forward
amybird
1924 views
Thumbnail for Remy: I'll Be Missing You (Puff Daddy Incandescent Light Bulb Parody)2:30
Remy: I'll Be Missing You (Puff Daddy Incandescent Light Bulb Parody)
ReasonVids
910 views
Thumbnail for The Soros Biden Partnership in Ukraine1:13
The Soros Biden Partnership in Ukraine
LibertyIsTheLaw
43740 views
Thumbnail for Why Elizabeth Warren's Wealth Tax Won't Work5:21
Why Elizabeth Warren's Wealth Tax Won't Work
ReasonVids
1047 views
Thumbnail for Post-election press conference with Jim Mora, head coach of the Democrats0:21
Post-election press conference with Jim Mora, head coach of the Democrats
ReasonVids
981 views
Thumbnail for Creating a Free State: Filmmaker Christina Heller on Building a Libertopia in New Hampshire8:48
Creating a Free State: Filmmaker Christina Heller on Building a Libertopia in New Hampshire
ReasonVids
954 views
Thumbnail for The Fracturing of Communist Cuba’s Propaganda Machine4:58
The Fracturing of Communist Cuba’s Propaganda Machine
ReasonVids
868 views
Thumbnail for Judge Alex Kozinski: From Communist Romania to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals49:41
Judge Alex Kozinski: From Communist Romania to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals
ReasonVids
868 views
Thumbnail for The Conservatarian Manifesto: Should Libertarians & Conservatives Unite?25:27
The Conservatarian Manifesto: Should Libertarians & Conservatives Unite?
ReasonVids
923 views
Thumbnail for "America Has Ceased to Exist": Investment Guru Doug Casey on the Coming Economic Meltdown15:44
"America Has Ceased to Exist": Investment Guru Doug Casey on the Coming Economic Meltdown
ReasonVids
836 views
Thumbnail for State and Federal Laws Let Gov’t Police for Profit20:59
State and Federal Laws Let Gov’t Police for Profit
IJvids
997 views
Thumbnail for Zoning Will Make this Elderly Woman Homeless4:02
Zoning Will Make this Elderly Woman Homeless
IJvids
870 views
Thumbnail for Generation Opportunity, Politics, and Millennials: Q/A with Evan Feinberg5:51
Generation Opportunity, Politics, and Millennials: Q/A with Evan Feinberg
ReasonVids
924 views
Thumbnail for Surveillance State: Maryland is Listening to You8:12
Surveillance State: Maryland is Listening to You
ReasonVids
937 views
Thumbnail for Why Americans Are Suckers for Quick Fixes From Psychologists5:01
Why Americans Are Suckers for Quick Fixes From Psychologists
ReasonVids
881 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian, reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv, school choice, national school choice week, brooklyn, matt welch, charter schools
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle