HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Tucker Carlson's Great Replacement Theory Is Spectacularly Wrong

Views:1026
@ReasonVids

The great replacement theory is spectacularly wrong in asserting that the government is going to create millions of new citizens overnight. And it's wrong too, that in the unlikely event that happened, they will be "obedient" in voting for Democrats.

https://reason.com/video/2022/05/27/tucker-carlsons-great-replacement-theory-is-spectacularly-wrong/
-------------------
Tucker and his pals are also really worried about the government giving all sorts of new and better stuff to immigrants—brand-new bikes! twice the allowance!—but he's got it backward. Immigrants consume fewer welfare benefits than native-born Americans (about 39 percent less in average cash value). And when the U.S. has had a relatively open-door policy, government spending grew less quickly than in periods when immigration has been restricted.

The last truly major immigration law was passed in 1986 when Ronald Reagan signed bipartisan legislation that ultimately allowed 2.7 million illegal immigrants—mostly from Mexico—to gain citizenship. Since then, reform in Washington has proven elusive. Indeed, like George W. Bush's attempt in the mid-2000s, Joe Biden's stated desire to provide a path to citizenship for 11 million illegals has gone exactly nowhere, partly because he has maintained and even expanded some of Donald Trump's most-draconian policies.

But even if those immigrants somehow became citizens overnight, would they automatically vote for Democrats and produce what Rep. Stefanik calls a "permanent liberal majority in Washington"?

Consider this: Within a few years of Reagan's amnesty program, the GOP took control of the House for the first time in 40 years and held it from 1995 until 2007; they basically did the same with the Senate. After losing majorities in the Obama landslide, they've managed back majorities as well. So over the past 40 years—a time of high immigration—the Republican party has somehow managed to secure more congressional power than they did during the previous 40 years.

More recently, between 2016 and 2020, Donald Trump made gains with every demographic group except for white men. In the 2004 election, George W. Bush grabbed 44 percent of the Hispanic vote, only 5 points off the 49 percent of the Hispanic vote he secured in the 1998 Texas governor race. Believers in the great replacement theory might be surprised to learn that Greg Abbott won 44 percent of the Hispanic vote in his first run for the governor's mansion in 2014 and that Texas and Florida are not only the two fastest-growing major states, but they are also major magnets for immigrants and yet keep getting more and more Republican.

There's at least one more thing to consider too: Rep. Stefanik and other replacement theorists routinely inveigh against "reckless spending" and the need to "rein in government spending." But higher levels of immigration seem to discourage big hikes in government spending. It was only after the United States closed its borders that government spending ratcheted up sky-high.

As Alex Nowrasteh and Andrew C. Forrester of the Cato Institute have documented, between 1921 and 1968, restrictive immigration laws cut the percentage of the population that was foreign-born from 13 percent down to 4.8 percent. During that same period though, the New Deal and Great Society programs caused government spending as a percentage of GDP to soar from 6.9 percent to 18.9 percent—a hike of 174 percent. Immigration laws were loosened up in 1968, and the foreign-born population grew to almost 14 percent in 2017. Yet over the same time period, federal outlays as a percentage of GDP went from 18.9 percent to 20.4 percent, an increase of less than 8 percent.

What explains this phenomenon? "The Great Depression and other ideological shifts in public opinion were necessary for big changes in American policy during the New Deal, but they were politically possible because closed immigration removed the politically-effective immigrant welfare-queen argument," according to Nowrasteh and Forrester.

Ironically, if proponents of the great replacement theory actually want to get government spending under control, they'd best start lobbying for more newcomers, including from countries whose descendants voted in bigger numbers for Donald Trump in 2020 than they did in 2016.

Written and narrated by Nick Gillespie. Graphs by Issac Reese and Adani Samat. Edited by Regan Taylor.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for Destroying Islamic Fundamentalism With Books1:21:18
    Destroying Islamic Fundamentalism With Books
    ReasonVids
    854 views
    Thumbnail for "Let people do what they want with their own bodies and property": Q&A with Todd Seavey6:18
    "Let people do what they want with their own bodies and property": Q&A with Todd Seavey
    ReasonVids
    947 views
    Thumbnail for M'eeeeeeeeh! (baby goat sounds)0:11
    M'eeeeeeeeh! (baby goat sounds)
    bestofupgoat
    301 views
    Thumbnail for Tech Visionary George Gilder: "Bitcoin is the Libertarian Solution to the Money Enigma."19:22
    Tech Visionary George Gilder: "Bitcoin is the Libertarian Solution to the Money Enigma."
    ReasonVids
    1028 views
    Thumbnail for Dr. David Martin, Proof of COVID Criminal Conspiracy - EU Parliament Strasbourg - (9-13-2023) - WHO25:58
    Dr. David Martin, Proof of COVID Criminal Conspiracy - EU Parliament Strasbourg - (9-13-2023) - WHO
    AOUisgay
    494 views
    Thumbnail for Jewish civil war3:12
    Jewish civil war
    bestofupgoat
    74 views
    Thumbnail for Learning Geography: Voat Edition0:49
    Learning Geography: Voat Edition
    bestofupgoat
    226 views
    Thumbnail for Sheep leaf sea slug0:11
    Sheep leaf sea slug
    bestofupgoat
    381 views
    Thumbnail for How we're taking down Detroit's notorious car impound system8:22
    How we're taking down Detroit's notorious car impound system
    IJvids
    969 views
    Thumbnail for Pm Trudeau Gets Schooled By Xi On Leaking Private Conversations1:00
    Pm Trudeau Gets Schooled By Xi On Leaking Private Conversations
    bestofvoatxyz
    701 views
    Thumbnail for '손흥민 오늘 한국 온다' 토트넘 훗스퍼 선수단 입국 현장 l KNN생중계 | KNN NEWS1:00
    '손흥민 오늘 한국 온다' 토트넘 훗스퍼 선수단 입국 현장 l KNN생중계 | KNN NEWS
    invidious
    265 views
    Thumbnail for Will Charlie Lynch Avoid Prison For Legally Operating a Medical Marijuana Dispensary?3:49
    Will Charlie Lynch Avoid Prison For Legally Operating a Medical Marijuana Dispensary?
    ReasonVids
    942 views
    Thumbnail for Man gives German Shepherd dog the finger to save a smaller dog 0:46
    Man gives German Shepherd dog the finger to save a smaller dog
    bestofupgoat
    87 views
    Thumbnail for Cop Fired for Speaking Out Against Ticket and Arrest Quotas6:43
    Cop Fired for Speaking Out Against Ticket and Arrest Quotas
    ReasonVids
    893 views
    Thumbnail for Save The Baby. Home Rush10:00
    Save The Baby. Home Rush
    stumble_bro
    497 views
    Thumbnail for Why The Stimulus Isn't Working: Q & A with economist Richard McKenzie7:35
    Why The Stimulus Isn't Working: Q & A with economist Richard McKenzie
    ReasonVids
    924 views
    Thumbnail for Yaaaayyyyy!0:44
    Yaaaayyyyy!
    bestofupgoat
    105 views
    Thumbnail for I don't want to sound anti-semitic1:16
    I don't want to sound anti-semitic
    bestofupgoat
    465 views
    Thumbnail for I'm with Sebastian the Cart Narc0:59
    I'm with Sebastian the Cart Narc
    bestofupgoat
    77 views
    Thumbnail for MonkeyPox is real0:59
    MonkeyPox is real
    bestofupgoat
    250 views
    Thumbnail for Remy: Old Town Road (Lil Nas X & Billy Ray Cyrus Parody)2:05
    Remy: Old Town Road (Lil Nas X & Billy Ray Cyrus Parody)
    ReasonVids
    950 views
    Thumbnail for Kaufman Institute for Coincidence1:59
    Kaufman Institute for Coincidence
    bestofupgoat
    526 views
    Thumbnail for Clean it up BITCH! 1:06
    Clean it up BITCH!
    bestofupgoat
    257 views
    Thumbnail for Biggest Liar On This Site! 🤥 original content1:12
    Biggest Liar On This Site! 🤥 original content
    bestofupgoat
    95 views
    Thumbnail for Gaza was turned into a huge amazement park0:13
    Gaza was turned into a huge amazement park
    bestofupgoat
    436 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle