HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

The Coronavirus Testing Debacle Stems From Decades of Bad FDA Policy

Views: 988
The FDA's emphasis on caution over speed led to needless suffering and loss of life long before the #COVID-19 pandemic.
#Coronavirus #COVID19 #FDA #Testing
------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV?subconfirmation=1
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason

Reason is the leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------

The delay in COVID-19 testing in the United States meant that for weeks doctors and public officials were flying blind about who was infected and where major outbreaks were located. This means that they had little hope of containing the virus before it started spreading out of control.

Why did the U.S. fall behind almost every other country in this regard?

The root of the problem is the Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) culture of extreme caution, which led to needless suffering and loss of life long before the coronavirus pandemic. In this case, its impact is so high profile and far-reaching that the episode could finally bring lasting reform.

The genetic sequence for COVID-19 was published on January 10th by Chinese scientists and uploaded to the National Institute of Health's website, allowing laboratories around the world to create their own diagnostic tests.

German scientists had one within the week, and other countries and private labs quickly followed suit. The World Health Organization shipped 250,000 German-made tests to labs around the world.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control (CDC) decided it needed to rely on its own version of the test, which could be certified by the FDA, but it wasn't ready until early February.

On February 6 and 7, 90 tests were shipped to state public health labs around the country, but the kits had a technical flaw and needed to be returned to the CDC for testing.

Meanwhile, the virus continued spreading.

On February 4, the FDA said it would allow government-approved labs with high complexity testing capabilities to create their own tests, provided they copy the CDC's approach and send all of their results to the agency's headquarters in Atlanta for verification. 

As former FDA Principal Deputy Commissioner Joshua Sharfstein told The New Yorker: "You certainly wouldn't want to say, 'Any lab can advertise a coronavirus test.' Because then it's going to be chaos. There are a lot of people who will sell things that may or may not work."

Though well-intentioned, the rule became a stumbling block.

Take the case of Alex Greninger, a doctor and researcher at the University of Washington, who, according to a report in GQ, submitted his application to create a coronavirus test via email. Then he learned that he also needed to submit a paper copy, and then another version burned to a compact disk or loaded onto a drive and delivered to the FDA's Maryland headquarters.

After he complied, the FDA did not approve his test right away, according to a report in ProPublica. They asked him to make sure his test didn't cross-diagnose with SARS and MERS, other coronaviruses which hadn't been seen in the U.S. in years. His test was finally certified on February 29, at which point the fatal outbreak in his home state of Washington was already underway. 

As the crisis worsened and the testing shortage drew headlines, the FDA simplified the process. But then on March 20, it shut down efforts to rapidly make available at-home testing kits on the grounds that they were unvetted and could be fraudulent.

The first documented cases of COVID-19 in the U.S. and South Korea were discovered around the same time. Yet, as of March 17, 1 out of 4,300 Americans had been tested. In South Korea, it was 1 out of 17. Had diagnostic tests for COVID-19 been available sooner, they would have helped public health officials isolate, quarantine, and provide medical supplies to areas of the U.S. affected by the virus.

How could this happen? This tragic testing delay has brought national attention to the FDA's longstanding, overly cautious approach to regulating American health care. To minimize risk, the agency has sacrificed speed—preventing doctors and patients from accessing the tools they need—until it's too late.

Produced and edited by Paul Detrick.

For photo credits, go here: https://reason.com/video/the-coronavirus-…f-bad-fda-policy/
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for When It Comes to Coronavirus, Nobody Knows Anything31:00
When It Comes to Coronavirus, Nobody Knows Anything
ReasonVids
887 views
Thumbnail for How City Hall is F*cking Record Store Day!3:47
How City Hall is F*cking Record Store Day!
ReasonVids
935 views
Thumbnail for Out Of Shadows Documentary1:17:37
Out Of Shadows Documentary
AOU
1563 views
Thumbnail for Singularity University's Salim Ismail on the Age of Technological Disruption5:19
Singularity University's Salim Ismail on the Age of Technological Disruption
ReasonVids
841 views
Thumbnail for How to Replace Coolant For Honda Accord | Genius Asian18:35
How to Replace Coolant For Honda Accord | Genius Asian
cars.topic
733 views
Thumbnail for Charles Murray: Why America is Coming Apart Along Class Lines34:46
Charles Murray: Why America is Coming Apart Along Class Lines
ReasonVids
774 views
Thumbnail for Strippers v. the Supreme Court: Live Nude Theater!2:33
Strippers v. the Supreme Court: Live Nude Theater!
ReasonVids
944 views
Thumbnail for Outraged Fullerton citizens react to Kelly Thomas beating tape3:14
Outraged Fullerton citizens react to Kelly Thomas beating tape
ReasonVids
832 views
Thumbnail for  Graham Linehan says he won’t work with Channel 4 again unless transphobic IT Crowd episode is reinstated2:50
Graham Linehan says he won’t work with Channel 4 again unless transphobic IT Crowd episode is reinstated
bestofphuks
2144 views
Thumbnail for GEN Z: WE ARE DOOMED | Pancho9:28
GEN Z: WE ARE DOOMED | Pancho
invidious
407 views
Thumbnail for Secret Art   Fantasy Nude | Agostinho Rodrigues6:15
Secret Art Fantasy Nude | Agostinho Rodrigues
science.topic
16 views
Thumbnail for 'I Use Heroin to Be a Better Person': Columbia University Neuroscientist Carl Hart6:40
'I Use Heroin to Be a Better Person': Columbia University Neuroscientist Carl Hart
ReasonVids
951 views
Thumbnail for Reason.tv at Sundance: The Most Famous Flag Burner of All Time!5:09
Reason.tv at Sundance: The Most Famous Flag Burner of All Time!
ReasonVids
855 views
Thumbnail for Hong Kong Is in Trouble. Let Its People Escape China by Coming to America.7:03
Hong Kong Is in Trouble. Let Its People Escape China by Coming to America.
ReasonVids
978 views
Thumbnail for Hangover Heaven: The Vegas Hangover Cure on Wheels3:01
Hangover Heaven: The Vegas Hangover Cure on Wheels
ReasonVids
879 views
Thumbnail for Rune Chat #98: Simulation Hypothesis ft. Endxr1:12:43
Rune Chat #98: Simulation Hypothesis ft. Endxr
RuneChat
710 views
Thumbnail for First attempt at a nature camera resulted in a zen recording19:04
First attempt at a nature camera resulted in a zen recording
moonchance
2668 views
Thumbnail for YouTube Won't Host Our Homemade Gun Video. So We Posted It on PornHub Instead.4:19
YouTube Won't Host Our Homemade Gun Video. So We Posted It on PornHub Instead.
ReasonVids
1000 views
Thumbnail for Textbook physics problem0:26
Textbook physics problem
publicfreakouts
685 views
Thumbnail for ISIS Runs Luxury Hotel in Iraq Now1:28
ISIS Runs Luxury Hotel in Iraq Now
ReasonVids
848 views
Thumbnail for Why John McCain Loves Being the Underdog2:02
Why John McCain Loves Being the Underdog
ReasonVids
834 views
Thumbnail for Is Colorado Pot Overtaxed and Over-Regulated Already?8:22
Is Colorado Pot Overtaxed and Over-Regulated Already?
ReasonVids
952 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian, reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle