HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Procedurally Deficient Court Strips Elderly Woman of Her Home and Ruins Her Life

Views: 801
When a court proceeding may result in a person losing their home, the U.S. Constitution demands a fair process with rigorous safeguards against erroneous deprivation. For defendants appearing in the Division 14 of the Shelby County, Tennessee, General Sessions Court, Criminal Division, which hears housing code cases and is known as the Environmental Court, the process they receive is anything but fair.

https://ij.org/case/memphis-environmental-court/

Sarah Hohenberg’s journey through the Environmental Court has left her bankrupt, homeless, stripped of her possessions, and a fugitive from the law. In 2009, a tree fell on her home causing significant damage. While she tried to get her insurance to repair her home, Ms. Hohenberg’s neighbors sued her in the Environmental Court, trapping her there for a decade. It is not an overstatement to say that this suit ruined Ms. Hohenberg’s life—she lost her house, the court’s multi-year proceedings caused her to deplete her finances on lawyers, and the court ordered her possessions removed from the house, leaving them to be stolen or carried away. Unable to meet the court’s ever-changing repair goalposts, Ms. Hohenberg lost the home that she owned outright. Humiliated and destitute, she fled to Mississippi as a fugitive because she refused to sign over her home. She is now ill, bankrupt, and homeless.

Like Sarah, Joseph Hanson also lost his home in Environmental Court proceedings after a tree fell on it. Despite no valid testimonial or evidentiary basis, the Environmental Court jailed Mr. Hanson numerous times and bulldozed his home and destroyed his possessions. He, too, is now homeless.

Ms. Hohenberg and Mr. Hanson arrived at this spot through a woefully constitutionally deficient process that took years to complete. In the Environmental Court, witnesses are not sworn in, nor do they attest that their testimony will be truthful. There is regularly hearsay testimony. Evidence, such as it is, is not authenticated. People “testify” from the courtroom audience. When witnesses testify, there is no foundation laid to determine their ability to provide evidence. The court does not follow the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure or the Tennessee Rules of Evidence. Instead, the Environmental Court’s proceedings are governed by the Shelby County General Session Rules—Criminal Division Rules, which is six pages long and largely concerns courtroom decorum.

Worse yet, the Environmental Court is not a “court of record” under Tennessee law, meaning that its proceedings are not transcribed or recorded. Appeals from the Environmental Court go directly to the Tennessee Court of Appeals, meaning that while a person may, in theory, appeal from an Environmental Court decision, there is no record for the Court of Appeals to examine. It is a right to appeal in name only.

Now, Sarah and Joseph have partnered with the Institute for Justice to ensure that court procedures involving occupied homes follow stringent procedural protections. This case aims to ensure that the Environmental Court, and similar housing courts across the country, comply with the due process clause of the U.S. Constitution.

https://ij.org/case/memphis-environmental-court/
Donate to IJ: https://ij.org/support/give-now/
@IJvidsfollow
Thumbnail for Professional Counselor Stands up to DC for the Right to Talk to Clients Online2:50
Professional Counselor Stands up to DC for the Right to Talk to Clients Online
IJvids
925 views
Thumbnail for I can fix her bro0:07
I can fix her bro
AOUisgay
633 views
Thumbnail for Just a beauty0:16
Just a beauty
bestofsaidit
4574 views
Thumbnail for Always amaze the lesser races0:09
Always amaze the lesser races
bestofupgoat
480 views
Thumbnail for Why The U.S. Won’t Pay Down Its Debt | CNBC11:28
Why The U.S. Won’t Pay Down Its Debt | CNBC
invidious
272 views
Thumbnail for How to Deal with Cops: Q&A with Steve Silverman of Flex Your Rights9:07
How to Deal with Cops: Q&A with Steve Silverman of Flex Your Rights
ReasonVids
835 views
Thumbnail for Nig gets spooked0:06
Nig gets spooked
bestofupgoat
511 views
Thumbnail for Remy: 'Full House’ (San Francisco Real Estate Parody)1:30
Remy: 'Full House’ (San Francisco Real Estate Parody)
ReasonVids
846 views
Thumbnail for ManBearPig, Climategate and Watermelons: A conversation with author James Delingpole9:52
ManBearPig, Climategate and Watermelons: A conversation with author James Delingpole
ReasonVids
767 views
Thumbnail for Live from the Bradley Manning Trial with Alexa O'Brien4:32
Live from the Bradley Manning Trial with Alexa O'Brien
ReasonVids
787 views
Thumbnail for What We Saw at NYC's Fast Food Strike2:30
What We Saw at NYC's Fast Food Strike
ReasonVids
955 views
Thumbnail for TikTok Israeli Model0:16
TikTok Israeli Model
guitar
519 views
Thumbnail for ENA - Power of Potluck9:52
ENA - Power of Potluck
invidious
362 views
Thumbnail for Don’t Worry Li’l Fella. Somewhere, a negress is no longer bald thanks to you.0:55
Don’t Worry Li’l Fella. Somewhere, a negress is no longer bald thanks to you.
bestofvoatxyz
604 views
Thumbnail for Judge: I am dropping your charges Me: Thanks I won't do it again My lawyer: | FunnyMemeSpot0:07
Judge: I am dropping your charges Me: Thanks I won't do it again My lawyer: | FunnyMemeSpot
invidious
189 views
Thumbnail for What the U.S. Media Get Wrong About Brexit: Daniel Hannan34:25
What the U.S. Media Get Wrong About Brexit: Daniel Hannan
ReasonVids
886 views
Thumbnail for 최파고가 말한다 부자가 되는 3단계 f. 미래에셋증권 최홍석 선임매니저 [글로벌 이슈체크] | 삼프로TV_경제의신과함께43:50
최파고가 말한다 부자가 되는 3단계 f. 미래에셋증권 최홍석 선임매니저 [글로벌 이슈체크] | 삼프로TV_경제의신과함께
invidious
299 views
Thumbnail for CPAC: The Conservative Case for Criminal Justice Reform3:51
CPAC: The Conservative Case for Criminal Justice Reform
ReasonVids
908 views
Thumbnail for Hope For a Better Drug Policy: "America's Longest War" Panel Discussion25:02
Hope For a Better Drug Policy: "America's Longest War" Panel Discussion
ReasonVids
854 views
Thumbnail for United We Stand 1:22
United We Stand
bestofvoatxyz
604 views
Thumbnail for Florida: Open for Business?0:57
Florida: Open for Business?
IJvids
813 views
Thumbnail for Gas Kikes (The Strokes: Last Nite)3:15
Gas Kikes (The Strokes: Last Nite)
judenhass
424 views
Thumbnail for The Importance of Uncomfortable Conversations11:01
The Importance of Uncomfortable Conversations
ReasonVids
765 views

points

Permalink
Reply
ij, institute for justice, freedom, liberty, individual rights, constitution, constitutional law, unconstitutional law, con law, constitutional litigation
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle