HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Is It OK To Punch a Nazi? We Asked Berkeley Students.

Views:1002
@ReasonVids

A year after fiery political protests erupted on campus, we visited to find out when students think it's OK to respond to words with violence.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.

---

Is it OK to punch a Nazi?

It was a hotly debated question for months after video of white nationalist Richard Spencer getting punched in the middle of an interview on the day of Donald Trump's inauguration went viral and inspired countless remixes.

But the question was never really just about Nazis. It is about the acceptability of political violence. And in the following year the question came up and again and again as several high-profile political protests turn violent, including at UC Berkeley, often considered the birthplace of the free speech movement in the 60s.

On February 1, 2017, the nation watched the University of California Berkeley burn as masked members of the far-left group Antifa lit fires, threw safety barriers through store windows, physically attacked people, and threw rocks at the police.

The riots were sparked by the arrival of right-wing provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos, who was invited to speak by a conservative student group. President Trump helped ignite the controversy by tweeting a threat to pull federal funding from Berkeley, and the event was ultimately canceled. Protests continued throughout the rest of the year as more conservative speakers were drawn to the Berkeley campus.

We visited Berkeley about a year after that protest-turned-riot to ask students whether punching Nazis, or other deplorables, is ever OK.

The students we talked to said that the violence was carried out almost entirely by outsiders. Antifa, short for anti-fascist, is a decentralized movement that rejects nonviolence and vows to fight whatever or whomever it identifies as fascist by any means necessary.

Most of the students with whom we spoke condemned the group and its tactics, but many also sympathized with their aims and said they wouldn't blame those engaging in violence against people they deemed Nazis.

But if the use of violence to counter certain ideas is acceptable, it becomes difficult to avoid a slide down the slippery slope into advocating violence against a broad array of political opponents. The response to the assault on Richard Spencer was hardly the only instance of a blase reaction to violence among the media, politicians, and celebrities.

The brutal attack on Senator Rand Paul, which left him with bruised lungs and six broken ribs, was met with suggestions that he had it coming because of his libertarian views. And they haven't stopped.

Putting aside the question of whether or not preemptive political violence is moral, is it actually effective?

In Why Civil Resistance Works, political scientists Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan compared nonviolent and violent movements through history and found that the nonviolent ones were more than twice as effective at achieving their goals.

Princeton researcher Omar Wasow found that the nonviolent protests of the early civil rights movement changed minds, while the left-wing riots in the late 60s likely tipped the presidential election in favor of Richard Nixon.

And if Antifa members still want to punch so-called Nazis, they should pay attention to the work of historian Laurie Marhoefer, who studies real Nazis and says the party often rallied close to its adversaries in order to provoke them, drawing a violent reaction that swayed public opinion in its favor.

Produced by Zach Weissmueller and Justin Monticello.
Camera by Paul Detrick and Monticello.
Music by Krackatoa, Kai Engel, and Teehoteeho available at http://freemusicarchive.org
Licensed under Creative Commons, CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 US
http://www.krackatoa.com
https://www.kai-engel.com
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
punch a nazi
,
richard spencer
,
white nationalists
,
free speech
,
protest
,
berkeley
,
milo yiannopolis
,
alt right
,
mlk
,
nonviolence
,
social change
,
zach weissmueller
,
justin monticello
    Thumbnail for Poker Champion Annie Duke on Making Smart Bets in Life, Politics, and Football18:56
    Poker Champion Annie Duke on Making Smart Bets in Life, Politics, and Football
    ReasonVids
    988 views
    Thumbnail for Halo 2 Classic - Team Slayer - Ascension (XBOX ONE) | Mystical Gaming7:31
    Halo 2 Classic - Team Slayer - Ascension (XBOX ONE) | Mystical Gaming
    invidious
    444 views
    Thumbnail for We all kmow at least one 0:11
    We all kmow at least one
    bestofupgoat
    74 views
    Thumbnail for I Turned The FOREST Into A TRAP BASE! | ReksMore Adventures10:40
    I Turned The FOREST Into A TRAP BASE! | ReksMore Adventures
    invidious
    458 views
    Thumbnail for UFC 310 LIVE PANTOJA VS ASAKURA LIVESTREAM & FULL FIGHT COMPANION | THE MMA GURU5:23:23
    UFC 310 LIVE PANTOJA VS ASAKURA LIVESTREAM & FULL FIGHT COMPANION | THE MMA GURU
    invidious
    174 views
    Thumbnail for Dragon ball GT Is "Canon" to Dragon Ball Z | Blackenfist8:24
    Dragon ball GT Is "Canon" to Dragon Ball Z | Blackenfist
    invidious
    438 views
    Thumbnail for Forecast 2024 - What To Expect From The New Year | Teal Swan12:14
    Forecast 2024 - What To Expect From The New Year | Teal Swan
    invidious
    341 views
    Thumbnail for FLAMENGO ATROPELA CORINTHIANS; PALMEIRAS PERDE EM CASA; VASCO DEMITE CARILLE | De Placa 28/04/25 | De Placa1:36:31
    FLAMENGO ATROPELA CORINTHIANS; PALMEIRAS PERDE EM CASA; VASCO DEMITE CARILLE | De Placa 28/04/25 | De Placa
    invidious
    110 views
    Thumbnail for PUSH RANK COMPE PARTY ANOMALI PART 30 | RRQ Skylar4:43:27
    PUSH RANK COMPE PARTY ANOMALI PART 30 | RRQ Skylar
    invidious
    129 views
    Thumbnail for "The Real Sun" by Danny Wilten - As Above, So Below Explained13:59
    "The Real Sun" by Danny Wilten - As Above, So Below Explained
    bestofvoatxyz
    876 views
    Thumbnail for Be the change you want to see in the world0:27
    Be the change you want to see in the world
    AOUisgay
    535 views
    Thumbnail for 🎄💦 #StrayKids #스트레이키즈 #리노 #LeeKnow #아이엔 #I_N #合 #HOP #WalkinOnWater #StrayKidsComeback | Stray Kids0:16
    🎄💦 #StrayKids #스트레이키즈 #리노 #LeeKnow #아이엔 #I_N #合 #HOP #WalkinOnWater #StrayKidsComeback | Stray Kids
    invidious
    153 views
    Thumbnail for Force on Force Training, Pepper Balls and Rubber Impact Rounds | hard2hurt19:55
    Force on Force Training, Pepper Balls and Rubber Impact Rounds | hard2hurt
    invidious
    436 views
    Thumbnail for Milaad K - Sorry U Changed (Official Music Video) | Milaad K2:32
    Milaad K - Sorry U Changed (Official Music Video) | Milaad K
    invidious
    91 views
    Thumbnail for Surgical Note Flap 🎶 #goodtoknow #funfacts #suturing #surgery #vet #medicine #surgeon #surgeonlife | Vetventures0:31
    Surgical Note Flap 🎶 #goodtoknow #funfacts #suturing #surgery #vet #medicine #surgeon #surgeonlife | Vetventures
    invidious
    159 views
    Thumbnail for Biden Remembers Justin Trudeau - KDS Clip | KyleDunnigan1:33
    Biden Remembers Justin Trudeau - KDS Clip | KyleDunnigan
    invidious
    532 views
    Thumbnail for LA PRIMA JUVE DI TUDOR (e YILDIZ) a CASA JUVENTIBUS | Juventibus2:01:29
    LA PRIMA JUVE DI TUDOR (e YILDIZ) a CASA JUVENTIBUS | Juventibus
    invidious
    156 views
    Thumbnail for confrontation1:29
    confrontation
    bestofvoatxyz
    468 views
    Thumbnail for Clark Neily: H.B. 3637 Would Keep Horse Teeth Floating Legal in Texas & Protect Horse Owners3:51
    Clark Neily: H.B. 3637 Would Keep Horse Teeth Floating Legal in Texas & Protect Horse Owners
    IJvids
    1075 views
    Thumbnail for Queens Man OUT SMARTS NYC Democrats | Actual Justice Warrior10:17
    Queens Man OUT SMARTS NYC Democrats | Actual Justice Warrior
    invidious
    110 views
    Thumbnail for Peter Schiff on the Fed, Rand Paul, and the Next Financial Crisis12:53
    Peter Schiff on the Fed, Rand Paul, and the Next Financial Crisis
    ReasonVids
    1039 views
    Thumbnail for Crispin Sartwell - Anarchist Philosopher5:16
    Crispin Sartwell - Anarchist Philosopher
    ReasonVids
    967 views
    Thumbnail for Top 3 Medical Glove Hacks #goodtoknow #lifeskills #tutorial #vet #medicine #funfacts #surgeonlife | Vetventures0:57
    Top 3 Medical Glove Hacks #goodtoknow #lifeskills #tutorial #vet #medicine #funfacts #surgeonlife | Vetventures
    invidious
    127 views
    Thumbnail for Zoomcopter Kiosks2:07
    Zoomcopter Kiosks
    x0x7
    3031 views
    Thumbnail for The Whitest Kids U'Know Season 4 Episode 820:58
    The Whitest Kids U'Know Season 4 Episode 8
    wkuk.topic
    559 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
punch a nazi
,
richard spencer
,
white nationalists
,
free speech
,
protest
,
berkeley
,
milo yiannopolis
,
alt right
,
mlk
,
nonviolence
,
social change
,
zach weissmueller
,
justin monticello
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle