HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Saving Lives: Challenging the Ban on Compensating Bone Marrow Donors

Views:915
@IJvids

FOR MORE ON THIS CASE, VISIT http://www.ij.org/bonemarrow

Every year, 1,000 Americans die because they cannot find a matching bone marrow donor. Minorities are hit especially hard. Common sense suggests that offering modest incentives to attract more bone marrow donors would be worth pursuing, but federal law makes that a felony punishable by up to five years in prison.

That is why on October 28, 2009, adults with deadly blood diseases, the parents of sick children, a California nonprofit and a world-renowned medical doctor who specializes in bone marrow research joined with the Institute for Justice to launch a legal fight against the U.S. Attorney General to put an end to a ban on offering compensation for bone marrow donors.

The National Organ Transplant Act (NOTA) of 1984 treats compensation for marrow donors as though it were black-market organ sales. Under NOTA, giving a college student a scholarship or a new homeowner a mortgage payment for donating marrow would land everyone—doctors, nurses, donors and patients—in federal prison for up to five years.

NOTAs criminal ban violates equal protection because it arbitrarily treats renewable bone marrow like nonrenewable solid organs instead of like other renewable or inexhaustible cells—such as blood—for which compensated donation is legal. That makes no sense because bone marrow, unlike organs such as kidneys, replenishes itself in just a few weeks after it is donated, leaving the donor whole once again. The ban also violates substantive due process because it irrationally interferes with the right to participate in safe, accepted, lifesaving, and otherwise legal medical treatment.


The only thing the bone marrow provision of NOTA appears to accomplish is unnecessary deaths. A victory in this case will not only give hope to thousands facing deadly diseases, but also reaffirm bedrock principles about constitutional protection for individual liberty. This is the first time NOTA has ever been the subject of a constitutional challenge.

'Actual Bone Marrow Donation' photo reproduced under a Creative Commons license from flickr user limowreck666.
Donate to IJ: https://ij.org/support/give-now/

institute
,
for
,
justice
,
bone
,
marrow
,
donation
,
compensation
,
scholarship
,
fanconi
,
anemia
,
leukemia
,
national
,
organ
,
transplant
,
act
,
flynn
,
v.
,
holder
,
economic
,
liberty
,
equal
,
protection
,
constitutional
,
challenge
,
lawsuit
,
doreen
,
akiim
,
deshay
,
jeff
,
rowes
,
chip
,
mellor
,
doctor
,
dr
,
john
,
wagner
,
mike
,
hamel
,
shaka
,
mitchell
,
kumud
,
majumder
,
mark
,
hachey
    Thumbnail for Challenging the Ban on Compensating Bone Marrow Donors - Press Conference 10/28/0915:22
    Challenging the Ban on Compensating Bone Marrow Donors - Press Conference 10/28/09
    IJvids
    988 views
    Thumbnail for Doom II - Nostalgia map26 (Sepulchural Slaughter) - UV-Max (fast monsters) | ryiron8:17
    Doom II - Nostalgia map26 (Sepulchural Slaughter) - UV-Max (fast monsters) | ryiron
    invidious
    448 views
    Thumbnail for AU: Pensioner Arrested For Inciting Violence For Projecting The Letter 'Z' On The Sydney Opera House2:49
    AU: Pensioner Arrested For Inciting Violence For Projecting The Letter 'Z' On The Sydney Opera House
    AOUisgay
    541 views
    Thumbnail for Riverside Cop Tricks Autistic Teen into Buying Pot7:08
    Riverside Cop Tricks Autistic Teen into Buying Pot
    ReasonVids
    892 views
    Thumbnail for Duck Vs. Tiger0:10
    Duck Vs. Tiger
    bestofvoatxyz
    1772 views
    Thumbnail for Testing the Limits of Delivery Drones! (with @theslowmoguys) | Adam Savage’s Tested22:13
    Testing the Limits of Delivery Drones! (with @theslowmoguys) | Adam Savage’s Tested
    invidious
    165 views
    Thumbnail for pride month in india0:47
    pride month in india
    bestofupgoat
    114 views
    Thumbnail for Sheboons loot store, almost shove old elderly women in escape0:41
    Sheboons loot store, almost shove old elderly women in escape
    bestofvoatxyz
    780 views
    Thumbnail for Kitty Kitty0:54
    Kitty Kitty
    bestofupgoat
    345 views
    Thumbnail for Top 10 BIGGEST Self-Haircut Mistakes To Avoid | Alex Kouras10:58
    Top 10 BIGGEST Self-Haircut Mistakes To Avoid | Alex Kouras
    invidious
    464 views
    Thumbnail for The Shortest Cup of The Day Track Ever | WirtualTV9:43
    The Shortest Cup of The Day Track Ever | WirtualTV
    invidious
    384 views
    Thumbnail for Probably just wanted to play, but some damn good protection & defense!0:21
    Probably just wanted to play, but some damn good protection & defense!
    bestofvoatxyz
    853 views
    Thumbnail for Baby octopus0:07
    Baby octopus
    bestofupgoat
    412 views
    Thumbnail for What the DHS Leaks Prove About Our Government | Grunt Speak2:53
    What the DHS Leaks Prove About Our Government | Grunt Speak
    Terrence Popp
    525 views
    Thumbnail for Hanukkah officially canceled0:07
    Hanukkah officially canceled
    AOUisgay
    448 views
    Thumbnail for Vanished Where Is Nicola Bulley?55:26
    Vanished Where Is Nicola Bulley?
    bestofvid8
    448 views
    Thumbnail for Calm Down - Clay Higgins from Louisiana - Truth In Media40:07
    Calm Down - Clay Higgins from Louisiana - Truth In Media
    AOUisgay
    485 views
    Thumbnail for Virat Kohli brings up his 4th 50+ score against PAK in ICC ODI Events! #ChampionsTrophyOnJioStar | Star Sports0:30
    Virat Kohli brings up his 4th 50+ score against PAK in ICC ODI Events! #ChampionsTrophyOnJioStar | Star Sports
    invidious
    91 views
    Thumbnail for The Most Remote Places on Earth | Thomas Mulligan0:56
    The Most Remote Places on Earth | Thomas Mulligan
    invidious
    224 views
    Thumbnail for Secrets of witchcraft they don’t want you to know - Sheila Zelinsky and Dr Erica Shepherd discuss what witches do and how to overcome the power of their curses and spells.10:12
    Secrets of witchcraft they don’t want you to know - Sheila Zelinsky and Dr Erica Shepherd discuss what witches do and how to overcome the power of their curses and spells.
    bestofsaidit
    716 views
    Thumbnail for Remy: The Equality Song1:50
    Remy: The Equality Song
    ReasonVids
    922 views
    Thumbnail for be ungovernable0:44
    be ungovernable
    bestofupgoat
    413 views
    Thumbnail for Turning Red Cooking Scene but with just sound effects | Josh Harmon0:20
    Turning Red Cooking Scene but with just sound effects | Josh Harmon
    invidious
    313 views
    Thumbnail for Arise News Live | Arise News1:00
    Arise News Live | Arise News
    invidious
    274 views
    Thumbnail for The Obsolete man3:38
    The Obsolete man
    bestofpoal
    1701 views

points

Permalink
Reply
institute
,
for
,
justice
,
bone
,
marrow
,
donation
,
compensation
,
scholarship
,
fanconi
,
anemia
,
leukemia
,
national
,
organ
,
transplant
,
act
,
flynn
,
v.
,
holder
,
economic
,
liberty
,
equal
,
protection
,
constitutional
,
challenge
,
lawsuit
,
doreen
,
akiim
,
deshay
,
jeff
,
rowes
,
chip
,
mellor
,
doctor
,
dr
,
john
,
wagner
,
mike
,
hamel
,
shaka
,
mitchell
,
kumud
,
majumder
,
mark
,
hachey
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle