HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Philly Tour Guides Return to Federal Court

Views: 890
CASE PAGE: http://ij.org/firstamendment/2198
PHILLY CITY STUDY: http://ij.org/citystudies/philadelphia

ALL THINGS CONSIDERED ~ NPR: http://n.pr/gmz65n
MARKETPLACE ~ AMERICAN PUBLIC RADIO: http://bit.ly/hAXAhf
WALL STREET JOURNAL: http://on.wsj.com/f6RgSl

Tait v. City of Philadelphia

In 2008 the city of Philadelphia passed a law making it illegal to give a tour of the city without first passing a test and obtaining a special government license. The Institute for Justice filed a constitutional challenge to that law because the First Amendment protects your right to communicate for a living, and that's true whether you're a journalist or a stand up comedian or a tour guide.

In 2009, though, the city asked a federal district judge to dismiss that case without considering the constitutional argument because it said it didn't have the money allocated in its budget to start enforcing the law right then. The law was important and they intended to enforce it, they just hadn't allocated the money to enforce it immediately.

And that's why on Tuesday January 11, 2011, we'll be having an argument in the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia, making the simple point that the city's budget priorities cannot trump the Constitution. Government officials simply can't be allowed to hide in the bushes until they feel like jumping out and taking away your rights.

Philadelphia's tour guides have the right to speak freely without having to worry whether the city is going to start enforcing its licensing requirement in six weeks, six months or a year.

And that's why the Institute for Justice is determined to vindicate the First Amendment rights of ordinary Philadelphians to talk to each other about their city and its history. And to make clear to city officials, in court, that they do not have the power to fine people for unauthorized talking.

Institute for Justice Staff Attorney Robert McNamara
Donate to IJ: https://ij.org/support/give-now/
@IJvidsfollow
Thumbnail for Police Seized $39,500 From Him at the Airport, but Never Charged Him With a Crime3:32
Police Seized $39,500 From Him at the Airport, but Never Charged Him With a Crime
IJvids
868 views
Thumbnail for Inside Sharknado 2: Mockbusters, Remix Culture, and the Earnestness of Camp4:09
Inside Sharknado 2: Mockbusters, Remix Culture, and the Earnestness of Camp
ReasonVids
871 views
Thumbnail for "We Don't Need More Copyright" - Tom W. Bell on Intellectual Property8:29
"We Don't Need More Copyright" - Tom W. Bell on Intellectual Property
ReasonVids
826 views
Thumbnail for Rand Paul: Republicans Can Only Win if "They Become More Live and Let Live"12:27
Rand Paul: Republicans Can Only Win if "They Become More Live and Let Live"
ReasonVids
825 views
Thumbnail for Rawesome Foods Raided... Again!3:37
Rawesome Foods Raided... Again!
ReasonVids
939 views
Thumbnail for WE'RE BACK! | MegaMogwai5:53:14
WE'RE BACK! | MegaMogwai
invidious
83 views
Thumbnail for Mañanas en Libertad con Luis del Pino 06 02 2025 | Radio Libertad3:15:24
Mañanas en Libertad con Luis del Pino 06 02 2025 | Radio Libertad
invidious
55 views
Thumbnail for Can Snakes Die From Venom? 😮 | Zack D. Films0:26
Can Snakes Die From Venom? 😮 | Zack D. Films
invidious
79 views
Thumbnail for City Threatens Single Mom’s Day Care After Golfer Complaints4:35
City Threatens Single Mom’s Day Care After Golfer Complaints
IJvids
806 views
Thumbnail for 13 Coolest Gadgets That Are Worth Seeing | YouFact Tech10:39
13 Coolest Gadgets That Are Worth Seeing | YouFact Tech
invidious
268 views
Thumbnail for How Kilonovas Made the Earth and Killed Alternate Gravity - Ask a Spaceman! | Paul M. Sutter18:14
How Kilonovas Made the Earth and Killed Alternate Gravity - Ask a Spaceman! | Paul M. Sutter
invidious
360 views
Thumbnail for 🔴 Baby cartoons & Baby videos LIVE. Full episodes cartoon for kids with Hop Hop the Owl | Hop Hop the Owl1:00
🔴 Baby cartoons & Baby videos LIVE. Full episodes cartoon for kids with Hop Hop the Owl | Hop Hop the Owl
invidious
315 views
Thumbnail for AI Sells New Chevy For 1$8:30
AI Sells New Chevy For 1$
AOUisgay
601 views
Thumbnail for The Best and Worst Christmas Films (Libertarian Edition)3:33
The Best and Worst Christmas Films (Libertarian Edition)
ReasonVids
896 views
Thumbnail for Busting Congestion in Chicago (or Any other City)4:26
Busting Congestion in Chicago (or Any other City)
ReasonVids
823 views
Thumbnail for 3 Reasons We Need a Dirty Deal on Debt Ceiling1:33
3 Reasons We Need a Dirty Deal on Debt Ceiling
ReasonVids
795 views
Thumbnail for The Real Miyagi's Dojo Threatened: Santa Ana Favors Foliage over Small Businesses5:29
The Real Miyagi's Dojo Threatened: Santa Ana Favors Foliage over Small Businesses
ReasonVids
833 views
Thumbnail for Remy: Fake News1:58
Remy: Fake News
ReasonVids
890 views
Thumbnail for Are Social Cons Still Relevant in the GOP?2:41
Are Social Cons Still Relevant in the GOP?
ReasonVids
970 views
Thumbnail for Law for Non-Lawyers – Due Process and Equal Protection31:57
Law for Non-Lawyers – Due Process and Equal Protection
IJvids
1115 views
Thumbnail for UFC 305 - Dricus Du Plessis vs. Israel Adesanya original content3:12
UFC 305 - Dricus Du Plessis vs. Israel Adesanya original content
bestofupgoat
128 views
Thumbnail for dogs: charlies breakfast9:58
dogs: charlies breakfast
drspastic
934 views
Thumbnail for Reason Foundation Co-Founder Tibor Machan on Ayn Rand6:09
Reason Foundation Co-Founder Tibor Machan on Ayn Rand
ReasonVids
878 views

points

Permalink
Reply
institute for justice, first amendment, economic liberty, federal lawsuit, philadelphia, tour guides, robert, mcnamara, tait, illegal, occupational, licensing, test, government, liberty, freedom, constitution, challenge, communicate, judge, budget, argument, history, unauthorized, talking
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle