HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Bitcoin's Regulatory Nightmare Is About to Get More Frightening

Views:960
@ReasonVids

Let’s say you want to start a Bitcoin company in the U.S., chances are you’re going to need a Money Transmitter License, or rather 51 of them, because 47 states three territories and the District of Columbia each have their own permitting process for any business that handles money on behalf of its customers.

This regulatory maze is thwarting the plans of many Bitcoin startups.

"Some of our applications have been in for over a year, and we're not able to determine the path forward because it's not a clear process," says Megan Burton, CEO of the Bitcoin exchange firm CoinX, at a May 16, 2014 public hearing of the Conference of State Bank Supervisors' Emerging Payments Task Force.

Fred Ehrsam, cofounder of the Bitcoin Wallet firm Coinbase, said at a public event in New York City last month that becoming compliant in just half the states has so far taken his company "two years and cost $2 million."

But dealing with the states is just the beginning. Bitcoin firms also have to abide by the rules of the Federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the U.S. Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, which just sent a chill through the industry by fining the the cryptocurrency startup Ripple Labs $700,000 for allegedly violating its rules.

"It takes lawyers in each state, criminal background checks in each state, bonds in each state," says Jerry Brito, who's the executive director of Coin Center, an industry advocacy group. "It's a huge barrier to entry."

Instead of working to sort out this regulatory mess, government officials are piling on even more red tape. Benjamin Lawsky, New York State’s top financial regulator, has spent the last year hammering out the details of the so-called BitLicense, a new regulatory regime that will apply to virtual currency companies that serve customers in New York.

"Right now the regulation of the virtual currency industry is still akin to a virtual wild west," Lawsky said at a public hearing on the BitLicense that was held on January 29, 2014 in New York City.

Lawsky points to a slew of recent headlines about drug sales, alleged money laundering, and theft in the Bitcoin world. But these activities are already illegal under existing laws and regulations, and New York already requires that companies obtain a Money Transmitter License. The latest draft of the BitLicense doesn't say whether companies will be required to obtain both.

"It doesn't acheive any purpose to require two licenses," says Brito. "When you do the background check for one license, what's the point of doing a background check for another license?"

While the final details of the BitLicense won’t be released until later this month, the most recent draft duplicate federal regulations that already on the books. "It has an anti-money laundering provision, which is something that's unprecedented," says Brito. "Anti-money laundering is something...handled at by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network at the Treasury Department. So now if you are a business, not only do you have to file Suspicious Activity Reports and Know Your Customer forms for the federal government, but now you also have to do it for a state as well."

"We already have rules against fraud and hacking, so really what we're left with is something that's really onerous and burdensome not just for American companies but for companies all over the world," says Bruce Fenton, who's the executive director of the Bitcoin Foundation.

What the Bitcoin industry really needs is for regulators to simplify the rules and processes that are already on the books. Not only would that clear the path for small innovative startups that can’t afford a legal team, it would also leave consumers better protected because companies would be accountable to one agency.

"Ideally a small startup could go to one place, wherever that is, and follow clear and simple rules to get licensing," says Brito.

"We don't know when the next Facebook is going to come along started by a guy in his dorm," says Fenton. "What if he had to spend $4 million to start that? We never would have seen it. We may not even know what kind of innovations are around the corner if we stifle them before they have a chance to start."

3 minutes and 23 seconds.

Written and produced by Jim Epstein.

Go to http://reason.com/reasontv for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube Channel to receive automatic updates when new material goes live

bitcoin
,
cryptocurrency
,
bitlicense
,
money transmitter license
,
benjamin lawsky
,
coinx
,
fred ehrsam
,
megan burton
,
free minds
,
libertarian
,
libertarianism (political ideology)
,
reason (magazine)
,
reason foundation
,
reason tv
    Thumbnail for With Liberty and Drag For All! What We Saw at RuPaul’s First Ever DragCon4:13
    With Liberty and Drag For All! What We Saw at RuPaul’s First Ever DragCon
    ReasonVids
    980 views
    Thumbnail for Andrew Campanella on National School Choice Week 20130:57
    Andrew Campanella on National School Choice Week 2013
    ReasonVids
    850 views
    Thumbnail for The Truth About Dive Bombing During World War II | American Veterans Center0:52
    The Truth About Dive Bombing During World War II | American Veterans Center
    invidious
    110 views
    Thumbnail for David Icke - The Coronavirus Conspiracy: How Covid-19 Will Seize Your Rights & Destroy Our Economy2:34:36
    David Icke - The Coronavirus Conspiracy: How Covid-19 Will Seize Your Rights & Destroy Our Economy
    AOU
    2183 views
    Thumbnail for RFK had to delete a retweet from Roger Waters because he doesn’t support israel1:01
    RFK had to delete a retweet from Roger Waters because he doesn’t support israel
    bestofvoatxyz
    544 views
    Thumbnail for Throwback to the ebaums world days of niggerdom!2:03
    Throwback to the ebaums world days of niggerdom!
    bestofvoatxyz
    581 views
    Thumbnail for Check out Reason's New LA Headquarters!4:10
    Check out Reason's New LA Headquarters!
    ReasonVids
    965 views
    Thumbnail for Asian woman admits she wants to commit the white genocide0:51
    Asian woman admits she wants to commit the white genocide
    bestofvoatxyz
    756 views
    Thumbnail for "Truckers have joined in the protests in France as well, dumping their loads on their way to Paris. Paris has an estimated 3 days of food supplies left at this stage..."0:38
    "Truckers have joined in the protests in France as well, dumping their loads on their way to Paris. Paris has an estimated 3 days of food supplies left at this stage..."
    AOUisgay
    390 views
    Thumbnail for Helicopter Parents vs. Free Range Kids: Q&A with "America's Worst Mom" Lenore Skenazy4:33
    Helicopter Parents vs. Free Range Kids: Q&A with "America's Worst Mom" Lenore Skenazy
    ReasonVids
    1002 views
    Thumbnail for The World Health Organization's Tough Tactics Against Tobacco and E-Cigs8:38
    The World Health Organization's Tough Tactics Against Tobacco and E-Cigs
    ReasonVids
    942 views
    Thumbnail for THE KID IS A GENIUS 🤣 | The Wingrove Family0:05
    THE KID IS A GENIUS 🤣 | The Wingrove Family
    invidious
    299 views
    Thumbnail for LA Forces Condoms onto Porn Actors! (Nanny of the Month, Jan 2012)1:23
    LA Forces Condoms onto Porn Actors! (Nanny of the Month, Jan 2012)
    ReasonVids
    637 views
    Thumbnail for Intel Battlemage Graphics Card Shocks Everyone! | META PCs0:57
    Intel Battlemage Graphics Card Shocks Everyone! | META PCs
    invidious
    109 views
    Thumbnail for The healing power of antisemitism 0:34
    The healing power of antisemitism
    AmericanMuskrat
    86 views
    Thumbnail for The Gorilla Judge's Movie: The Sequel | SomePkmn-LovingDude5:31
    The Gorilla Judge's Movie: The Sequel | SomePkmn-LovingDude
    mattknezz
    368 views
    Thumbnail for J6: ANOTHER anti-White in uniform lying about what White people did.1:32
    J6: ANOTHER anti-White in uniform lying about what White people did.
    AOUisgay
    463 views
    Thumbnail for Richard Riordan on Unions and Dysfunctional LA (Extended Interview)40:42
    Richard Riordan on Unions and Dysfunctional LA (Extended Interview)
    ReasonVids
    931 views
    Thumbnail for France Now0:17
    France Now
    bestofvoatxyz
    625 views
    Thumbnail for Top 10 Republican Party Sex Scandals in the USA 20186:12
    Top 10 Republican Party Sex Scandals in the USA 2018
    WarmPotato
    1836 views
    Thumbnail for Tea Party Confidential: Live From the September 12 Taxpayer March on Washington6:08
    Tea Party Confidential: Live From the September 12 Taxpayer March on Washington
    ReasonVids
    1160 views
    Thumbnail for MST3k 815 - Agent for H.A.R.M. | analogkid011:31:07
    MST3k 815 - Agent for H.A.R.M. | analogkid01
    invidious
    330 views
    Thumbnail for Pokemon Radical Red, BUT IT'S A BATTLE TOWER! Pt.2 | shadypenguinn1:31:37
    Pokemon Radical Red, BUT IT'S A BATTLE TOWER! Pt.2 | shadypenguinn
    invidious
    98 views
    Thumbnail for Want to know the secret to the perfect steak? 🥩 | Andy Cooks0:50
    Want to know the secret to the perfect steak? 🥩 | Andy Cooks
    invidious
    31 views
    Thumbnail for CrossFit Founder Greg Glassman: "I'm a rabid libertarian"8:50
    CrossFit Founder Greg Glassman: "I'm a rabid libertarian"
    ReasonVids
    864 views

points

Permalink
Reply
bitcoin
,
cryptocurrency
,
bitlicense
,
money transmitter license
,
benjamin lawsky
,
coinx
,
fred ehrsam
,
megan burton
,
free minds
,
libertarian
,
libertarianism (political ideology)
,
reason (magazine)
,
reason foundation
,
reason tv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle