HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

IJ Takes on the Fight for Owner's "Right to Rent" in Wilmington, N.C.

Views: 857
David and Peg Schroeder are lifelong residents of Wilmington, North Carolina. They raised their family in Wilmington and were small business owners in the city. After retiring to the mountains, the Schroeders bought a townhome in Wilmington as a place to stay when they visit family and to maintain their ties with the community. To afford the townhome, they planned also to offer it as a vacation rental when they were not living there. But now the city of Wilmington is trying to ruin their retirement plan by taking their right to rent away from them.

https://ij.org/case/north-carolina-amortization/

The Schroeders made substantial investments to renovate their townhome to make it suitable as a vacation rental—all based on the correct belief that it would be perfectly legal for them to do so. After several months and about $75,000 in renovation costs, the Schroeders had the property ready to rent. That is when the City changed the rules on them—passing a zoning ordinance that created a hard cap on how many properties were allowed to engage in vacation rentals. And under the cap, any property that fell within 400 feet of another vacation rental would be prohibited from operating as a vacation rental. Finally, to decide which property owners would retain their right to offer vacation rentals, the city devised a randomized lottery process. The result was an arbitrary, zero-sum process that pitted neighbor against neighbor in a raffle for property rights. And because the Schroeders’ neighbor drew a winning ticket, the Schroeders lost.

Using an oppressive and little-known process called “amortization,” Wilmington gave properties that did not win the lottery one year to continue operating. At the end of that time, people like the Schroeders would have to quit renting. That is because, as the theory of amortization goes, the Schroeders would be able to use that one-year period to recoup their investment in their property. And according to the city, this absolves the city of having to pay the Schroeders “just compensation” for their taking of the Schroeders’ property rights. In other words, Wilmington believes that it can take the Schroeders’ property and not pay for it because the Schroeders had time to cover their own losses.

But if the city wants to take the Schroeders’ property rights, it has to pay for them. What Wilmington cannot do is turn peoples’ property rights into lottery tickets and raffle them off. Nor can it create a small group of people allowed to exercise rental rights at the expense of everyone else. The North Carolina Constitution protects the Schroeders’ right to rent and it prohibits the city from granting exclusive privileges and creating rental monopolies that prohibit everyone else from renting. Now the Schroeders are fighting back, determined not to lose the property right they invested so much to acquire. That is why they have teamed up with the Institute for Justice to challenge Wilmington’s unconstitutional zoning and amortization scheme.

https://ij.org/case/north-carolina-amortization/
Donate to IJ: https://ij.org/support/give-now/
@IJvidsfollow
Thumbnail for IJ on the Individual Mandate2:25
IJ on the Individual Mandate
IJvids
951 views
Thumbnail for Dinesh D’Souza - obvious the election was manipulated by an organized political effort to use fraudulently obtained ballots to stuff remote ballot collection boxes in those key precincts.3:25
Dinesh D’Souza - obvious the election was manipulated by an organized political effort to use fraudulently obtained ballots to stuff remote ballot collection boxes in those key precincts.
bestofpoal
816 views
Thumbnail for Five Things You Need to Know About the Texas Supreme Court Ruling Protecting Economic Liberty2:50
Five Things You Need to Know About the Texas Supreme Court Ruling Protecting Economic Liberty
IJvids
851 views
Thumbnail for Free to Design: Florida Entrepreneurs Take On the Interior Design Cartel3:27
Free to Design: Florida Entrepreneurs Take On the Interior Design Cartel
IJvids
857 views
Thumbnail for Woke Psycho Thinks Meat is Racist and Sexist | Grunt Speak Shorts14:19
Woke Psycho Thinks Meat is Racist and Sexist | Grunt Speak Shorts
Terrence Popp
705 views
Thumbnail for What Happened to the Antiwar Movement?7:10
What Happened to the Antiwar Movement?
ReasonVids
857 views
Thumbnail for Be With You - Mondays feat. Lucy [Aphmau Official] | Aphmau3:34
Be With You - Mondays feat. Lucy [Aphmau Official] | Aphmau
kids.topic
19 views
Thumbnail for Silicon Valley Is Helping Expunge Marijuana Convictions4:31
Silicon Valley Is Helping Expunge Marijuana Convictions
ReasonVids
976 views
Thumbnail for Vote Bear0:56
Vote Bear
ReasonVids
836 views
Thumbnail for Ursus vs Homo Africanus0:14
Ursus vs Homo Africanus
bestofupgoat
28 views
Thumbnail for Should the Supreme Court Allow Us to "Go to Hell"?17:19
Should the Supreme Court Allow Us to "Go to Hell"?
ReasonVids
643 views
Thumbnail for Black Farmers Market original content1:48
Black Farmers Market original content
bestofupgoat
137 views
Thumbnail for Taco Truck Takedown: Why is the LAPD hassling food carts?2:34
Taco Truck Takedown: Why is the LAPD hassling food carts?
ReasonVids
887 views
Thumbnail for John B. Taylor "How Government Interventions Caused the Financial Crisis."6:28
John B. Taylor "How Government Interventions Caused the Financial Crisis."
ReasonVids
955 views
Thumbnail for never has a candidate elicited so much fear1:30
never has a candidate elicited so much fear
bestofupgoat
358 views
Thumbnail for We're the TSA and You Can Count on Us! (to overreact to tiny threats and ignore big ones)1:04
We're the TSA and You Can Count on Us! (to overreact to tiny threats and ignore big ones)
ReasonVids
926 views
Thumbnail for How Payday Lenders & Check Cashers Help the Poor13:11
How Payday Lenders & Check Cashers Help the Poor
ReasonVids
817 views
Thumbnail for Sen. Ted Cruz on Obama & Drug Policy: "No man is above the law, especially not the president."2:07
Sen. Ted Cruz on Obama & Drug Policy: "No man is above the law, especially not the president."
ReasonVids
946 views
Thumbnail for Honor Flight Doc Remembers World War II Heroes6:46
Honor Flight Doc Remembers World War II Heroes
ReasonVids
985 views
Thumbnail for Lockdowns For Thee, Not For Me! - #NewWorldNextWeek19:57
Lockdowns For Thee, Not For Me! - #NewWorldNextWeek
corbettreport_uo
1792 views
Thumbnail for Moaning Myrtles - Prefects are Hot with lyrics - Nina Janckowicz2:32
Moaning Myrtles - Prefects are Hot with lyrics - Nina Janckowicz
bestofvoatxyz
711 views
Thumbnail for Rep. Tom McClintock on the Contradictions of Green Policy9:06
Rep. Tom McClintock on the Contradictions of Green Policy
ReasonVids
874 views

points

Permalink
Reply
ij, institute for justice, freedom, liberty, individual rights, constitution, constitutional law, unconstitutional law, con law, constitutional litigation
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle