HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

New York Cops Took $8,040 From Her. She Was Never Charged With a Crime.

Views:864
@IJvids

Cristal Starling runs a mobile food cart in Rochester, New York, to provide for herself and her grandnephew. She dreamed of expanding the business into a food truck, and she saved enough money to do just that. But in the fall of 2020, the local police raided her apartment and seized $8,040—the money she was going to use to pursue her dream.

https://ij.org/case/new-york-forfeiture-appeal/

Police accused Cristal’s then-boyfriend of dealing drugs, but he was acquitted by a jury. Yet Cristal’s nightmare continued. The police turned Cristal’s savings over to the U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA), which sought to keep her money through an abusive practice called civil forfeiture, and federal prosecutors pressed forward with the civil forfeiture case even after the not-guilty verdict. Civil forfeiture laws take the presumption of innocence and turn it upside down, forcing property owners like Cristal to prove their own innocence.

Cristal fought to get her money back. She did everything she knew—making phone calls, following instructions she received, and filing a claim with the DEA. It made no economic sense to hire a lawyer to recover $8,040, so Cristal tried to fight without one. She successfully navigated the administrative process at the DEA, but when prosecutors filed a forfeiture action in federal court she missed the deadline to file one required piece of paper. That was enough for the government to take her money forever.

The government never even tried to show that Cristal had done anything wrong, but it was able to take her money by tying her up in complicated legal procedures. And, unfortunately, that is typical in civil forfeiture cases. The average value of forfeiture cases is small, meaning it doesn’t make sense for most people to hire a lawyer even if they could afford one, and most civil forfeiture cases end with a missed deadline rather than a decision on the merits. Property owners are forced to run a procedural gauntlet, and they lose by default if they make just a single mistake.

Cristal has teamed up with the Institute for Justice (IJ) to appeal the district court’s decision to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. In a non-forfeiture case, the court would have let Cristal continue her case notwithstanding a single missed deadline. Forfeiture should be no different. Cristal showed up in court to fight, she tried to fight, and she should have been allowed to make her case.
Donate to IJ: https://ij.org/support/give-now/

ij
,
institute for justice
,
freedom
,
liberty
,
individual rights
,
constitution
,
constitutional law
,
unconstitutional law
,
con law
,
constitutional litigation
    Thumbnail for New York County Tries To Destroy a 100-Year-Old Neighborhood4:54
    New York County Tries To Destroy a 100-Year-Old Neighborhood
    IJvids
    891 views
    Thumbnail for Public Defense Lawyer in Seattle1:15
    Public Defense Lawyer in Seattle
    bestofupgoat
    86 views
    Thumbnail for Explosively hydroforming a steel sphere0:18
    Explosively hydroforming a steel sphere
    bestofvoatxyz
    1742 views
    Thumbnail for Lord of the Ruqqus: Return of the Freeze Peach King24:55
    Lord of the Ruqqus: Return of the Freeze Peach King
    moviegoats
    427 views
    Thumbnail for Mathematician: Election numbers don’t add up2:42
    Mathematician: Election numbers don’t add up
    bestofpoal
    1892 views
    Thumbnail for 'Climate Change Is Real, But It's Not the End of the World:' Michael Shellenberger1:03:09
    'Climate Change Is Real, But It's Not the End of the World:' Michael Shellenberger
    ReasonVids
    801 views
    Thumbnail for 戰甲車棚裝滿光電板? 學者憂淪活靶 昔用愛發電.今用坦克發電?《庶民大頭家》完整版 20240122 #廖偉翔 #李德維 #費鴻泰 #蔡壁如 #單厚之@chinatvnews | 中視新聞48:51
    戰甲車棚裝滿光電板? 學者憂淪活靶 昔用愛發電.今用坦克發電?《庶民大頭家》完整版 20240122 #廖偉翔 #李德維 #費鴻泰 #蔡壁如 #單厚之@chinatvnews | 中視新聞
    invidious
    314 views
    Thumbnail for THE CHEMICALS IN THE WATER TURN THE FREAKING DINOSAURS GAY0:35
    THE CHEMICALS IN THE WATER TURN THE FREAKING DINOSAURS GAY
    bestofvoatxyz
    537 views
    Thumbnail for Ron Paul and the GOP Convention4:10
    Ron Paul and the GOP Convention
    ReasonVids
    813 views
    Thumbnail for An influencer factory in Indonesia0:49
    An influencer factory in Indonesia
    bestofupgoat
    487 views
    Thumbnail for How Did Water Solve the 1800-Year-Old Talmudic Bankruptcy Problem? | Mathologer39:58
    How Did Water Solve the 1800-Year-Old Talmudic Bankruptcy Problem? | Mathologer
    invidious
    111 views
    Thumbnail for You're Gay?  Keep That Shit To Yourself!0:32
    You're Gay? Keep That Shit To Yourself!
    bestofupgoat
    106 views
    Thumbnail for Ideas, The turrets copper top. | Escape to rural France8:03
    Ideas, The turrets copper top. | Escape to rural France
    invidious
    38 views
    Thumbnail for Justin Amash Left the GOP—Opening a New Set of Possibilities in American Politics3:42
    Justin Amash Left the GOP—Opening a New Set of Possibilities in American Politics
    ReasonVids
    1117 views
    Thumbnail for I don't understand how you can't just look at this and know it won't work...0:31
    I don't understand how you can't just look at this and know it won't work...
    AOUisgay
    471 views
    Thumbnail for Game with a ceiling fan and a water bottle0:42
    Game with a ceiling fan and a water bottle
    bestofpoal
    831 views
    Thumbnail for Katie Couric Responds to Deceptive Editing Charges in Gun Documentary0:31
    Katie Couric Responds to Deceptive Editing Charges in Gun Documentary
    ReasonVids
    862 views
    Thumbnail for The hidden meaning behind Twitter's new "X" logo 0:14
    The hidden meaning behind Twitter's new "X" logo
    bestofvoatxyz
    482 views
    Thumbnail for "You are dismissed!" - How to trigger ZOG bots2:14
    "You are dismissed!" - How to trigger ZOG bots
    AOUisgay
    487 views
    Thumbnail for Based, based, BASED! Love my black Queen! 😍4:47
    Based, based, BASED! Love my black Queen! 😍
    bestofupgoat
    239 views
    Thumbnail for Chitãozinho e Xororó (José & Durval) - A Gente Grita [Vídeo Oficial] | Chitãozinho & Xororó2:44
    Chitãozinho e Xororó (José & Durval) - A Gente Grita [Vídeo Oficial] | Chitãozinho & Xororó
    invidious
    192 views
    Thumbnail for „Тешки Муабети“ vs „Политиканти“, епизода 139, петта сезона - 21.03.2025 | Инфомакс2:43:47
    „Тешки Муабети“ vs „Политиканти“, епизода 139, петта сезона - 21.03.2025 | Инфомакс
    invidious
    124 views
    Thumbnail for Shocking scenes, a packed beachside remembrance for The 𝙐𝙣𝙛𝙤𝙧𝙩𝙪𝙣𝙖𝙩𝙚 𝘾𝙤𝙞𝙣𝙘𝙞𝙙𝙚𝙣𝙘𝙚𝙨....1:53
    Shocking scenes, a packed beachside remembrance for The 𝙐𝙣𝙛𝙤𝙧𝙩𝙪𝙣𝙖𝙩𝙚 𝘾𝙤𝙞𝙣𝙘𝙞𝙙𝙚𝙣𝙘𝙚𝙨....
    AOUisgay
    522 views
    Thumbnail for The Fall of 76 | Internet Historian26:22
    The Fall of 76 | Internet Historian
    invidious
    494 views
    Thumbnail for Lynching Charlie Lynch, Medical Marijuana Martyr: Q&A with Filmmaker Rick Ray7:17
    Lynching Charlie Lynch, Medical Marijuana Martyr: Q&A with Filmmaker Rick Ray
    ReasonVids
    880 views

points

Permalink
Reply
ij
,
institute for justice
,
freedom
,
liberty
,
individual rights
,
constitution
,
constitutional law
,
unconstitutional law
,
con law
,
constitutional litigation
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle