HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

3 Questions for SCOTUS Nominee Neil Gorsuch

Views: 824
The Senate Judiciary Committee is holding hearings this week on the nomination of Judge Neil Gorsuch to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Gorsuch is a federal judge with admirers across the political spectrum. But his views on several crucial constitutional issues remain unclear. Here are three questions I'd like to hear Judge Gorsuch address this week before the Senate Judiciary Committee.



Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv

Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a


  1. Congressional Power

The Supreme Court has upheld the power of the federal government to prosecute cannabis users in California under Congress's authority to regulate interstate commerce. Yet the medical marijuana that was the focus of that 2005 ruling was both grown and consumed only in California.

I'd like to hear Judge Gorsuch explain his views on the limits of federal power. Does Congress have the authority to ban a local activity that's legal under state law?

  1. Executive Power

The federal courts are currently hearing arguments about the constitutionality of President Trump's ban on travelers from a handful of majority-Muslim countries. According to the Trump administration, the federal courts have no business second-guessing the president's authority on an issue that affects national security.

I'd like to know if Judge Gorsuch agrees that the president's executive orders are beyond the reach of judicial review. How deferential must the federal courts be to the commander in chief?

  1. Unenumerated Rights

The Constitution lists a number of individual rights, such as free speech and the right to keep and bear arms. But it also refers to rights that aren't explicitly mentioned.

For example, the Supreme Court has protected the right to privacy, the right of parents to send their children to private schools, and the right to gay marriage. None of these rights are mentioned anywhere in the text of the Constitution.

In his 2006 book, Judge Gorsuch was critical of reading the Constitution in this way. He wrote that the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment has been "stretched beyond recognition" in the name of defending unwritten rights.

I'd like to know if Judge Gorsuch thinks the same is true of the 9th Amendment and the Privileges or Immunities Clause, both of which refer to unwritten rights. Does he believe the Constitution protects any rights that aren't explicitly mentioned?

The American people deserve to hear what Judge Gorsuch has to say about these fundamental constitutional issues. Given all the unanswered questions about his jurisprudence, he should fully explain himself at this week's confirmation hearings.

Camera by Jim Epstein. Graphics and editing by Joshua Swain.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Journalist Barrett Brown on Prison, Leakers, and Private Intelligence Agencies18:53
Journalist Barrett Brown on Prison, Leakers, and Private Intelligence Agencies
ReasonVids
899 views
Thumbnail for West Hollywood Reacts to SCOTUS Gay Marriage Decision2:40
West Hollywood Reacts to SCOTUS Gay Marriage Decision
ReasonVids
891 views
Thumbnail for Can Businesses Actually Do Some Social Good?: William Eggers on The Solution Revolution9:58
Can Businesses Actually Do Some Social Good?: William Eggers on The Solution Revolution
ReasonVids
948 views
Thumbnail for How the IRS has been seizing $ from innocent Americans1:55
How the IRS has been seizing $ from innocent Americans
IJvids
914 views
Thumbnail for Is the Vice Presidency an Irrelevant Position?7:38
Is the Vice Presidency an Irrelevant Position?
ReasonVids
871 views
Thumbnail for Individual Mandate is Unconstitutional and a Threat to Liberty says Ilya Somin9:38
Individual Mandate is Unconstitutional and a Threat to Liberty says Ilya Somin
ReasonVids
913 views
Thumbnail for Poker Champion Annie Duke on Making Smart Bets in Life, Politics, and Football18:56
Poker Champion Annie Duke on Making Smart Bets in Life, Politics, and Football
ReasonVids
932 views
Thumbnail for The Truth About Florida's Interior Design Deregulation2:38
The Truth About Florida's Interior Design Deregulation
IJvids
883 views
Thumbnail for Alex 810:54
Alex 8
MerkinMuffly
444 views
Thumbnail for VA Recap: U.S. Vet on Cause, Solution, and Scale of Scandal6:43
VA Recap: U.S. Vet on Cause, Solution, and Scale of Scandal
ReasonVids
865 views
Thumbnail for Why the Lights Are Still Off in Puerto Rico4:51
Why the Lights Are Still Off in Puerto Rico
ReasonVids
823 views
Thumbnail for How to Track COVID-19 Without Mass Surveillance9:31
How to Track COVID-19 Without Mass Surveillance
ReasonVids
974 views
Thumbnail for When a decade feels like an office0:04
When a decade feels like an office
bestofvoatxyz
785 views
Thumbnail for Obamacare, Gov't Insurance Exchanges, & The Coming Price Explosion4:30
Obamacare, Gov't Insurance Exchanges, & The Coming Price Explosion
ReasonVids
960 views
Thumbnail for How Washington Learned to Love Video Games5:34
How Washington Learned to Love Video Games
ReasonVids
999 views
Thumbnail for LA Is Spending Over $1 Billion to House the Homeless. It’s Failing.9:31
LA Is Spending Over $1 Billion to House the Homeless. It’s Failing.
ReasonVids
861 views
Thumbnail for what IT really looks like0:05
what IT really looks like
bestofupgoat
373 views
Thumbnail for worthless1:07
worthless
bestofupgoat
76 views
Thumbnail for Libertarian Party Candidate Gary Johnson on Voting Libertarian For One Election5:38
Libertarian Party Candidate Gary Johnson on Voting Libertarian For One Election
ReasonVids
813 views
Thumbnail for Greg Lukianoff: How Colleges Fight Free Speech4:09
Greg Lukianoff: How Colleges Fight Free Speech
ReasonVids
859 views
Thumbnail for Trump's Cuba Crackdown: It's Time to End the Ridiculous Embargo3:45
Trump's Cuba Crackdown: It's Time to End the Ridiculous Embargo
ReasonVids
877 views
Thumbnail for Some orphaned wild Monkey videos melt even my bitter cold heart. SOOOOO CUTE!0:39
Some orphaned wild Monkey videos melt even my bitter cold heart. SOOOOO CUTE!
poalcatbox
643 views
Thumbnail for Obama's Recovery That Wasn't; Plus: How to Really Cut Defense Spending!3:31
Obama's Recovery That Wasn't; Plus: How to Really Cut Defense Spending!
ReasonVids
837 views
Thumbnail for Jo Jorgensen: Don't Waste Your Vote on Trump or Biden4:05
Jo Jorgensen: Don't Waste Your Vote on Trump or Biden
ReasonVids
878 views
Thumbnail for GPT4ALL: EASIEST Local Install and Fine-tunning of "ChatGPT" like MODEL | Prompt Engineering20:19
GPT4ALL: EASIEST Local Install and Fine-tunning of "ChatGPT" like MODEL | Prompt Engineering
tech.topic
582 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian, reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv, judge neil gorsuch, scotus, supreme court, trump
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle