HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

In Defense of Payday Lending

Views: 897
Few industries are more reviled than payday lending, which primarily services the working poor by offering short-term loans at high interest rates. Payday customers borrow an average of $350 for a period of two weeks, or until their next paycheck comes in. The money is handed over on the spot, once the payday store can verify that the customer has a job, earns enough to afford the loan, and hasn't recently defaulted with another vendor. Payday loans are in high demand: There are 22,000 payday storefronts in the United States and in 2009 they loaned a combined $35 billion.

And yet the industry is fighting for its survival. Montana just voted to make it illegal for the payday-loan industry to operate profitably, so lenders are loading their wagons and wheeling out of "The Land of the Shining Mountains." They've already moved on from Oregon, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Arizona, Georgia, and Washington, D.C, because of similar regulations. The annualized interest on payday loans runs about 400 percent, but the reality is that payday firms see returns closer to 10 percent, or about the same as other less-demonized financial service providers.

Now there's a danger the federal government will quash the rest of the U.S. payday industry. The Frank-Dodd Financial Reform bill, passed in July, created the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), which posseses the power to regulate paydays at the national level for the first time. The vaguely written law doesn't allow the CFPB to cap interest rates, but regulators have the latitude to enact other rules that would obliterate profits, such as limiting the number of payday loans a customer can take out over a set period of time.

Payday critics, such as the Center for Financial Responsible Lending (which declined our interview request) argue that payday stores "trap" their customers and practice what "amounts to legal loan sharking."

Reason.tv's Nick Gillespie looks at payday loans—why people depend on them, why they're expensive, and the assumption at the core of every attack on the industry: that the working-poor are too stupid to manage their own money.

The story features payday antagonist Gary Rivlin, the author of the recent book Broke USA; George Mason law professor Todd Zywicki, who has studied paydays; and Greg Fay and Saran Goubeaux of Hometown Cash Finance, a small chain of payday stores in Ohio.

Two studies are citied in this story: the Federal Reserve's 2007 look at the effect of booting paydays out of George and Virginia, and the 2007 Vanderbilt-Oxford University study that reveals that, contrary to the claims of industry critics, paydays aren't exceptionally profitable.

For more info, read Katherine Mangu-Ward's October 2009 feature story on payday lending in Reason Magazine, and her Wall Street Journal review of Rivlin's Broke USA.

For complete links on this story go to:
http://reason.tv/video/show/payday-loans

Approximately 5 minutes.

Produced by Jim Epstein, with help from Dan Hayes, Josh Swain, and Michael Moynihan.

Go to http://www.reason.tv for HD, iPod, and audio versions of this and all our videos, and subscribe to Reason.tv's YouTube channel to receive automatic notification when new content is posted.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Are We Really Less Free Today? Sheldon Richman on the State of Liberty6:37
Are We Really Less Free Today? Sheldon Richman on the State of Liberty
ReasonVids
907 views
Thumbnail for 3 Reasons We Shouldn't Bail Out Student Loan Borrowers3:33
3 Reasons We Shouldn't Bail Out Student Loan Borrowers
ReasonVids
937 views
Thumbnail for Porker of the Month January 20111:33
Porker of the Month January 2011
ReasonVids
893 views
Thumbnail for "The Skeptical Environmentalist": A Conversation with John Tierney and Bjorn Lomborg27:03
"The Skeptical Environmentalist": A Conversation with John Tierney and Bjorn Lomborg
ReasonVids
849 views
Thumbnail for Media Manipulation and Unconventional Marketing: Author Ryan Holiday on "Trust Me I'm Lying"7:52
Media Manipulation and Unconventional Marketing: Author Ryan Holiday on "Trust Me I'm Lying"
ReasonVids
807 views
Thumbnail for Ex Cop: Everyone Behaves Better When They're on Video5:43
Ex Cop: Everyone Behaves Better When They're on Video
ReasonVids
955 views
Thumbnail for Sports Stadiums Are Bad Public Investments. So Why Are Cities Still Paying for Them?4:53
Sports Stadiums Are Bad Public Investments. So Why Are Cities Still Paying for Them?
ReasonVids
1010 views
Thumbnail for Kurt Loder on Film: The Good, the Bad, & the Godawful4:21
Kurt Loder on Film: The Good, the Bad, & the Godawful
ReasonVids
976 views
Thumbnail for Why Americans Are Suckers for Quick Fixes From Psychologists5:01
Why Americans Are Suckers for Quick Fixes From Psychologists
ReasonVids
883 views
Thumbnail for Questioning WW2 History and book burnings0:56
Questioning WW2 History and book burnings
bestofupgoat
98 views
Thumbnail for Cheating Ex Gets Karma Kancer After Destroying Marriage | Grunt Speak25:42
Cheating Ex Gets Karma Kancer After Destroying Marriage | Grunt Speak
Terrence Popp
601 views
Thumbnail for White bishop takes black pawn0:04
White bishop takes black pawn
bestofupgoat
406 views
Thumbnail for Ranking EVERY Death Row Meal: Clarence Ray Allen | Josh Slavin1:00
Ranking EVERY Death Row Meal: Clarence Ray Allen | Josh Slavin
invidious
92 views
Thumbnail for Deputies Bust Gays with Unconstitutional Sodomy Law: Don't Cops Have Better Things to Do?!2:07
Deputies Bust Gays with Unconstitutional Sodomy Law: Don't Cops Have Better Things to Do?!
ReasonVids
835 views
Thumbnail for Democratic Debate: The Remy Rap1:30
Democratic Debate: The Remy Rap
ReasonVids
912 views
Thumbnail for Remy: $20 Trillion Reasons (Lady Gaga Million Reasons Parody)2:20
Remy: $20 Trillion Reasons (Lady Gaga Million Reasons Parody)
ReasonVids
876 views
Thumbnail for Randy Barnett: Secret NSA Snooping is "a Fundamental Challenge" to Democracy9:46
Randy Barnett: Secret NSA Snooping is "a Fundamental Challenge" to Democracy
ReasonVids
898 views
Thumbnail for Yes, they are niggers. I can't fcking stand niggers. Whores discussing how they hate Elon Musk trying to buy Twatter.0:42
Yes, they are niggers. I can't fcking stand niggers. Whores discussing how they hate Elon Musk trying to buy Twatter.
bestofpoal
1359 views
Thumbnail for John J. Miller on "The First Assassin": History, Poltics, & The Future of Publishing8:03
John J. Miller on "The First Assassin": History, Poltics, & The Future of Publishing
ReasonVids
853 views
Thumbnail for Hollywood meets Wall Street: Author William Stadiem talks Moneywood6:14
Hollywood meets Wall Street: Author William Stadiem talks Moneywood
ReasonVids
841 views
Thumbnail for Enjoying the little things. Hummingbirds found my feeder original content1:09
Enjoying the little things. Hummingbirds found my feeder original content
bestofupgoat
458 views
Thumbnail for More Money Doesn't Make Better Schools - Q&A with E3's Derrell Bradford1:03
More Money Doesn't Make Better Schools - Q&A with E3's Derrell Bradford
ReasonVids
745 views
Thumbnail for Gene Epstein: Murray Rothbard's Mixed Legacy6:03
Gene Epstein: Murray Rothbard's Mixed Legacy
ReasonVids
666 views
Thumbnail for Steven Pinker: Rationality Saves Lives56:42
Steven Pinker: Rationality Saves Lives
ReasonVids
722 views

points

Permalink
Reply
payday lending, payday industry, advance america, libertarian, libertarianism, gary rivlin, broke usa, todd zywicki, nick gillespie, reason.tv, reason magazine, reason foundation, financial reform
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle