HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Has the U.S. Constitution Lost Its Meaning? A Debate

Views: 807
Should the U.S. Constitution be interpreted and applied according to the original meaning of its text?

On June 11, 2018, two leading constitutional legal scholars, Georgetown's Randy Barnett and Cornell's Michael Dorf, debated "originalism," which seeks to protect against arbitrary and personal interpretations by jurists, while making the law stable, predictable, and consistent in its application.


Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv

Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.


The debate was hosted by Reason and the Soho Forum, which runs Oxford-style debates, in which the audience votes on the resolution at the beginning and end of the event, and the side that gains more ground is victorious. The resolution was: "The U.S. Constitution should be interpreted and applied according to the original meaning communicated to the public by the words of the text."

Dorf won the debate by changing the minds of 20 percent of the attendees.

Barnett, arguing for the affirmative, is the Carmack Waterhouse Professor of Legal Theory at the Georgetown University Law Center and the director of the Georgetown Center for the Constitution. His books include Our Republican Constitution: Securing the Liberty and Sovereignty of We the People and Restoring the Lost Constitution: The Presumption of Liberty. After taking a J.D. from Harvard Law School, he worked as a prosecutor in Chicago. Barnett is a Senior Fellow of the Cato Institute and the Goldwater Institute.

Dorf, for the negative, is the Robert S. Stevens Professor of Law at Cornell University Law School. He is the editor, author, or co-author of six books, including On Reading the Constitution, with co-author Laurence Tribe. Since 2000, Dorf has written a bi-weekly column, currently appearing on Justia's Verdict. He also posts less formal legal analysis several times per week on his blog, Dorf on Law. After taking a JD from Harvard Law School, he served as a law clerk for Judge Stephen Reinhardt of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit and then for Justice Anthony Kennedy of the Supreme Court of the United States.

The event opened with a standup routine from comedian Dave Smith.

The Soho Forum is held every month at the SubCulture Theater in Manhattan's East Village. The next debate, which is sold out, features Erik Voorhees and Peter Schiff on bitcoin and crypotcurrency. On August 27, William Easterly and Joseph Stiglitz will discuss whether free markets or government action is the best way to eliminate global poverty. You can buy tickets to that debate here.

You can catch all Soho Forum debates by subscribing to the Reason Podcast and our YouTube Channel.

Produced by Todd Krainin.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Remy: Violent Video Games (The Rap)1:57
Remy: Violent Video Games (The Rap)
ReasonVids
849 views
Thumbnail for Cancer Patients' Constitutional Challenge to the Allow Compensation for Marrow Donation2:39
Cancer Patients' Constitutional Challenge to the Allow Compensation for Marrow Donation
IJvids
895 views
Thumbnail for Will the Ohio Healthcare Freedom Amendment Sink Obamacare?5:20
Will the Ohio Healthcare Freedom Amendment Sink Obamacare?
ReasonVids
792 views
Thumbnail for How a Great School is Breaking the Cycle of Poverty in America's Poorest City5:37
How a Great School is Breaking the Cycle of Poverty in America's Poorest City
ReasonVids
970 views
Thumbnail for Cuban Health Care Is a Disaster22:12
Cuban Health Care Is a Disaster
ReasonVids
866 views
Thumbnail for How Government is Destroying the Medical Profession: Q&A with Dr. Jeffrey Singer6:11
How Government is Destroying the Medical Profession: Q&A with Dr. Jeffrey Singer
ReasonVids
852 views
Thumbnail for Cory Doctorow on The War on Kids, Boing Boing, & His Next Novel5:26
Cory Doctorow on The War on Kids, Boing Boing, & His Next Novel
ReasonVids
847 views
Thumbnail for Obama’s 2015 SOTU: Magical Pain-Free Prosperity For Everyone!1:33
Obama’s 2015 SOTU: Magical Pain-Free Prosperity For Everyone!
ReasonVids
886 views
Thumbnail for Алексей Венедиктов** и Сергей Бунтман / Будем наблюдать // 02.12.23 | Живой Гвоздь1:58:16
Алексей Венедиктов** и Сергей Бунтман / Будем наблюдать // 02.12.23 | Живой Гвоздь
invidious
456 views
Thumbnail for Stem Cell Harvesting From Abortions | The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters17:38
Stem Cell Harvesting From Abortions | The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters
invidious
352 views
Thumbnail for What We Saw at the People's Climate March3:18
What We Saw at the People's Climate March
ReasonVids
869 views
Thumbnail for Too Big To Regulate: Barron's Gene Epstein on Dodd-Frank25:35
Too Big To Regulate: Barron's Gene Epstein on Dodd-Frank
ReasonVids
863 views
Thumbnail for Police Have Immunity to Violate Your Rights - Here's How26:07
Police Have Immunity to Violate Your Rights - Here's How
IJvids
910 views
Thumbnail for FDA: Milk is not Milk1:42
FDA: Milk is not Milk
IJvids
832 views
Thumbnail for Unify original content2:38
Unify original content
bestofupgoat
302 views
Thumbnail for 3 Reasons Not to Go to War with Syria2:14
3 Reasons Not to Go to War with Syria
ReasonVids
842 views
Thumbnail for Mitch Daniels on How to Cut Government & Improve Services30:51
Mitch Daniels on How to Cut Government & Improve Services
ReasonVids
865 views
Thumbnail for How Glamour Shapes Our Lives: Q&A with Former Reason Editor Virginia Postrel1:02:05
How Glamour Shapes Our Lives: Q&A with Former Reason Editor Virginia Postrel
ReasonVids
719 views
Thumbnail for [신장식의 뉴스하이킥🔴] '혁신위는 김기현체제 시간끌기용' 이 말이 발단? - 헬마우스&김은지, 용혜인&천호선, 양지열&이상민, 강아솔 | MBC 라디오 시사2:11:11
[신장식의 뉴스하이킥🔴] '혁신위는 김기현체제 시간끌기용' 이 말이 발단? - 헬마우스&김은지, 용혜인&천호선, 양지열&이상민, 강아솔 | MBC 라디오 시사
invidious
302 views
Thumbnail for I dig it1:16
I dig it
AOUisgay
528 views
Thumbnail for Licensing Gone Wild:  Armed Government Agents Raiding Barber Shops1:30
Licensing Gone Wild: Armed Government Agents Raiding Barber Shops
IJvids
855 views
Thumbnail for America Would Be Better Off If Bitcoin Became the World’s Reserve Currency1:03:14
America Would Be Better Off If Bitcoin Became the World’s Reserve Currency
ReasonVids
802 views
Thumbnail for Obamacare Launch Eroding Faith in Government as Problem Solver: Reason-Rupe Poll December 20134:34
Obamacare Launch Eroding Faith in Government as Problem Solver: Reason-Rupe Poll December 2013
ReasonVids
915 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian, reason magazine, reason.com, reason.tv, reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle