HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Who is Publius? or, Who's Afraid of Anonymous Political Speech?

Views:950
@ReasonVids

To hear the Obama administration tell it, there are few things worse than anonymous political activity. Just recently, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius told the Christian Science Monitor:

"The untold story of 2010 is not the "tea party" or not the health-care bill, or a number of these issues. It is the amount of money that is flowing in districts around the country and particularly the amount of anonymous money....

I haven't been any place where there aren't dozens of ads now being run and nobody knows who is behind them...I am used to a political system where people engage in battles and you know who brought them to the dance."

But is anonymous political speech really that new - or that bad?

Indeed, anonymous political speech isn't just a great American tradition. It helped create the United States of America. The Federalist Papers, the series of essays that influenced the adoption of the Constitution, were published under the pseudonym "Publius" (in reality James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and John Jay). The anti-Constitution position was in turn articulated by "the Federal Farmer," whose identity remains a mystery.

Former Federal Election Commission chair Bradley Smith lays out other arguments in favor of anonymous political speech in a contemporary context:

"Election disclosure regulations are some of the most burdensome. Disclosure limits free speech because it allows the government to retaliate against people. The Supreme Court has consistently held that people do have a right to anonymous speech. The cases speak for themselves.

The most prominent one is probably NAACP v. Alabama (1964), when Alabama wanted to know who was funding the NAACP's activities. We can see how that would be intimidating. Then there's McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission (1995). McIntyre was doing anonymous brochures against a school tax, which all the school officials supported. She had children in the schools who needed grades and access to such things as athletic teams and bands. She didn't necessarily want her name known, even though it was important for her to fight this issue. Another major case was Brown v. Socialist Workers '74 Campaign Committee (1982). The socialists rightly said, "If we have to reveal our donors, they won't give us money. They will get harassed. Their businesses will get blackballed and that sort of thing." Disclosure can be more inhibiting than people think."

Which is something to think about when people already in power push legislation such as The DISCLOSE Act, which would force groups to list donors and reveal their names in advertisements. The DISCLOSE Act is in part a response to this year's controversial Citizen's United v. Federal Election Commission ruling by the Supreme Court. Hyperbolically likened by critics to the infamous Dred Scott decision, Citizen's United dealt with a documentary film censored by the government and broadened the speech rights of corporations, unions, and nonprofits. Far from opening American politics up to undue influence by unspecificed foreigners (as President Obama has charged), the ruling makes it easier for smaller groups and individuals to spread their messages.

As with many political firestorms, the current one about "dangerous" anonymous speech generates more heat than insight. Anonymous speech is fully in the American grain but it also comes at a price. When the source of political speech is not known or disclosed, voters tend to discount it, or at least look for corroboration elsewhere. Which is exactly how it should be. And if you don't in the end trust voters to make informed decisions, then all the mandatory disclosure in the world can't help them.

"Who is Publius?" is written and produced by Meredith Bragg and Nick Gillespie. Approximately 45 seconds.

For downloadable versions of all our videos, go to http://reason.tv. To receive automatic notification when new material goes live, subscribe to Reason.tv's YouTube Channel.

reason
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reason magazine
,
reason foundation
,
nick gillespie
,
federalist papers
,
james madison
,
alexander hamilton
,
john jay
,
anonymous
,
kathleen sebelius
,
sebelius
,
citizen's united
,
supreme court
,
dred scott
,
barack obama
,
disclosure
,
fec
    Thumbnail for Liberty for Africa: Q&A with Adedayo Thomas4:54
    Liberty for Africa: Q&A with Adedayo Thomas
    ReasonVids
    826 views
    Thumbnail for Activists with Just Stop Oil, an organization infamous for its obnoxious tactics, had their own event ruined by counterprotestors armed with balloon-borne rape alarms. LMAO1:08
    Activists with Just Stop Oil, an organization infamous for its obnoxious tactics, had their own event ruined by counterprotestors armed with balloon-borne rape alarms. LMAO
    bestofvoatxyz
    552 views
    Thumbnail for Wait, Trump warned us about a rocky economic transition period? Let's check the tape #dailyshow | The Daily Show0:52
    Wait, Trump warned us about a rocky economic transition period? Let's check the tape #dailyshow | The Daily Show
    invidious
    55 views
    Thumbnail for Minecraft is getting a graphics change. | Phoenix SC2:46
    Minecraft is getting a graphics change. | Phoenix SC
    invidious
    387 views
    Thumbnail for Stunning Style In This Woman’s Single Level Tiny Home 🌟 | Living Big In A Tiny House18:03
    Stunning Style In This Woman’s Single Level Tiny Home 🌟 | Living Big In A Tiny House
    invidious
    186 views
    Thumbnail for Hanukkah officially canceled0:07
    Hanukkah officially canceled
    AOUisgay
    439 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Silk Road Founder Jailed, Drug Sales Up5:40
    Stossel: Silk Road Founder Jailed, Drug Sales Up
    ReasonVids
    803 views
    Thumbnail for George Hotz: Fully Self-Driving Cars Are a 'Scam' and Silicon Valley 'Needs To Die'22:55
    George Hotz: Fully Self-Driving Cars Are a 'Scam' and Silicon Valley 'Needs To Die'
    ReasonVids
    981 views
    Thumbnail for IJ's Scott Bullock discusses the Forfeiting Justice report3:33
    IJ's Scott Bullock discusses the Forfeiting Justice report
    IJvids
    896 views
    Thumbnail for 'Long Strange Trip' Film Shows the Grateful Dead's Anti-Authoritarian Streak4:37
    'Long Strange Trip' Film Shows the Grateful Dead's Anti-Authoritarian Streak
    ReasonVids
    955 views
    Thumbnail for Christmas Starbucks Coffee Shop Music🎄Best Christmas Jazz Playlist 2024🎄Happy Christmas for Relax | Cozy Starbucks Cafe1:00
    Christmas Starbucks Coffee Shop Music🎄Best Christmas Jazz Playlist 2024🎄Happy Christmas for Relax | Cozy Starbucks Cafe
    invidious
    344 views
    Thumbnail for French Motorcycles0:07
    French Motorcycles
    bestofvoatxyz
    568 views
    Thumbnail for Ed Sheeran, Kygo, Avicii, Robin Schulz, Lost Frequencies, The Chainsmokers Styles - Feeling Me1:00
    Ed Sheeran, Kygo, Avicii, Robin Schulz, Lost Frequencies, The Chainsmokers Styles - Feeling Me
    invidious
    307 views
    Thumbnail for Hikaru Plays 5D Chess For The First Time | GMHikaru36:11
    Hikaru Plays 5D Chess For The First Time | GMHikaru
    invidious
    482 views
    Thumbnail for Halo CE - Big Team Battle Slayer - Sidewinder (XBOX ONE) | Mystical Gaming10:38
    Halo CE - Big Team Battle Slayer - Sidewinder (XBOX ONE) | Mystical Gaming
    invidious
    216 views
    Thumbnail for Fall Beans10:00
    Fall Beans
    stumble_bro
    456 views
    Thumbnail for Quiet Majority - John Cleese on #Extremism 1987 - restored audio & video #FarRight #project2025 | Quiet Majority2:12
    Quiet Majority - John Cleese on #Extremism 1987 - restored audio & video #FarRight #project2025 | Quiet Majority
    science.topic
    88 views
    Thumbnail for The Cruel Fate of Kekistan16:10
    The Cruel Fate of Kekistan
    murdochmurdoch
    1543 views
    Thumbnail for We Know How to Make America Strong8:50
    We Know How to Make America Strong
    AmericanRenaissance
    1727 views
    Thumbnail for Former MTV VJ Kennedy on Her Libertarian Evolution28:22
    Former MTV VJ Kennedy on Her Libertarian Evolution
    ReasonVids
    1085 views
    Thumbnail for Remy: Courtesy of the Red, White & Blue (Toby Keith Civil Liberties Parody)2:42
    Remy: Courtesy of the Red, White & Blue (Toby Keith Civil Liberties Parody)
    ReasonVids
    851 views
    Thumbnail for This is Your Brain on Acid (Seriously)15:21
    This is Your Brain on Acid (Seriously)
    ReasonVids
    917 views
    Thumbnail for $456,000 Squid Game In Real Life! | MrBeast25:42
    $456,000 Squid Game In Real Life! | MrBeast
    invidious
    398 views
    Thumbnail for Young White boy has nigger fatigue0:25
    Young White boy has nigger fatigue
    bestofvoatxyz
    863 views
    Thumbnail for Jewopoly (fun vid about jews good for normies)16:25
    Jewopoly (fun vid about jews good for normies)
    bestofupgoat
    129 views

points

Permalink
Reply
reason
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reason magazine
,
reason foundation
,
nick gillespie
,
federalist papers
,
james madison
,
alexander hamilton
,
john jay
,
anonymous
,
kathleen sebelius
,
sebelius
,
citizen's united
,
supreme court
,
dred scott
,
barack obama
,
disclosure
,
fec
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle