HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Abortion Rights vs. Women's Safety in Virginia

Views: 795
Last April, the Virginia Board of Health approved strict new regulations for abortion providers. Unlike most similar laws, the regulations cover not just new facilities but existing ones too. Clinics have until October 2014 to comply, but a high-stakes legal challenge in the Old Dominion may change that early next year.

Senate Bill 924 reclassifies any health clinic that provides five or more first trimester abortions a month as an outpatient surgical center rather than a physician's office, which is the current classification. The law sets standards for the number of parking spaces, width of hallways, size of janitor closets, and more, all which could cost millions of dollars in renovations per facility. Abortion clinics throughout the state have said compliance costs will force many of them to close and two out of 20 abortion clinics have already shut down, citing financial burdens related to the new regs.

In a reversal of conventional positions, SB 924 has political conservatives arguing for increasing regulations on small businesses and liberals arguing against them. The bill initially passed the Democratic-controlled state senate in 2011 by a vote of 20-20 (Lieutenant Gov. Bill Bolling, a pro-life Republican cast the tie-breaking vote). Republican Gov. Bob McDonnell eventually signed it into law after numerous rounds of political back-and-forth.

Supporters of abortion rights believe that pro-life legislators in Virginia and elsewhere around the country are using retroactive regulations to get around constitutional guarantees to abortion on demand during the first trimester of pregnancy. Defenders of the new regulations say that they are simply protecting the safety of women.

"This is really necessary to ensure that woman are treated with care consistent with their human dignity," says Mallory Quigley of the Susan B. Anthony List (SBL), a pro-life organization. A woman who chooses to have an abortion, says Quigley, should be able to do so without fearing for her health and safety. Quigley and other supporters point to the deplorable conditions in abortion clinics such as the one run by Kermit Gosnell in Philadelphia. Gosnell, who ran an operation described as a "horror house," was convicted of murder and other crimes after several patients died at his clinic.

"Physicians that are practicing in Virginia have been outspoken about the lack of medical evidence that is deciding this legislation," says Sara Wallace-Keeshen of Falls Church Health Care Center (FCHC). Located in northern Virginia, FCHC has filed an administrative appeal against the new regulations, claiming that renovations would cost the center $2 million and potentially force them out of business.

FCHC center has had no deaths since opening in 2002, an outcome that is similar to the generally low rate of complications related to abortions performed in clinics. Indeed, since 1974 state data show only three deaths during legal abortions. For first-trimester abortions, the complication rate is 0.3 percent, throwing doubt on the safety argument.

A court date is set for April 2014.

Aprrox. 4 minutes. Produced by Amanda Winkler. Camera by Winkler and Joshua Swain.


Visit http://reason.com/reasontv/2013/12/16/abortion-clinics-targeted-under-new-virg for full text, links, and downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube Channel to receive automatic updates when new material goes live.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Caretaker of Disabled Child Humiliated in Botched Sex Sting: Don't Cops Have Better Things to Do?!2:18
Caretaker of Disabled Child Humiliated in Botched Sex Sting: Don't Cops Have Better Things to Do?!
ReasonVids
836 views
Thumbnail for Will the Supreme Court Limit Police Power to “Stop and Frisk”?39:03
Will the Supreme Court Limit Police Power to “Stop and Frisk”?
IJvids
971 views
Thumbnail for Black Open Carry: Why Gun Rights and Civil Rights Need Each Other7:07
Black Open Carry: Why Gun Rights and Civil Rights Need Each Other
ReasonVids
816 views
Thumbnail for Ex president Poroshenko shows up just in time for the CNN broadcast to show he's willing to fight for Ukraine...But then this unfortunate thing happens on camera0:28
Ex president Poroshenko shows up just in time for the CNN broadcast to show he's willing to fight for Ukraine...But then this unfortunate thing happens on camera
AOU
923 views
Thumbnail for Joe Biden’s Endless River of Debt and Regulation3:37
Joe Biden’s Endless River of Debt and Regulation
ReasonVids
908 views
Thumbnail for COULD THE SECRETS WITHIN SACRED GEOMETRY UNLOCK THE ULTIMATE FREE ENERGY SOURCE?45:44
COULD THE SECRETS WITHIN SACRED GEOMETRY UNLOCK THE ULTIMATE FREE ENERGY SOURCE?
bestofvoatxyz
814 views
Thumbnail for Who's a clever boy?1:00
Who's a clever boy?
bestofvoatxyz
761 views
Thumbnail for Oh Come On!0:21
Oh Come On!
bestofvoatxyz
1364 views
Thumbnail for Grace VanderWaal, Sofie Dossi, And The Most Talented Kids! Wow! - America’s Got Talent | America's Got Talent13:43
Grace VanderWaal, Sofie Dossi, And The Most Talented Kids! Wow! - America’s Got Talent | America's Got Talent
agt.topic
680 views
Thumbnail for How Will Mad Men End? Or Why Don Draper MUST Die (or at least fade away)5:00
How Will Mad Men End? Or Why Don Draper MUST Die (or at least fade away)
ReasonVids
845 views
Thumbnail for Will The Libertarian Party Seize Its Moment?0:42
Will The Libertarian Party Seize Its Moment?
ReasonVids
804 views
Thumbnail for I Built a TRICKY Mini Golf Track to Challenge The Dev! | Kosmonaut19:38
I Built a TRICKY Mini Golf Track to Challenge The Dev! | Kosmonaut
invidious
259 views
Thumbnail for Banning Soda, Lessons from Wisconsin, & Obama the Pot Smoker7:37
Banning Soda, Lessons from Wisconsin, & Obama the Pot Smoker
ReasonVids
932 views
Thumbnail for It's Time to Legalize Hemp! Q&A with CEO of Dr. Bronner's Magic Soaps2:59
It's Time to Legalize Hemp! Q&A with CEO of Dr. Bronner's Magic Soaps
ReasonVids
927 views
Thumbnail for Matt Welch: Why I Wrote McCain: The Myth of a Maverick2:35
Matt Welch: Why I Wrote McCain: The Myth of a Maverick
ReasonVids
861 views
Thumbnail for Reason's Katherine Mangu-Ward on the Future of the Magazine48:11
Reason's Katherine Mangu-Ward on the Future of the Magazine
ReasonVids
872 views
Thumbnail for Trying not to sexualize Annie for 5 minutes straight | Schokollama5:48
Trying not to sexualize Annie for 5 minutes straight | Schokollama
invidious
540 views
Thumbnail for The Worst YouTube Mansion Tours | WolfeWatch25:03
The Worst YouTube Mansion Tours | WolfeWatch
invidious
417 views
Thumbnail for Buy American Pot: A Special Message From the AMGA, Dedicated to Keeping Pot Illegal & Profits High!1:14
Buy American Pot: A Special Message From the AMGA, Dedicated to Keeping Pot Illegal & Profits High!
ReasonVids
845 views
Thumbnail for Pranking a Gardener in 1896 - Restored Footage0:26
Pranking a Gardener in 1896 - Restored Footage
AOUisgay
435 views
Thumbnail for What We Saw at the Stewart-Colbert Rally to Restore Sanity5:54
What We Saw at the Stewart-Colbert Rally to Restore Sanity
ReasonVids
836 views
Thumbnail for The goyim mustn't know!0:49
The goyim mustn't know!
AOU
1132 views
Thumbnail for How Medical Pot Is Helping Seniors Get Off (Prescription) Drugs5:48
How Medical Pot Is Helping Seniors Get Off (Prescription) Drugs
ReasonVids
821 views
Thumbnail for Is California Over?3:07
Is California Over?
ReasonVids
870 views

points

Permalink
Reply
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle