HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

The Deeply Flawed Studies Behind the Eviction Moratoriums

Views:1012
@ReasonVids

The government and media relied on studies plagued by shoddy statistics to make the case for blocking evictions during the COVID-19 pandemic.

For full text, links, and more, go to: https://reason.com/video/2021/07/01/the-deeply-flawed-studies-behind-the-eviction-moratoriums/
------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV?subconfirmation=1
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------
On September 4, 2020, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) halted residential evictions in the United States for nonpayment of rent due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Many states and municipalities got there first, imposing at least partial eviction moratoriums starting in March and April of 2020. The theory behind these emergency orders was that if Americans were forced to leave their homes and move into more crowded settings, it would increase transmission of COVID-19.

The federal ban was supposed to expire at the end of 2020. Then it was extended a month, then two more months, then through the end of June, and then last week, the CDC extended it again until the end of July. Many states and cities have also extended their moratoriums—in some cases through the end of September, even as COVID-19 infection and death rates are plummeting.

Were the eviction bans necessary to protect public health during the pandemic? Two studies that got widespread media attention, and that have been cited by the federal government to support its policies, claim to show that the moratoriums saved thousands of lives.

"Researchers estimated that the lifting of moratoriums could have resulted in between 365,200 and 502,200 excess coronavirus cases and between 8,900 and 12,500 excess deaths," noted NPR, in an interview with postdoctoral researcher Kathryn Leifheit of UCLA's Fielding School of Public Health.

Leifheit was the lead author of "Expiring Eviction Moratoriums and COVID-19 Incidence and Mortality," a study cited by the CDC in its order extending the federal moratorium. (Leifheit didn't respond to Reason's interview request.)

The second study, which also makes dramatic claims about the eviction moratoriums, was authored by a team of researchers at Duke University. It got widespread media attention and was cited twice by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) in the federal register as justification for its rulemaking.

These studies are deeply flawed. Their underlying data are incomplete and inconsistent. Their results are implausible. The size of the effect is wildly disproportionate to other public health interventions. The researchers also claim an absurd amount of certainty in their results despite the large uncertainties in the data they use, and they assert a causal effect based solely on correlation.

If the authors were correct, they would have arrived at one of the greatest public health discoveries in history. It took over a year and perhaps $100 billion to reduce COVID-19 rates by 40 percent with vaccinations; the Duke researchers claim that if a universal eviction moratorium had been implemented six months earlier, it could have reduced death rates by over 40 percent. Researchers have struggled to demonstrate the benefits of masks, social distancing, and lockdowns with high levels of certainty. Yet these eviction moratorium researchers find high confidence for a gigantic immediate effect from a legal change affecting a tiny subset of the population.

Finally, the authors of the Duke study declined to share their dataset with Reason for scrutiny on the grounds that it hasn't yet been published in a peer-reviewed journal, which not only raises additional red flags but is a violation of basic research ethics—particularly in the case of a study that's been widely reported on in the media and is cited by a government agency as justification for federal policies.

Produced and edited by Justin Monticello. Written by Monticello and Aaron Brown. Graphics by Isaac Reese. Audio production by Ian Keyser.

Music: Aerial Cliff by Michele Nobler, Land of the Lion by C.K. Martin, The Plan's Working by Cooper Cannell, Thoughts by ANBR, Flight of the Inner Bird by Sivan Talmor and Yehezkel Raz, and Run by Tristan Barton.

Photos: Marilyn Humphries/Newscom; John Rudoff/Sipa USA/Newscom; Erik McGregor/Sipa USA/Newscom; Marilyn Humphries/Newscom; John Rudoff/Sipa USA/Newscom; Erik McGregor/Sipa USA/Newscom; Erik McGregor/Sipa USA/Newscom; Erik McGregor/Sipa USA/Newscom

Eviction protest footage: Liberation News/YouTube

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
aaron brown
,
justin monticello
,
housing policy
,
coronavirus
,
covid-19
,
public health
,
real estate
,
cdc
,
affordable housing
,
evictions
,
eviction moratorium
    Thumbnail for Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 4)2:47
    Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 4)
    ReasonVids
    910 views
    Thumbnail for I love these. Another airport classical duet0:59
    I love these. Another airport classical duet
    bestofvoatxyz
    560 views
    Thumbnail for Home is where the heart is0:59
    Home is where the heart is
    bestofupgoat
    218 views
    Thumbnail for stuck screw0:10
    stuck screw
    bestofupgoat
    239 views
    Thumbnail for The Arc de Triomphe in Paris - Show this to anyone who thinks faggots are oppressed0:12
    The Arc de Triomphe in Paris - Show this to anyone who thinks faggots are oppressed
    AOUisgay
    556 views
    Thumbnail for Zeitgeist - The Movie (2007)18:13
    Zeitgeist - The Movie (2007)
    bestofsaidit
    764 views
    Thumbnail for How To INTERACT with Game Objects using UNITY EVENTS Tutorial | BMo10:43
    How To INTERACT with Game Objects using UNITY EVENTS Tutorial | BMo
    tech.topic
    681 views
    Thumbnail for What We Saw at the 2011 Seattle Hempfest3:02
    What We Saw at the 2011 Seattle Hempfest
    ReasonVids
    976 views
    Thumbnail for Pollinating 0:23
    Pollinating
    bestofupgoat
    125 views
    Thumbnail for Atlas Shrugged Part II Trailer! Release Date October 12, 20122:15
    Atlas Shrugged Part II Trailer! Release Date October 12, 2012
    ReasonVids
    931 views
    Thumbnail for Charlie Sykes: 'Something broken in Trump' prevents him from understanding sacrifice | MSNBC0:59
    Charlie Sykes: 'Something broken in Trump' prevents him from understanding sacrifice | MSNBC
    invidious
    213 views
    Thumbnail for Why new dressers suck at storing stuff | MatthiasWandel5:42
    Why new dressers suck at storing stuff | MatthiasWandel
    invidious
    168 views
    Thumbnail for (((HandsomeTruth / GDL / ADL))) and his (((BitChute))) accounts.1:00
    (((HandsomeTruth / GDL / ADL))) and his (((BitChute))) accounts.
    bestofupgoat
    101 views
    Thumbnail for Just another day on voat0:09
    Just another day on voat
    bestofvoatxyz
    607 views
    Thumbnail for Upgoat user fends of Poal admin with sticks.0:12
    Upgoat user fends of Poal admin with sticks.
    bestofupgoat
    234 views
    Thumbnail for UK's new PM pushes Universal Basic Income: free money or slavery?8:32
    UK's new PM pushes Universal Basic Income: free money or slavery?
    bestofsaidit
    828 views
    Thumbnail for Alex Jones & Brother Nathanael debate the jewish conspiracy57:11
    Alex Jones & Brother Nathanael debate the jewish conspiracy
    AOUisgay
    464 views
    Thumbnail for How Cultural Innovation Happens: Q&A with Anthropologist Grant McCracken7:47
    How Cultural Innovation Happens: Q&A with Anthropologist Grant McCracken
    ReasonVids
    1050 views
    Thumbnail for Homeschool your kids.0:41
    Homeschool your kids.
    bestofupgoat
    538 views
    Thumbnail for Sheboon Mad At Car for Driving on Road!0:24
    Sheboon Mad At Car for Driving on Road!
    bestofupgoat
    277 views
    Thumbnail for Crocodile ventured into the wrong neighbourhood 0:30
    Crocodile ventured into the wrong neighbourhood
    bestofupgoat
    471 views
    Thumbnail for Why Geezers Are the True Enemy of Occupy Wall Street3:40
    Why Geezers Are the True Enemy of Occupy Wall Street
    ReasonVids
    893 views
    Thumbnail for Pajeet – Radiohead cover4:24
    Pajeet – Radiohead cover
    bestofupgoat
    171 views
    Thumbnail for Veronique de Rugy Tells the Truth about Taxes & Entitlements4:12
    Veronique de Rugy Tells the Truth about Taxes & Entitlements
    ReasonVids
    847 views
    Thumbnail for My first map that I'm truly happy with | Smiley | Trackmania 2020 | Bastiro0:45
    My first map that I'm truly happy with | Smiley | Trackmania 2020 | Bastiro
    invidious
    472 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
aaron brown
,
justin monticello
,
housing policy
,
coronavirus
,
covid-19
,
public health
,
real estate
,
cdc
,
affordable housing
,
evictions
,
eviction moratorium
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle