HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Stossel: Junk Science Locks Up Innocent People

Views:898
@ReasonVids

DNA testing reveals that long-used forensic methods are error-riddled.

---------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
---------

TV shows like CSI, Law & Order, and NCIS depict incredible technology for identifying criminals.

In one NCIS scene, a 3D hologram identifies a person's teeth, precisely matching the killer's bite to a bite mark on a victim. "A little 3D magic for clarity and I give you—the killer's incisors!" NCIS character "Abby" announces proudly.

John Stossel loves crazy Abby, but notes that in the real world, court-approved experts reach similar conclusions—without good science to back them up.

Alfred Swinton was convicted of murder after "bite mark expert" Dr. Gus Karazulas said Swinton's teeth matched a bite on a victim.

Karazulas told the TV show Cold Case Files: "We look at the evidence and we make sure that if we are going to make a decision it's gonna be a truthful decision."

But a decade later, DNA testing showed it was not Swinton's DNA on the bite mark. He was released after 18 years in prison.

To his credit, Karazulas now admits he was wrong. "Bite mark evidence is junk science," he tells us by email. He testified to that in court and resigned as a member of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences.

The verdict was wrong because bite mark analysis has never been scientifically proven, says Chris Fabricant of the Innocence Project, which represented Swinton.

Fabricant tells Stossel that bite mark analysis "is similar to you and I looking at a cloud, and then I say, 'John, doesn't that cloud look like a rabbit to you?' And you look at it and say, 'yeah, Chris, I think that does look like a rabbit.'"

Many experts agree. "Bite mark analysis is a subjective method," reads a 2016 report by the President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology, which notes that even the most positive studies on it find an error rate of 1-in-6.

NYPD detective Harry Houck tells Stossel that he agrees bite mark analysis has problems, but that it can be used as one piece in a puzzle to convict people.

Other methods have flaws, too. Even fingerprint analysis sometimes goes wrong, as do carpet fiber evidence, gun tracing, and hair matching.

Stossel asks Fabricant: "Why do judges admit this stuff? Why don't defense attorneys get it thrown out?" Fabricant answers: "We all went to law school because we don't know science, we don't know math. And if somebody comes in in a white lab coat...that's good enough for government work."

That shouldn't be the standard, says Stossel. Jurors and judges should be much more skeptical of "scientific" evidence.



The views expressed in this video are solely those of John Stossel, his independent production company, Stossel Productions, and the people he interviews. The claims and opinions set forth in the video and accompanying text are not necessarily those of Reason.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for Resolved: The Government Should Cut Off All Funding to Colleges and Universities1:32:37
    Resolved: The Government Should Cut Off All Funding to Colleges and Universities
    ReasonVids
    894 views
    Thumbnail for If We Do Nothing: The Folly of Women in Combat11:41
    If We Do Nothing: The Folly of Women in Combat
    AmericanRenaissance
    870 views
    Thumbnail for The Evil That Men Do14:02
    The Evil That Men Do
    AmericanRenaissance
    1895 views
    Thumbnail for 🇯🇵Small but tasty #sushi | Chef Hiro (シェフヒロ)0:25
    🇯🇵Small but tasty #sushi | Chef Hiro (シェフヒロ)
    invidious
    141 views
    Thumbnail for Should the Federal Government Assume a Larger Role in Managing the Economy? A Soho Forum Debate1:38:12
    Should the Federal Government Assume a Larger Role in Managing the Economy? A Soho Forum Debate
    ReasonVids
    809 views
    Thumbnail for  Smooth Nigger0:39
    Smooth Nigger
    AOU
    1592 views
    Thumbnail for CNN Interviews Jared Taylor on White Identity48:27
    CNN Interviews Jared Taylor on White Identity
    AmericanRenaissance
    1909 views
    Thumbnail for What are Geometry Nodes? | Blender4:25
    What are Geometry Nodes? | Blender
    invidious
    396 views
    Thumbnail for (((they))) are more evil than the average person could even comprehend0:41
    (((they))) are more evil than the average person could even comprehend
    bestofupgoat
    141 views
    Thumbnail for Rosetta Stoned - Tool cover (Video) | Sakis Strigas11:19
    Rosetta Stoned - Tool cover (Video) | Sakis Strigas
    invidious
    59 views
    Thumbnail for Happy New Year!5:14
    Happy New Year!
    AmericanRenaissance
    1623 views
    Thumbnail for Brutal Doom Deathmatch Fun | Eandrave11:36
    Brutal Doom Deathmatch Fun | Eandrave
    invidious
    318 views
    Thumbnail for Why Would I Give You These Things? | SomePkmn-LovingDude3:10
    Why Would I Give You These Things? | SomePkmn-LovingDude
    invidious
    303 views
    Thumbnail for Birmingham Airport Live ✈️ WET RUNWAY ACTION 21.04.2025 | Airport Action4:10:18
    Birmingham Airport Live ✈️ WET RUNWAY ACTION 21.04.2025 | Airport Action
    invidious
    112 views
    Thumbnail for Gypsy "refugee" caught with magicians gown by angry British shop owner1:23
    Gypsy "refugee" caught with magicians gown by angry British shop owner
    AOUisgay
    563 views
    Thumbnail for Cheating Ex Gets Karma Kancer After Destroying Marriage | Grunt Speak25:42
    Cheating Ex Gets Karma Kancer After Destroying Marriage | Grunt Speak
    Terrence Popp
    661 views
    Thumbnail for Don't Be Afraid of Those 6,000 Felons Just Released From Prison - FAMM's Kevin Ring10:55
    Don't Be Afraid of Those 6,000 Felons Just Released From Prison - FAMM's Kevin Ring
    ReasonVids
    952 views
    Thumbnail for Pure Bloods Microwaved6:44
    Pure Bloods Microwaved
    bestofvoatxyz
    751 views
    Thumbnail for Niggers and smoke detectors0:09
    Niggers and smoke detectors
    AOUisgay
    677 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: NYC Government Traumatizes Gun Owners5:46
    Stossel: NYC Government Traumatizes Gun Owners
    ReasonVids
    955 views
    Thumbnail for Math Creating Strawberries | Thomas Mulligan0:51
    Math Creating Strawberries | Thomas Mulligan
    invidious
    173 views
    Thumbnail for Disturbing Video Shows Walgreens Pharmacist Refusing To Fill Man's Ivermectin Prescription3:49
    Disturbing Video Shows Walgreens Pharmacist Refusing To Fill Man's Ivermectin Prescription
    AOU
    2888 views
    Thumbnail for Are ‘Pandemic Pods’ a Symptom of the Public School Monopoly? A Soho Forum Debate1:33:27
    Are ‘Pandemic Pods’ a Symptom of the Public School Monopoly? A Soho Forum Debate
    ReasonVids
    811 views
    Thumbnail for PANIC! Dem rep is apoplectic after seeing the video of fraud - Her reaction1:40
    PANIC! Dem rep is apoplectic after seeing the video of fraud - Her reaction
    AOU
    1433 views
    Thumbnail for This is what racism really looks like0:33
    This is what racism really looks like
    AOU
    1347 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle