HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Stossel: Junk Science Locks Up Innocent People

Views:817
@ReasonVids

DNA testing reveals that long-used forensic methods are error-riddled.

---------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
---------

TV shows like CSI, Law & Order, and NCIS depict incredible technology for identifying criminals.

In one NCIS scene, a 3D hologram identifies a person's teeth, precisely matching the killer's bite to a bite mark on a victim. "A little 3D magic for clarity and I give you—the killer's incisors!" NCIS character "Abby" announces proudly.

John Stossel loves crazy Abby, but notes that in the real world, court-approved experts reach similar conclusions—without good science to back them up.

Alfred Swinton was convicted of murder after "bite mark expert" Dr. Gus Karazulas said Swinton's teeth matched a bite on a victim.

Karazulas told the TV show Cold Case Files: "We look at the evidence and we make sure that if we are going to make a decision it's gonna be a truthful decision."

But a decade later, DNA testing showed it was not Swinton's DNA on the bite mark. He was released after 18 years in prison.

To his credit, Karazulas now admits he was wrong. "Bite mark evidence is junk science," he tells us by email. He testified to that in court and resigned as a member of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences.

The verdict was wrong because bite mark analysis has never been scientifically proven, says Chris Fabricant of the Innocence Project, which represented Swinton.

Fabricant tells Stossel that bite mark analysis "is similar to you and I looking at a cloud, and then I say, 'John, doesn't that cloud look like a rabbit to you?' And you look at it and say, 'yeah, Chris, I think that does look like a rabbit.'"

Many experts agree. "Bite mark analysis is a subjective method," reads a 2016 report by the President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology, which notes that even the most positive studies on it find an error rate of 1-in-6.

NYPD detective Harry Houck tells Stossel that he agrees bite mark analysis has problems, but that it can be used as one piece in a puzzle to convict people.

Other methods have flaws, too. Even fingerprint analysis sometimes goes wrong, as do carpet fiber evidence, gun tracing, and hair matching.

Stossel asks Fabricant: "Why do judges admit this stuff? Why don't defense attorneys get it thrown out?" Fabricant answers: "We all went to law school because we don't know science, we don't know math. And if somebody comes in in a white lab coat...that's good enough for government work."

That shouldn't be the standard, says Stossel. Jurors and judges should be much more skeptical of "scientific" evidence.



The views expressed in this video are solely those of John Stossel, his independent production company, Stossel Productions, and the people he interviews. The claims and opinions set forth in the video and accompanying text are not necessarily those of Reason.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for Resolved: The Government Should Cut Off All Funding to Colleges and Universities1:32:37
    Resolved: The Government Should Cut Off All Funding to Colleges and Universities
    ReasonVids
    853 views
    Thumbnail for Dennis Hof on Why He Started "Pimpin' for Paul"1:28
    Dennis Hof on Why He Started "Pimpin' for Paul"
    ReasonVids
    870 views
    Thumbnail for The Longest Forced Checkmate I've Ever Seen! | Chess Vibes8:10
    The Longest Forced Checkmate I've Ever Seen! | Chess Vibes
    invidious
    398 views
    Thumbnail for How High Would You Make the Minimum Wage? We Asked L.A. Residents.6:52
    How High Would You Make the Minimum Wage? We Asked L.A. Residents.
    ReasonVids
    898 views
    Thumbnail for 2020 Presidential Candidate Blowout! | ReasonTV2:52
    2020 Presidential Candidate Blowout! | ReasonTV
    invidious
    154 views
    Thumbnail for Killer Chic: Hollywood's Sick Love Affair with Che Guevara (Chinese translation)8:35
    Killer Chic: Hollywood's Sick Love Affair with Che Guevara (Chinese translation)
    ReasonVids
    940 views
    Thumbnail for Ferguson Grand Jury Decides - Police Press Conference (Parody)2:21
    Ferguson Grand Jury Decides - Police Press Conference (Parody)
    ReasonVids
    946 views
    Thumbnail for The Dark Trump Rises0:46
    The Dark Trump Rises
    ReasonVids
    867 views
    Thumbnail for Unbelievable boots on the ground footage, Ukraine March 2022 What is going on here? Lez Luthor clips15:22
    Unbelievable boots on the ground footage, Ukraine March 2022 What is going on here? Lez Luthor clips
    AOU
    1084 views
    Thumbnail for  Dr. Simone Gold - The truth about the CV-19 Vaccine56:08
    Dr. Simone Gold - The truth about the CV-19 Vaccine
    AOU
    1119 views
    Thumbnail for The Terrifying World of Giant Insects: What Was Earth Like During the Carboniferous Period? | Destiny34:49
    The Terrifying World of Giant Insects: What Was Earth Like During the Carboniferous Period? | Destiny
    invidious
    97 views
    Thumbnail for $0.99 Coffee from McDonalds | Save Money with McDonalds App | Jenny Hoyos0:17
    $0.99 Coffee from McDonalds | Save Money with McDonalds App | Jenny Hoyos
    invidious
    277 views
    Thumbnail for We're on the wrong side.  I fully support Russia nuking ukraine and israel.0:43
    We're on the wrong side. I fully support Russia nuking ukraine and israel.
    bestofupgoat
    83 views
    Thumbnail for Sandy Springs, Georgia: The City that Outsourced Everything7:53
    Sandy Springs, Georgia: The City that Outsourced Everything
    ReasonVids
    789 views
    Thumbnail for Gillie goes off on a US Marshall for questioning him about allegedly smelling like marijuana while boarding a flight from Dallas, Texas on American Airlines.0:45
    Gillie goes off on a US Marshall for questioning him about allegedly smelling like marijuana while boarding a flight from Dallas, Texas on American Airlines.
    publicfreakouts
    570 views
    Thumbnail for How did you clean up the eraser shavings? #shorts | Stationery Pal0:26
    How did you clean up the eraser shavings? #shorts | Stationery Pal
    invidious
    154 views
    Thumbnail for Meet Congress' Favorite Bootlegger: Prohibition, Hypocrisy, and "The Man in the Green Hat"4:36
    Meet Congress' Favorite Bootlegger: Prohibition, Hypocrisy, and "The Man in the Green Hat"
    ReasonVids
    927 views
    Thumbnail for Introducing Reason's 2009 Webathon! Because Free Minds and Free Markets Aren't Free!1:41
    Introducing Reason's 2009 Webathon! Because Free Minds and Free Markets Aren't Free!
    ReasonVids
    774 views
    Thumbnail for Who Wants to Live Forever? Dr. Stephen Coles on the Secrets of the World's Oldest People12:20
    Who Wants to Live Forever? Dr. Stephen Coles on the Secrets of the World's Oldest People
    ReasonVids
    867 views
    Thumbnail for Russians Are Salty About Missing the Olympics2:28
    Russians Are Salty About Missing the Olympics
    bestofupgoat
    176 views
    Thumbnail for Democrats and Sleepy Joe’s Peaceful Protestors!: Black power extremists invade McDonalds in Pittsburgh cuz of rrrrrraaaacim ‘n stuff. 2:20
    Democrats and Sleepy Joe’s Peaceful Protestors!: Black power extremists invade McDonalds in Pittsburgh cuz of rrrrrraaaacim ‘n stuff.
    AOU
    1646 views
    Thumbnail for Adil C - INTHEMOOD (Official Music Video) | Adil C2:59
    Adil C - INTHEMOOD (Official Music Video) | Adil C
    invidious
    332 views
    Thumbnail for #AmericanCarnage: The Dystopian Rhetoric of Trump’s Inauguration Speech0:52
    #AmericanCarnage: The Dystopian Rhetoric of Trump’s Inauguration Speech
    ReasonVids
    918 views
    Thumbnail for Gotta love a girl who stays in shape0:09
    Gotta love a girl who stays in shape
    bestofupgoat
    241 views
    Thumbnail for Can an Undocumented Immigrant Become a U.S. Lawyer? California High Court Will Decide8:42
    Can an Undocumented Immigrant Become a U.S. Lawyer? California High Court Will Decide
    ReasonVids
    966 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle