HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

North Carolina Shelter Sues for Right to Offer Private Charity on Private Property

Views: 881
When the Catherine H. Barber Memorial Shelter applied for a zoning permit to open at a new facility in North Wilkesboro, its board of directors was confident that the town would grant the permit. After all, the building is in an ideal location, near businesses and public transit but far from residential areas, and it meets the town’s requirements for homeless shelters. They assumed they would get the permit and could then shift to renovating the space to meet their needs. But one thing they didn’t expect was the town Board of Adjustment to break its own rules—as well as state law and the Constitution—to find a reason to deny the permit.

https://ij.org/case/north-carolina-shelter-zoning/

Citing the shelter’s supposed lack of “harmony” with the community, among other reasons, on September 9, 2020, the Board of Adjustment rejected the Shelter’s application. Now, with the help of the Institute for Justice, the Barber Shelter is fighting back. Today it filed a lawsuit to the challenge the Board’s denial and stand up for the shelter’s right to use private property for private charity.

“There is not a ‘harmony exception’ to the Constitution’s protection of private property,” said Diana Simpson, an attorney at the Institute for Justice, which represents the Barber Shelter. “The Supreme Court has made it clear that when the government limits people’s property rights, it must follow the rules and have a rational reason for imposing those limitations. The Town of North Wilkesboro and its Board of Adjustment could not point to a single good reason to reject the Barber Shelter, but they denied the permit anyway. From their actions, it is clear that they just don’t want a homeless shelter anywhere.”

The Catherine H. Barber Memorial Shelter opened its doors more than three decades ago. As the only shelter in all of Wilkes County, N.C., most clients are experiencing temporary homelessness due to acute economic distress, domestic abuse, or a family breakdown. Its goal is to transition people as quickly as possible to more long-term arrangements, working with local social services agencies to help people access resources and get back on their feet.

In search of new space, the Barber Shelter was relieved when a local dentist offered to donate his 3,000 square foot office building. It is in an ideal location—in the Highway Business district, just as the zoning code requires; its immediate neighbors are a mix of non-residential uses, such as a cell-phone store and gym; it is near public transit; and the state just built new sidewalks along the road. In other words, the property completely satisfies the town’s zoning requirements.

But that is not enough for the Town of North Wilkesboro, which has taken steps in recent years to remove people in need from visibility. Until 2018, shelters were allowed without a special permit. But after getting wind that a nonprofit from a neighboring county was considering building a shelter in North Wilkesboro, the town amended its zoning code to add specific requirements for homeless shelters, including that they obtain a conditional-use permit from the town’s Board of Adjustment.

The Barber Shelter’s conditional-use-permit application objectively satisfied the zoning code’s homeless shelter ordinance. Even the Board of Adjustment agreed: “The issue here is that it meets the zoning requirements, but that doesn’t mean it belongs there,” said Board of Adjustment Chair Lisa Casey. So the Board of Adjustment came up with irrational reasons to deny the permit. One such reason? The supposed danger of the proximity of the Barber Shelter to the road and sidewalks, despite the fact that the zoning code requires shelters be next to busy roads and have sidewalks.

“All we want to do is serve our clients and our community,” said Barber Shelter Chair Elizabeth Huffman. “It isn’t right that the town is making up reasons to keep us out.”

The lawsuit asks the court to hold that the Barber Shelter’s constitutional rights are violated by the town requiring that homeless shelters obtain a conditional-use permit, even though similar uses, like drug rehabilitation facilities, don’t need one. It also argues that the Board of Adjustment violated the U.S. Constitution in denying the Barber Shelter a conditional-use permit based on irrational reasons not supported by evidence.

“The principles of this case affect Americans everywhere,” said IJ attorney Alexa Gervasi. “Allowing the Board’s decision here to stand paves the way for zoning boards to invent irrational reasons to deny any applicant their permit, regardless of their proposed use.”

In recent years, the Institute for Justice has particularly focused on the abuse of zoning laws through excessive fines and fees to deny freedom and opportunity to those of modest means. This case expands on that work.

https://ij.org/case/north-carolina-shelter-zoning/
Donate to IJ: https://ij.org/support/give-now/
@IJvidsfollow
Thumbnail for Ocheesee Creamery v. Putnam and Newton14:28
Ocheesee Creamery v. Putnam and Newton
IJvids
823 views
Thumbnail for wagging tails to go to school1:01
wagging tails to go to school
bestofupgoat
404 views
Thumbnail for How To End Poverty in the South Bronx8:25
How To End Poverty in the South Bronx
ReasonVids
861 views
Thumbnail for Starfish0:24
Starfish
bestofupgoat
312 views
Thumbnail for NY's 9/11 Memorial: When Did Honoring the Dead Become an Occassion for Fleecing the Living?2:36
NY's 9/11 Memorial: When Did Honoring the Dead Become an Occassion for Fleecing the Living?
ReasonVids
899 views
Thumbnail for If Minecraft Had Doctors 6 | ReidBoehm0:44
If Minecraft Had Doctors 6 | ReidBoehm
invidious
64 views
Thumbnail for Why Does Light Slow Down in a Medium...Or Does It? | Arvin Ash11:10
Why Does Light Slow Down in a Medium...Or Does It? | Arvin Ash
invidious
248 views
Thumbnail for Rings Of Power DESTROYED By Fans Mocking Galadriel's TERRIBLE Archery Form1:00
Rings Of Power DESTROYED By Fans Mocking Galadriel's TERRIBLE Archery Form
bestofupgoat
144 views
Thumbnail for This AI Generated Pizza Commercial is Terrifying | Asmongold Clips0:48
This AI Generated Pizza Commercial is Terrifying | Asmongold Clips
invidious
478 views
Thumbnail for Some Tough Love for Generation Z | Live From The Lair22:36
Some Tough Love for Generation Z | Live From The Lair
Terrence Popp
327 views
Thumbnail for 🔴 Hauhalla! — GOD OF WAR: RAGNAROK Livestream #13 | Krzysztof M. Maj1:00
🔴 Hauhalla! — GOD OF WAR: RAGNAROK Livestream #13 | Krzysztof M. Maj
invidious
104 views
Thumbnail for The Whitest Kids U'Know Season 1 Episode 621:52
The Whitest Kids U'Know Season 1 Episode 6
wkuk.topic
496 views
Thumbnail for Groomed for Doom | Grunt Speak Live | Terrence Popp2:47:20
Groomed for Doom | Grunt Speak Live | Terrence Popp
invidious
186 views
Thumbnail for The Freakiest Anime You'll Ever See... | Snooze7:03
The Freakiest Anime You'll Ever See... | Snooze
invidious
78 views
Thumbnail for Bring the First Amendent Into the 21st Century says Freedom of the Press Foundation's Trevor Timm8:00
Bring the First Amendent Into the 21st Century says Freedom of the Press Foundation's Trevor Timm
ReasonVids
830 views
Thumbnail for Just a beauty0:16
Just a beauty
bestofsaidit
4330 views
Thumbnail for Friday Night Trump: Locker Room Talk0:52
Friday Night Trump: Locker Room Talk
ReasonVids
876 views
Thumbnail for Bison Gores Yellowstone National Park Visitor | NBC News2:21
Bison Gores Yellowstone National Park Visitor | NBC News
bestofsaidit
384 views
Thumbnail for Did you know there are different versions of Inside Out? | This Week's Movie0:47
Did you know there are different versions of Inside Out? | This Week's Movie
invidious
342 views
Thumbnail for Trump Is Terrible on Trade. Top 2020 Dems Are No Better.4:10
Trump Is Terrible on Trade. Top 2020 Dems Are No Better.
ReasonVids
901 views

points

Permalink
Reply
north carolina, homeless, shelter, property rights, constitution
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle